<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<itemContainer xmlns="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xsi:schemaLocation="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5 http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5/omeka-xml-5-0.xsd" uri="https://projectdaps.org/items/browse?output=omeka-xml&amp;page=19&amp;sort_field=Dublin+Core%2CTitle" accessDate="2026-11-21T04:34:23+00:00">
  <miscellaneousContainer>
    <pagination>
      <pageNumber>19</pageNumber>
      <perPage>20</perPage>
      <totalResults>1839</totalResults>
    </pagination>
  </miscellaneousContainer>
  <item itemId="1658" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="1403">
        <src>https://projectdaps.org/files/original/f887041b7d5e241707ea7ea56f837c55.pdf</src>
        <authentication>2e641d2bea9e29ce72b587deab8692a9</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="52">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="16911">
                    <text>Page
Felder v. H.
Cir., 196:

United States Court of Appeals

County Board of Education, 409 F.2d 1070 (4th
12,19,22

FOR THE FOURTH CIRCUIT

Green v. Coui.'y School Board of New Kent County, 391 U.S. 430
(1963) .......................
8, 27
Green v. Sclx
Board of City of Roanoke, 316 F.Supp. 6 (W.D.
Va. 1970) ............................................
21

No. 71-1791

Haney v. Coi. .'.y Board of Education of Sevier County, 429 F.2d
364 (8th (
1970) ............................................
21

JOHN K. HART, e t a l .,

Lee v. Macon C ;nty Board of Education, 448 F.2d 746 (5th Cir.,
1971) ....................................
21

v.

Mims v. Du
C.'ounty School Board, 329 F. Supp. 123 (M.D.
Fla., 1971) ...........................................
2 3 ,2 4
Swann v. Cl
e-Mccklcnburg Board of Education, 402 U.S. 1
(1971) ...............
2, 4, 8, 9, 10, 12, 19, 22, 27
Walton v. N
F.2d 137 (:

!e, Arkansas, Special School District No. 1, 401
Cir., 1969) ................... ....................
26

Wanner v. Coi
(4th Cir..

School Board of Arlington County, 357 F.2d 452
&gt;) ...................
16

Appellants,

COUNTY SCHOOL BOARD OF
ARLINGTON COUNTY, e t a l .,
Appellees.
Appeal from the United States District Court for the
Eastern District of Virginia a t Alexandria
BRIEF FO R APPELLEES

ISSUE PRESENTED FO R REVIEW

The sole issue presented for review in this case is whether
or not the desegregation plan adopted by the Arlington
County School Board and put into effect in September,
1971, is constitutionally valid.
STA TEM EN T O F T H E CASE

On May 6, 1970, plaintiffs initiated this action to com
plete the elimination of racial segregation in the public
schools of Arlington County (App. 5 ).1An answer on behalf
1 All references App. are to pages in the printed appendix.

�2

3

of the County School Board of Arlington County and the
Division Superintendent of Schools of Arlington County
was timely filed (App. 8-9), and discovery procedures in
volving interrogatories to defendants and requests for the
production of documents were thereafter initiated by the
plaintiffs (App. 1).
On March 5, 1971, a pre-trial conference was held, at
which time a hearing on the merits was scheduled for July
26, 1971 (R. 70).2 The hearing in this case was deliberately
postponed by the District Court to await the decision of the
United States Supreme Court in Swann v. Charlotte-Meck
lenburg Board of Education, 402 U.S. 1, and its companion
cases (App. 10).
On June 28, 1971, the Arlington County School Board
adopted and filed in the District Court its plan for the estab
lishment of a unitary school system throughout the county,
which plan was to be put into effect in September, 1971
(App. 19-28). On the morning of the hearing, plaintiffs
amended their complaint to state their objections to the
plan (App. 6-7, 11), which objections were subsequently
overruled and the school board’s plan approved by the Dis
trict Court in its memorandum opinion and order of August
10, 1971 (App. 10-15). See, 329 F. Supp. 953.
On August 12, 1971, plaintiffs hied in the District Court
their notice of appeal (R. 67) and on August 20, 1971 also
hied an application for injunction pending appeal which
was denied by the District Court the same day. Thereafter,
plaintiffs hied a similar application in this Court, which
application was denied on September 3, 1971. See, Record
in No. 71-1792 (4 Cir., 1971). A further such application
was presented to the Chief Justice of the United States, as
Circuit Justice for the Fourth Circuit, and denied by him on
September 4,1971. See, No. A-262,1971 Term.

STATEM ENT O F T H E FAf ,TS

2 All references R. are to pages in the record.

The Arlington County School Division embraces the entire county of Arlington and has an a; &lt;a of 25.7 square
■City of Richmiles. It is less than one-half the size of
. and less than
mond which has an area of 63 square r.
Fairfax which
one-tenth the size of the adjacent count
has an area of 402 square miles (App. 41
For the school year 1971-72, the total ’ mentary school
be 11,233 stupopulation of the Division was estimate;
dents, of which number 9,983 were wh: and 1,250 were
ary schools was
Negro. Thus the racial ratio in the elen
89°/o white and 11% black (App. 15, 2 _ . which ratio is
substantially identical to that for the pr&lt; ding years. See,
Answers to Interrogatories (R. 19).
A t the beginning of the 1969-70 sch
year, the high
schools and junior high schools of the c&lt; tyrhad been de
segregated, while the elementary schools \.
being operated
on the basis of geographic attendance z
established for
each school. Under this arrangement, i
«f the twentynine elementary schools in the system—I
and HoffmanBoston—were attended solely by Xcgr
.dents, as the
geographical boundaries of those school
.compassed allNegro residential areas, while eleven of tl
•nty-nine were
attended by all, or virtually all, white stu
- (App. 15, 35,
■
42). The Hoffman-Boston school also ho: i seventh grade
students, of which some 70% were white icients bussed in
from other districts in the county (App.
. On December
18, 1969, the school board adopted a i 'ution directing
the Division Superintendent and his staff
prepare a staff
study of the various alternatives available { r desegregating
the Drew Elementary School (App. 29-3 . This resolution
suggested consultation with appropriate
al agencies, a
step which had already been taken by the vision Superin-

�4

o

tendent who (1) had discussed the matter generally with
representatives of the Department of Health, Education and
Welfare (HEW) earlier in the month (2) had caused data
requested by HEW to be compiled by his staff and sub
mitted and (3) was awaiting return of specific suggestions
from HEW for consideration by his staff and the school
board (App. 43). In the interim, the Division Superintend
ent directed his research department to begin its own study
of the problem in line with the school board’s resolution
(App. 43).
No response was ever received from HEW, and shortly
after the research department had assembled its own data
and begun a consideration of alternatives, the instant suit
was filed (App. 44). Thereafter, the school board was ad
vised of the pendency of the Charlotte-Mecklenburg litiga
tion which would in all probability shed light on the prob
lem the board was considering, and the board decided to
await the outcome of that litigation before determining the
method of desegregating Drew Elementary School (App.
44). No attempt was made by the plaintiffs to seek a hear
ing of this matter for the 1970-71 school year.
On April 20, 1971, the Swann case was decided. There
after the school board and its staff returned to a consider
ation of the Drew school situation, but this time did so in
the larger context of establishing a unitary school system
throughout the county in compliance with Swann (App.
44). On June 10, 1971, while these deliberations were going
on, this Court decided a series of cases under the style of
Adams v. School District No. 5, Orangeburg Co., S.C., 444
F.2d 99, specifically emphasizing for district courts and
school boards various aspects of Swann and Davis v. Board
of School Commissioners of Mobile County, 401 U.S. 33.
Some two weeks after Adams, the school board adopted and

filed in the District Court its plan
the operation of a
unitary system in Arlington County (App. 19).
As stated by the Division Supcrin . ! -nt, the purposes of
the school board’s plan were “first of a . primarily to elimi
nate all vestiges of a dual system, to . , ve to establish a true
unitary system throughout the cor. . to provide and to
establish racial balanced schools, and I think, then, to get
on with the primary purpose of the ’ ool system which is
the education of young people.” (.
. 40). These objec
tives would be accomplished by con.-. ting both the Drew
and Hoffman-Boston schools to spec '.ad pre-kindergarten
and kindergarten facilities. In addition, the Drew school
would also house an experimental r;
1 elementary school
to be conducted on an integrated b
and utilizing imagi
native new approaches to elements
iucation, as well as
for adult education and other schoi
lograms. The Hoff
man-Boston school would also be : /ed, as in previous
years, for the integrated seventh gra- ■f the Thomas Jeffer
son Junior High School (App. 10.
iO). Former Drew
and Hoffman-Boston students in
s one through six
would be assigned to other element:
hools in the county
in accordance with the following crit
App. 21):
A. The added students wouh
t cause the receiving
school to have an enrollment (
ding its established
rated capacity by more than 5^.
B. The ratio of black to wh
ipils in each school
would be as close to 11 % as pra a I, within a range of
7% to 15%, with the excepti : of four elementary
schools whose current enrolli: :it already exceeded
15% (i.c. 18% to 22%).
C. Family groupings would 1 &lt; taken into account in
•
assignments to a particular sch !. .-&gt; that family units
0
would not be broken up.
D. Transportation would be
vided as needed.

�6

7

Under the school board’s plan, all one-race schools in
Arlington County are eliminated—there remain no one-race
white schools and no one-race black schools. Moreover, stu
dents advancing from an elementary school will attend the
junior high school serving that elementary school and, in
turn, will advance to the high school serving that particu
lar junior high school (App. 20, 24). This feeder system
insures that for the 1971-72 school year, and for every school
year thereafter, every child in Arlington county will receive
his elementary and secondary education in an integrated
facility (App. 39-40). In addition, nineteen of the twentythree elementary schools affected by the plan will have racial
ratios which fall within the 7% to 15% range established
by the board as a target deviation from the 11% racial
ratio of the system as a whole (App. 15, 22). Indeed, seven
teen of these nineteen schools fall within one percent of the
11 % racial ratio in the system as a whole (App. 15). Finally,
faculty desegregation is achieved by establishing a ratio in
each school as close to the ratio of black to white teachers
in the school system as a whole, as is practical (App. 25).
In no case is there more than a 4% deviation from the sys
tem wide ratio (App. 25).
The longest bus ride (in terms of lapsed time) for the
former Drew and Hoffman-Boston pupils is 29 minutes,
while the average bus ride for such children is 22 minutes
(App. 12, 40-41). Similarly, the average bus ride for ele
mentary children in the system as a whole is also 22 minutes
(App. 41). The additional transportation costs involved in
the school board’s plan is approximately $11,000 per year.
Adoption of an alternate plan to achieve the same degree of
integration would involve busing 90% of the Drew and
HniTman-Boston students to other schools and replacing
them with an equivalent number of white students from
other schools and would entail an initial cost of $206,000

and an additional cost of $130,000 per year thereafter for
transportation. Thirteen new buses, plus drivers, would be
required for such an alternative “90 "Ut 90% in” plan
(App. 12, 45-48). See also, Brief for 0: Appellants, p. 17.
No alternate plan submitted by the
V.tiffs would elimi
nate all one-race schools in the count_. i r achieve as much
actual desegregation as the school b—.. i' s plan (App. 50,
64).
ARGUM ENT
The Desegregation Plan Adopted And 1 : Into Effect By The
Arlington County School Board Is C titutionally Valid.

Plaintiffs in the case at bar are N&lt; • children who had
been assigned to the Drew Elemen y School when this
suit was instituted and the parents or
rdians of such chil
dren. Asserting that all, or virtually al
the pupils assigned
to the Drew Elementary School \u . Negroes, plaintiffs
alleged that the Arlington County S
.! Board had failed
to adopt and execute a plan “to c
&lt; ' tely convert said
public school system to a unitary nor * ial system.” (App.
4). (Emphasis supplied.) They soul . :■ an order from the
District Court requiring the defend
school board “ta
adopt and forthwith implement” sue
plan (App. 5).
Even before this suit was filed, the school board had been
aware of the Drew situation and had,
formal resolution,
directed a staff study to be made of v ous alternatives for
desegregating the Drew School. The i &gt;olution, however,
did not specifically embrace the Ho.
oi-Boston Elemen
tary School, the only other all-Negro
.ol in the county,
nor did it envision the desegregation &lt;
• eleven all-white,
or virtually all-white, elementary sci - ols in the county
school system.
After the study contemplated by th
olution had been
initiated and prior to the date set by t: District Court for a

�8
hearing of this matter (July 26, 1971), the Supreme Court
decided the Swann and Davis cases, supra, (April 20, 1971),
and this Court decided the Adams cases, supra, (June 10,
1971). Because of the existence of Adams, no independent
analysis need now be made of Swann and Davis, nor of their
progenitors, Brown, Green and Alexander.3 In Adams, this
Court remanded a series of school desegregation cases to
their respective district courts with instructions to receive
from the various school boards “new plans” which would
give effect to Swann and Davis. Id., at 100. During the
course of its opinion, this Court spelled out what is now
required of district courts and school authorities in the fol
lowing explicit language (444 F. 2d at 100-101):
“ It is now clear, we think, that in school systems that
have previously been operated separately as to the races
by reason of state action, “the district judge or school
authorities should make every effort to achieve the
greatest possible degree of actual desegregation, taking
into account the practicalities of the situation” Davis,
supra at ...., 91 S.Ct. at 1292. We remand these cases
because the respective district judges did not have the
benefit of the Supreme Court mandate that adequate
consideration be given “to the possible use of bus trans
portation and split zoning ” Davis, supra at ..... , 91
S.Ct. at 1292. Wherever schools are “all or predomi
nately of one race in a district of mixed population
(there will be required) close scrutiny to determine
that school assignments are not part of state-enforced
segregation.” Swann, supra a t ..... , 91 S.Ct. at 1281.
Although the existence of “some small number of onerace, or virtually one-race, schools within a district is
not in and of itself the mark of a system which still
3 Brown v. Board of Education, 347 U.S. 483 (1954) 349 U.S. 294
(1955); Green v. County School Board of New K ent Comity, 391
U.S. 430 (1968); Alexander v. Holmes County Board of Education,
396 U.S. 19 (1969).

9
practices segregation by law,” Swann, supra a t ..... . 91
S.Ct. at 1281, both the school author: y and the district
judge must nevertheless be concei,i i with the elimi
nation of one-race schools.
The school authorities and the ;
consider the use of all techniques f
cluding pairing or grouping of sc!:
attendance zones, restructuring of
tramp ortation of pupils.” (Italics si

;ct court should
segregation, in
. noncontiguous
levels, and the
lied.)

Emphasizing the imperative nature of • commands itali
cized above was (1) the specific aut! ization conferred
upon district courts to employ indep lent educational
experts at the expense of any local schr jnard which sub
mitted a plan that did not comply “w die directions set
forth in this opinion . . .” and (2) the r
. ement that any
district court which approved a plan ; ! ving less actual
desegregation than would be achieved
r an alternative
plan must find facts that made imprac
c the achieving
of a greater degree of integration “espec y if there remain
any schools all or predominantly of on ice.” Id., at 101.
(Emphasis supplied.)
With the prescriptions of Swann and iris thus focused
in the commands of Adams, it was obvi&lt; :Fat any plan for
the establishment of a unitary school
cm in Arlington
County which contemplated the desc gation of Drew
School only—and which left another
mentary school
with an all-Negro student body and elev
her elementary
schools with all-white, or virtually all-v
. student bodies
—could not possibly survive judicial ap
al. If a unitary
system was to be established, all of the
mentary schools
comprising that system would have to :* considered and
.
desegregated if reasonably possible. Cor : y to appellants’

�10

11

assertion, this was not a “self-imposed objective” of the
defendant school board; it was a judicially imposed impera
tive. See, Brief for the Appellants, p. 16. The command that
the Arlington County School Board must “be concerned
with the elimination of one-race schools” could hardly be
complied with merely by passing a resolution expressing
such concern and taking no other action, especially when the
elimination of all one-race schools in the county was not only
possible, but feasible. Adams, supra, at 101.
In this setting, the school board adopted and submitted to
the District Court a plan which (1) achieved the greatest
possible degree of actual desegregation, taking into account
the practicalities of the situation (2) eliminated all one-race
schools, both white and Negro (3) insured that every child
in the Arlington school system will receive both his elemen
tary and secondary education in an integrated facility (4)
established in substantially all of the elementary schools a
student racial ratio which reflects the racial ratio of the
system as a whole (5) racially balanced the faculties in each
elementary school in the county so that the ratio of white to
black faculty members in each school is substantially the
same as the ratio of white to black faculty members in the
system as a whole and (6) established in Arlington County
a unitary school system which has neither “white” schools
nor “black” schools—just schools.
Achievement of the above stated objectives in compliance
with the prescriptions of Swann and Davis and the com
mands of Adams was possible in only two ways. One method
—that adopted by the school board—entailed the conversion
of the Drew and Hoffman-Boston schools from traditional
elementary facilities to other educational programs and the
establishment within the all-Negro geographic areas of those
schools of a series of “satellite” zones by which elementary

pupils formerly assigned to Drew and Hoffn: m-Boston
would be assigned to various all-white, or pre
:nantly
white, schools in the county in accordance \v.: i criteria
which would not only integrate every elemental
hool in
the system, but would indeed racially balance sintially
all of such schools. Bus transportation would be p vied by
the school board for all the pupils thus reassign . 704 in
number, and no such pupil would be required t
■bused
for as much as one-half hour to reach his new;/ assigned
school. Indeed, since Arlington County is only s •■ miles
•n
long and slightly more than three miles wide, t ( average
bus ride for such children would be the same as t
for ele
mentary pupils in the county generally. Care was ven to
insure that no family groups would be disturbed by -he new
plan, and a feeder system was adopted to insui
iat the
racial balance achieved in the elementary school lid be
preserved, and even heightened, over the years.
No overcrowding results under the school bo
plan,
and the additional transportation cost incurred
Id be
approximately $11,000 per year. In addition, th
. n enablcs the school board to utilize the existing i ■w and
Hoffman-Boston facilities for other innovative
i highly
desirable educational programs designed to incr ease the
already outstanding excellence of the Arlington - ml systern. In this connection, it should be emphasized that the
Drew and Hoffman-Boston schools arc not being &lt;losed or
removed from the public school system or com ited to
administrative or non-educational uses. On the
itrary,
these facilities have been reprogrammed under ; school
board’s plan to serve exclusively educational fui ' ns in
the emerging fields of pre-kindergarten instructio:
r children three and four years of age, model element: i school
experimentation in ungraded education and for .
t edu-

�12

13

cation. In this setting, appellants’ assertion that the school
board’s plan must be examined as if the Drew school was
being “used to store furniture” is surely wide of the mark.
See, Brief for the Appellants, p. 24.
Essentially the school board’s plan for establishing a uni
tary system of elementary schools in Arlington County tracks
that utilized for the junior high schools in the CharlotteMecklcnburg school system in Swann, which was subse
quently approved by this Court and the Supreme Court. As
stated by the Supreme Court (402 U.S., at 9 ):

and replacing them with an equal number of white students
drawn from the various predominantly white schools in the
county. Mathematically, such a plan would i quire (a) re
moving 102 of the 114 Negro elementary p
at HoflmanBoston, leaving 12 Negro pupils there to i i ined by 102
replacement white students from other sch&lt; i in the county
and (b) removing 530 of the 590 Negro (
ntary pupils
at Drew, leaving 60 Negro pupils there : • be joined by
530 replacement white students also cir
from other
schools throughout the county. Such a plar. (1') would sub
stantially double the amount of busing ne&lt; ary to achieve
a unitary system (2) would entail an initi; i expenditure of
$206,000 (including thirteen new buses) far the first year
and an expenditure of $130,000 per yea: ; :creafter and
(3) would, by unnecessarily continuing Dr.
nd HoffmanBoston as traditional elementary schools, ct :ve the school
board of facilities for its pre-kindergarten
. del elemen
tary school and adult education programs.
By contrast to the plans described abo1 is manifest
at a glance that neither of the plans espou
y the appel
lants in their brief even remotely appro;
&lt; compliance
with the controlling constitutional require: :s. See, Brief
for the Appellants, Appendix A. The first. . esc plans en
visions the desegregation of Drew Scho&lt; : by pairing or
clustering it with five other elementary sr . nis in the vi
cinity, and is based upon a working paper .pared by the
staff of the defendant school board pursue
lo the resolu
tion previously mentioned. While the pla : effectively de
segregates the Drew school, it falls far short
stablishing a
unitary school system in Arlington County.
tier this plan,
the elementary portion of the Hoffman-!
m school re
mains an all-Negro facility, while four otl. schools in the
county (Custis, Jamestown, Madison and
udmont) rc-

“The Finger plan for the junior high schools employed
much of the rezoning plan of the board, combined with
the creation of nine “satellite” zones. Under the satel
lite plan, inner-city Negro students were assigned by
attendance zones to nine outlying predominantly white
junior high schools, thereby substantially desegregating
every junior high school in the system.’’ (Italics sup
plied.)
In addition, the feeder system aspect of the school board’s
plan (1) counters the specific objection expressed by this
Court in Felder v. Harnett County Board of Education, 409
F. 2d 1070, 1075 (4 Cir., 1969) that the plan there under
consideration did “not eliminate the possibility that what
ever feeder system is adopted to effect this transition will not
recreate a dual system at the high school level” and (2)
further evidences the school board’s awareness of, and intent
to comply with, the teachings of the decisions of this Court
in school desegregation cases.
The only other plan which would achieve the results of
the school board’s plan and honor the prescriptions of
Swann and Davis, as well as the command of Adams, would
be one which entailed assigning 90% of the black students
in Drew and Hoffman-Boston to other schools in the county

�14

15

main all white, five other schools (Barcroft, Jackson, Nott
ingham, Page and Tuckahoe) remain 99% white and two
schools (Key and Maury) remain 98% white. Thus, twelve
of the twenty-nine elementary schools in the county would
remain one-race, or virtually one-race, schools under this
plan (App. 16, 38-39).
The appellants’ suggested plan for the desegregation of
Hoffman-Boston is even more inadequate. It is the result
of “hasty preparation” by Mr. Richardson, a witness for
the plaintiffs, and manifestly represents an effort to bring
this case within the scope of Brice v. Landis, 314 F. Supp.
974 (W.D. Cal. 1969) by attempting to show that a reason
able alternative to the school board’s plan exists. It contem
plates pairing Hoffman-Boston with three other elementary
schools in the vicinity. While effectively desegregating the
Hoffman-Boston Elementary School and the previously allwhite Custis Elementary School, it makes no provision for
the Drew school which would remain all-black, nor for ten
of the eleven all-white, or virtually all-white, elementary
schools mentioned in the preceding paragraph, which
schools would retain their 98-100% white status (App. 17,
62-63).
Moreover, utilization of both of these plans simultaneously
would not discharge the school board’s obligation to establish
a unitary system. Combination of the appellants’ suggested
plans would indeed eliminate all one-race black schools;
however over one-third (ten of twenty-nine) of the county’s
elementary schools would still remain 98-100% white. And
no racial balancing of the county’s elementary schools would
even be attempted, much less achieved. Obviously, even
if combined, the plans which appellants put forth as alter
natives to the school board’s plan (1) would not achieve
a unitary system (2) would not eliminate all one-race,

or virtually one-race, schools (3) would not achieve the
greatest possible degree of actual dese: i ration taking into
account the practicalities of the situati
mid, accordingly,
ann and Davis
would not honor the prescriptions oi
nor comply with the commands of Ad.
. It is also inter
esting to note that 1,664 pupils would be bused under
these alternative plans which do noi : et constitutional
standards, while only 704 pupils would de bused under the
school board’s plan which does meet tl
standards. If the
defendant school board had adopted bud if the appellants’
suggested alternatives, we submit that 1 would have been
1
required, as were the various school bo ,ds in Adams, to
prepare a “new” plan which wouki “ 1 effect to Swann
and Davis” by according adequate con-1 ation to the “use
of bus transportation and split zoning. ' Adams, supra, at
100- 101.
In light of the legal deficiencies in the .
Hants’ suggested
alternatives and the demonstrated dra&gt; . rks of the “90%
out 90% in” plan, it is difficult to co due how the plan
adopted by the school board can be s. i d to be invidiously
discriminatory. In this connection, c&lt; udn aspects of the
case at bar must be emphasized. First diis case does not
involve the closing of any school, mer
he conversion of
facilities from one type of educational
t ram to another.
Second, this case does not involve even;
gestion of “white
flight,” and neither that term nor th. t concept was ever
mentioned by any party at any point i n diese proceedings.
Third, this case does not involve any rt 1 wnce on the part
of the school board to assign and bus kite children to
formerly all-black schools located in aid r predominantly,
Negro neighborhoods. On the contrary , the record discloses
that a majority (70%) of white stud i ts have for years
been transported to the formerly all-bin..:; Hoffman-Boston

�16

17

Junior High School (Jefferson Annex) located in that com
pletely Negro residential area (App. 42). See, Wanner v.
County School Board of Arlington County, 357 F. 2d 452,
456 (4 Cir., 1966). Moreover, the plan adopted by the
School Board envisioned the enrollment of a majority of
white students in the model elementary school to be housed
in the converted Drew facility which is located in an allNegro residential area, and that feature of the school board’s
plan is even now in effect. See, Brief for the Appellants, p. 7.
Significant in this context, is the decision of this Court in
Chambers v. Iredell County Board of Education, 423 F.2d
613 (4th Cir., 1970). Under consideration in that case was a
school desegregation plan in which one school, Unity School,
remained all black with 285 students. That facility was to be
replaced the following school year by a new school which
was then under construction. When completed, the new
facility would absorb Unity’s 285 black students and some
475 white students from three other schools, at which time
the formerly all-black Unity School would be closed. Plain
tiffs there alleged that the decision to close Unity was racially
motivated “because it arose out of a disinclination to put
white pupils into a previously all-black school.” Id., at 616.
Rejecting this contention, this Court stated (423 F.2d at
616):

school is not indicative of racial motivation when a school
board has integrated another previously all-.
:: school in
the same system, then the mere conversion &lt; a previously
all-black school to a different educational p
am and the
enrollment of a majority of white students in that identical
facility, coupled with the previous assignment &lt; a majority
-f
of white students to another formerly all-bla. school, can
not be said to be racially motivated.
Even more nearly in point and controllin: - the decision
of this Court in Allen V. Asheville City Boa*
Education,
434 F.2d 902 (4th Cir., 1970). In that ca&gt; . he Asheville
School Board decided that it was ncccssa: y to close two
formerly all-black elementary schools and on formerly allwhite elementary school to achieve racial . ounce. After
plaintiffs objected to the proposed plan on ! basis of the
closing of the two all-black schools, the sch 1 toard modi
fied the plan to provide for the continued &lt; : tion of the
formerly all-white school, with the two fo1 y all-black
schools remaining dosed. During the court
its opinion,
this Court stated the plaintiffs’ objection to t h plan and the
reason therefore in the following language ( 1 . i F.2d at 905,
906):

“This contention is not persuasive in light of the fact
that the school board has already integrated Amity
School, which was previously all-black and is now twothirds white. There appears to be no pattern of simply
closing black schools because they have been black.”
Similarly, in the case at bar, the Arlington County School
Board long ago integrated the Hoffman-Boston Junior High
School “which was previously all-black and is now twothirds white.” We submit that if the closing of an all-black

“Able counsel for plaintiffs are unal ‘ - to fault the
Board’s plan other than a complaint wii i expect to the
closing of two previously all-black sclu
and the im
pact of their closing, in the context of : a rest of the
plan, upon black students.
* *
*
“Plaintiffs insist, however, that the sch i : board’s true
reason for selection is undisclosed and is imply its ‘re
luctance to send primary grade white children into
traditionally all-black schools located in . black neigh
borhoods.’ ”

�18

19

Rejecting plaintiffs’ contention that the Asheville School
Board had unfairly discriminated against black students in
the closing of the two schools there in question, this Court
enunciated the following principles governing such situ
ations (434 F.2d at 905, 906):

elementary schools, or if they were recou- tituted as such, 90
pcrcent of the black students formerly in •?ach school would
have to be moved out into other schools ; ; .1 this 90 percent
replaced by white students. Moreover, •’ ; purpose of the
implement the
school board’s plan here is not merely
Brown I I principle, but also to implem :nt Swann, Davis
and Adams. That the plan “effectively
ieves that end”
is acknowledged even by the appellant ■ c, Brief for the
Appellants, p. 19. In addition, the schoi
a rd ’s plan is the
plan that will
only demonstrably rational and praci
comply with the requirements of Swann. .Oavis and Adams.
'
In Chambers, this Court expressed &lt; mbt that many
school systems had achieved a higher c: ee of integration
than then prevailed in Iredell Count . Subsequently, in
Allen, this Court stated that Asheville v ■ “at or near the
pinnacle of arithmetical desegregation i America.” Id., at
903. So far as we are aware, Asheville ; ill near the pincrica: however,
nacle of arithmetical desegregation in
.1 desegregation
we submit that at the pinnacle of arithm
in America is Arlington County. Here
in, it should be
pointed out that this distinction was ach
i without closing
any school, while in the Chambers and
n cases, the all
black facilities there under considcratioi. ure selected “for
extinction” and were removed from the
:c school system.
upra, at 905.
Allen v. Asheville City Board of Educati
None of the cases relied upon by ay; Hants derogates
.ibers and Allen
from the principles enunciated in the (
cases. In Felder v. Harnett County B nd of Education,
supra, the basis of this Court’s decision was the complete
failure of the school board to discstalA . an entrenched
dual school system in which only 4.3% « ’ e black children
were attending previously all white sc'
s. Moreover, in
that case there was not the slightest ass : . ice of achieving

In the first place, we think the mechanics of integra
tion, where the purpose is obviously to implement the
Brown I I principle and effectively achieves that end, is
ordinarily a matter within the discretion of school ad
ministrators. The question is no(whether we might have
selected different schools for extinction, nor even
whether substantial evidence supports the Board’s deci
sion, but is instead whether the Board’s decision is so
plainly unfair that it clearly amounts to invidious dis
crimination in violation of the equal protection clause.
■X*

#

"A
*

.. . Moreover, the situation of which plaintiffs complain
cannot possibly be changed except at the cost of in
creasing the transportation of pupils approximately 40
percent. This is so because if the two black schools that
have been closed were reopened, 70 percent of the black
students formerly in each school would have to be
moved out into other schools and this 70 percent re
placed by white students.
*

*

*

It is urged upon us that even so, both schools that
were closed are newer and physically better than most
of the other schools retained. We agree that this is a
relevant factor. But neither alone nor in context docs it
establish invidious discrimination. Such a factor is only
one of many that enter into a school closing decision.
We repeat that we do not sit to review state adminis
trative decisions beyond the very limited reach of the
Constitution. (Italics supplied.)
Similarly, in the case at bar, as previously pointed out, if
Drew and Hoffman-Boston had been retained as traditional

�20
a unitary school system and the selection of the schools for
closing was therefore suspect. See, Allen, supra at 906.
In Green v. School Board of City of Roanoke, 316 F.
Supp. 6 (W.D. Va. 1970), the closing of the formerly all
black high school there under consideration would have
caused overcrowding in the three remaining predominantly
white high schools in the city. In the face of this circum
stance, no adequate reason was advanced by the school
board, in terms of its desegregation plan or otherwise, to
justify discontinuance of the school in question.
Brice v. Landis, 314 F. Supp. 974 (N.D. Cal. 1969) states
nothing to the contrary. In that case, the closing of a 99%
black school, pursuant to the school board’s plan would have
resulted in overcrowded classes and distorted pupil-teacher
ratios at the three remaining predominantly white schools
in the system. Id., at 977. Other “options, alternatives and
courses of action” were available to the school board. Id., at
978. Pointing out that a particular desegregation plan “when
not reasonably required under the circumstances” could be
discriminatory, the District Court observed (314 F. Supp. at
978):
“Whether the plan, as here presented, is a good faith,
reasonably adequate implementation of constitutional
principles involved, must be determined in the light,
among other things, of the alternative options and
courses of action available to the District.” (Italics
supplied.)
Commenting upon this decision in Allen, supra, this Court
succinctly stated (434 F.2d at 907):
“We are advertent to Brice v. Landis (N.D. Cal.,
Aug. 8, 1969), 314 F.Supp. 974, which held on the
peculiar facts of the case that the closing of a Negro
school was invidiously discriminatory and subject to in-

21

junction. We think it means no more than that and
agree there may be such a case. ! it think it is not this
one. If it is read to imply that
is ordinarily for the
district courts to determine whit k rhools shall be closed
rather than for the school boatd, ne reject the propo
sition.” (Italics supplied.)
Even less apposite is Lee v. Mact . b ounty Board of Edu
cation, 448 F. 2d 746 (5 Cir., 1971
. that case, the Court
of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit r
ed a decree of the
district court which would have 1
ac effect of leaving
over 45% of the school district’s Nc
,'tudents in all-black,
or virtually all-black, schools. Id.,
748, 753. Moreover,
the justification advanced by the s&lt; ■ board for the pro
!
posed closing of two formerly all-bl 1 schools was (1) that
whites would resist going to school
&lt;ilitics formerly used
by blacks, and (2) that otherwise v.! &lt; students would flee
■
750, 754. In light of
the school system altogether. Id.,
these circumstances, the Court of .
als directed the dis
trict court to require the school bo.
"forthwith to consti
tute and implement a student assign
u plan that complies
with the principles established in S:
■v. Charlotte-Mecklenburg Board of Education.” Id., . 53. In short, Lee is a
school closing, racially motivated, v te-flight, non-unitary,
non-Swann school desegregation ca . Not one of the abovelisted considerations obtains in the e. at bar.
Haney v. County Board of Edit- ■■ of Sevier County,
''on
429 F. 2d 364 (8 Cir., 1970) is cqu.
inapplicable. In that
case, the district court decreed the ;
xation of a small all
black school district in the count y a larger all-white
school district and, in addition, d
ed that the facilities
of the larger all-white school distri
uld be utilized and,
only if these facilities proved inadeo
. would those of the
formerly all-Negro district be used.
re was nothing in the
record to explain the closing of th
lities formerly used

�22
for the instruction of black students. After referring to this
Court’s decision in the Felder case and Brice v. Landis,
supra, the Court of Appeals observed (429 F.2d at 372):
“The matter of utilization of available facilities is with
in the province and discretion of the school board.
There is a statement in the record that the class rooms
of the former Sevier District are not of sufficient size to
meet current state standards. These details, of course,
are subject to many variations and much can be done
within the existing framework of operation to suffi
ciently utilize existing facilities. This is not a matter for
court consideration but rather should be resolved on
some rational non-discriminatory basis by the local
school board.” (Italics supplied.)
Throughout their briefs, both appellants and amici curiae
make only glancing references to Swann, pay no respect to
Adams and do not even mention Davis at all. Indeed, refer
ence is made to Adams only for its one line affirmance of
the district court’s retention of the Addison School in Roan
oke; so far as appellants and amici are concerned, the rest
of what this Court said in Adams does not even exist. Thus
do they seek to avoid any consideration whatever of the
school board’s clear obligation to eliminate one-race schools
and achieve the greatest possible degree of actual desegre
gation as required by Swann, Davis and Adams. Thus, too,
do they seek to insinuate that the school board in this case
can get by with something less than full compliance with the
commands of these decisions, even though full compliance
can be had, as demonstrated by the plan which the school
board adopted and put into effect last September and which
this Court and the Chief Justice of the United States refused
to enjoin.
In addition, both appellants and amici persist in pressing
the illusion that there “may” be other plans which would

23
meet the prescribed constitutional standards. See Brief for
the Appellants, p. 17; Brief for Amici Curi, ■ p. 16. How
.
ever, both are careful to avoid stating that the- o “is” such a
plan or informing this Court of the detain. or even the
outlines, of such other plan. The reason for 17 equivocation
is quite obvious—both appellants and amici k : w full well
that there is no plan other than that adopt■ y the school
board which rationally and practically acr
dishes what
this Court said in Adams must be done.
The assertion that the school board’s pi:
fairly bur
dens the Negro students of Drew and Hoff : Boston will
not bear scrutiny. For years pupils at the
chools have
attended a “walk-in” facility and have not i • • o required to
.
be bused (App. 48-49). If attendance at . ‘walk-in” fa
cility can be deemed a convenience, it is ;
which these
students have enjoyed for years while tht
ds of other
children in Arlington County have been b:
(App. 13).
To require them at this late date to forego
onvcnicnce
so that a racially balanced, unitary schot
em can be
established can hardly be considered unfai . iiis, we sub
mit, is especially true when one remembers
he bus ride
they arc asked to take is, on the average, 1
ten minutes
longer than the time it would take them
walk to the
Drew and Hoffman-Boston facilities, and t:
ilk to those
facilities had to be made in all weather cor ■ &gt;ns through
out the school year (App. 39). Finally, wh i i d i e Drew and
Hoffman-Boston students arc now bused w her schools,
over 40% of the Negro elementary studr - in Arlington
County still attend their neighborhood scl
(App. 15).
In Allen, a similar contention was reject
y this Court
in language subsequendy deemed contrnllii
1 quoted at
length in Mims v. Duval County School Bot
’29 F. Supp.
123 (M.D. Fla., 1971). In Mims, approving , i segregation

�24
plan which involved the closing of seven black elementary
schools, the district court observed (329 F. Supp. at 132133):
“In their second argument plaintiffs seek to have this
Court require the School Board to bus white children
to the core city for all elementary grades, not just to
sixth grade centers, so to achieve equal busing of the
races. The United States Court of Appeals for the
Fourth Circuit resolved the same argument in Allen v.
Asheville City Board of Education [434 F.2d 902, 907
(4 Cir., 1970)] with these words:
We are asked to decide whether the district court, in
approving the plan, unconstitutionally placed ‘the
burden of desegregation’ upon black pupils in the
school system. It is urged upon us that the plan ap
proved by the district court ‘places an unfair, racially
discriminatory burden upon black children’ in that
black children in grades 1 through 5 who previously
attended all-black Livingston and Herring Elemen
tary Schools will be required to travel as much as five
or six miles in order to attend previously all-white
schools. This is said to be an unfair allocation of the
‘burden’ of integration, and it is suggested that the
Constitution requires that an equivalent number or
proportion of white children in the same grades be
required to travel an equivalent distance to enter
schools outside their previous attendance zones.
Wc hold that such a pattern of assignment imple
mented by free school bus transportation does not
violate the equal protection clause of the Fourteenth
Amendment.
The rationale in the Second Circuit is essentially the
same. In Norwalk Core v. Norwalk Board of Education,
[423 F.2d 121, 124 (2 Cir., 1970)] the Court noted:
Plaintiffs would eliminate what they call unequal
treatment by having, in effect, one white child bussed

25
out of his neighborhood for every black child bussed
out of his—in other words, deprive as many whites of
neighborhood advantages as bla s are deprived by
being bussed to schools predomi: :. ly white. But the
problem is not as simple as a &gt;. black, one white
ratio. It is a question of the Boa o . with the facilities
available having ‘acted in the u:
: good faith, in a
nonarbitrary and deliberate ma; r, in order both to
insure racial balance and to ;■ ;de high quality
education.’ * * *”
Nor will it do to assert that the sell 1 board's plan sug
gests to black children that it would be
.gcrous if “blacks
make up more than 15% of the enrol tit of any school.”
See, Brief for the Appellants, p. 15. T h: .- rtion is instantly
blunted by the fact that four element; y schools in Arling
ton County already had black studer ii excess of 15%
when the school board’s plan was ado d. Moreover, the
alternative arrangements for the Drr\
ool espoused in
plaintiffs’ brief would limit black enrol
to 21% in each
of the schools affected. Does this arra:
:ent suggest that
any number of black students in excess ■ i % in any school
is dangerous? Was any such message ;
it or implicit in
the racially balanced plans approve : y this Court in
Chambers and Allcn'l Neither, we sir, , it, dries the plan
adopted by the school board in the ca at bar carry such
an inference.
It is, of course, primarily the obligati; .
the school board
to frame and put into effect a plan wl
establishes a uni
tary school system, and, as pointed out
&gt;airis, supra at 37,
the “measure of any desegregation pla : its effectiveness.”
From Brown II to Adams, the dcci
confirming this
principle have been legion and r&lt; iw-tr:
- stated in Brad
ley v. School Board of City of III I: mot
:5 T. Supp. 828.
832-833 (E.D.Va. 1971):

�26
“A second principle guiding the Court—almost as ob
vious as the doctrine of precedent—is that it is primarily
the School Board’s duty to run the schools, and not this
Court’s nor the plaintiffs’ . . . Because both expertise
and responsibility are the School Board’s, it is to their
proposals that courts look first for a legally sufficient
plan. . . . When they assume the ‘responsibility which
Brown II placed squarely on the School Board,’ Id.,
442, 88 S. Ct. 1696, courts will not presume to dictate a
selection between equally effective desegregation
plans.” Wanner v. County School Board of Arlington
County, 357 F. 2d 452, 436 (4th Cir. 1966). (Italics
supplied.)
Echoing these observations are those of Judge Bryan in his
special concurring opinion in Adams, supra, at 102:
" . . . I think the only pattern the school authorities and
the Courts must observe is one honoring the prescrip
tions of Swann and Davis. So long as it is in keeping
with these decisions, my understanding is that formu
lation of a plan is entrusted to the discretion of the
school authorities. . . ” (Italics supplied.)
We submit that in the case at bar the obligation resting upon
the Arlington County School Board has been fully dis
charged by the adoption of a desegregation plan which
honors the prescriptions of Swann and Davis, complies with
the commands of Adams, and is therefore constitutionally
valid.
CONCLUSION

In Walton v. Nashville, Arkansas, Special School District
No. 1, 401 F. 2d 137, 144 (8 Cir., 1969), Judge Blackmun,
speaking for a court which sustained the non-reemployment
of certain Negro teachers in a school desegregation case,
made the following observations:

27
“We are conscious in this case, as we have been in
earlier ones, that the process of sc hool integration is not
easy and that there will be hurts and disappointments
as integration is accomplished. Certainly, under the
precepts of the Brown clecisi
it has been too long
delayed at Nashville. But we w told that it has now
been fully accomplished liter, . That fact should be a
source of satisfaction for all &lt; ns, white as well as
black.” (Italics supplied.)
In the case at bar, this Court is ; . &gt;informed that inte
gration has now been fully accompi 1d in Arlington Coun
ty. It is so informed by the plan
f, which is currently
before this Court and was adopted i carry out the following
policy of the school board (App. 4 :
“The purposes that the board
1 was. first of all, pri
marily to eliminate all vesti. of a dual system, to
move to establish a true unitaiy . stem throughout the
county, to provide and to c-: ash racial balanced
schools, and I think, then, to _ in with the primary
purpose of the school system s
a is the education of
young people.”
It is similarly informed by the a'
iants who admit tha:
the plan is one “which unqurstion
docs away with the
last vestiges of school segregation r
lining from the legis
latively imposed dual school systc:, and who further ac
knowledge that it “is undisputed t- the Arlington School
Board has put into effect a plan th:
illy complies with the
primary mandates laid down in” E : n, Green and Swann.
See, Brief for the Appellants, pp. 1.1.
Finally, this Court is so inf umed
'he District Court in
the following language of its opinb
. 29 F. Supp. at 955956 (App. 14):
“The Arlington Conn's Scl
complied with the Sun ; (

Hoard has now fully
decision in Brown I

�28
—A unitary school system as required by Green and
Alexander has been established—Arlington will have
neither black nor white schools—just schools.”
In light of the foregoing, and for the reason heretofore
stated, we submit that the decision of the Distirct Court is
clearly correct and should be affirmed.
Respectfully submitted,
J a m e s H. Sim m o n d s
G r e g o r y U. E v a n s

1500 North Courthouse Road
Arlington, Virginia
R. D . M c I lw a in e , I I I

P.O. Box 705
Petersburg, Virginia
Counsel for Appellees
CERTIFICATE

I certify that two copies of the within brief for appellees
were mailed, with first class postage prepaid, to S. W.
Tucker, Esquire, 214 East Clay Street, Richmond, Virginia
23219; to Robert M. Alexander, Esquire, 2011'South Glebe
Road, Arlington, Virginia 22204; to Allison W. Brown, Jr.,
Esquire, Suite 501, 1424 Sixteenth Street, N.W., Washing
ton, D.C. 20036; to Lawrence J. Latto, Esquire, 734 Fif
teenth Street, N.W., Washington, D.C. 20005; and to Jack
Greenburg, Esquire, Suite 2030, 10 Columbus Circle, New
York, New York 10010, counsel for plaintiffs; and to William
H. Allen, Esquire, and John B. Jones, Jr., Esquire, 888 Six
teenth Street, N.W., Washington, D.C. 20006, counsel for
amici curiae, this 10th day of March, 1972.
R. D. M c I l

w a in e

, III

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="10">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="2122">
                  <text>RG 18: Personal Papers of Barbara Marx</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="16903">
                <text>Copy of John K. Hart, et al vs. County School Board of Arlington County, Virginia, et al, Brief for Appellees, March 10, 1972.  15 pages.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="16904">
                <text>Copy of John K. Hart, et al vs. County School Board of Arlington county, Virginia, et al, Brief for Appellees, March 10, 1972.  </text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="42">
            <name>Format</name>
            <description>The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="16905">
                <text>PDF</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="48">
            <name>Source</name>
            <description>A related resource from which the described resource is derived</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="16906">
                <text>RG 18</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="39">
            <name>Creator</name>
            <description>An entity primarily responsible for making the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="16907">
                <text>Counsel for Appellees</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="16908">
                <text>1972-03-10</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="38">
            <name>Coverage</name>
            <description>The spatial or temporal topic of the resource, the spatial applicability of the resource, or the jurisdiction under which the resource is relevant</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="16909">
                <text>1970s</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="47">
            <name>Rights</name>
            <description>Information about rights held in and over the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="16910">
                <text>This image is subject to copyright. Unauthorized use of the images in the Local History Collections of the Arlington Community Archives is prohibited.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="43">
            <name>Identifier</name>
            <description>An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="22010">
                <text>18_2_1_16_28</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="1661" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="1406">
        <src>https://projectdaps.org/files/original/1c1cc55d87d7074e092850f5a6a4c1f4.pdf</src>
        <authentication>c883f73983e924692221b2b218df19e3</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="52">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="16941">
                    <text>IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEAIS
FOR THE FOURTH CIRCUIT

JOHN K . HART, e t a l . ,
P l a i n t I f f s -A p p e H a n t s ,
v.
COUNTY SCHOOL BOARD OF ARLINGTON
COUNTY, V IR G IN IA , e t a l . ,
D e fe n d a n ts - A p p e lle e s .

ON APPEAL FROM THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE EASTERN D ISTRICT OF VIRGINIA

BRIEF FOR CERTAIN ARLINGTON ORGANIZATIONS AS AMICI CURIAE

A m ic i O r g a n i z a t i o n s :

WILLIAM H . ALLEN
JOHN B . JONES, J r .

ARLINGTON COUNCIL ON HUMAN RELATIONS
ARLINGTON EDUCATION ASSOCIATION
C o v i n g to n &amp; B u r l i n g
ARLINGTON HEALTH AND WELFARE COUNCIL
8 8 8 1 6 t h S t r e e t , N.W.
ARLINGTON VIEW CIVIC ASSOCIATION
W a s h in g t o n , D .C . 2 0 0 0 6
LEAGUE OF WOMEN VOTERS OF ARLINGTON
NAUCK CIVIC ASSOCIATION
A t t o r n e y s f o r A m ic i C u r i a e
NORTHERN VIRGINIA CENTER FOR SOCIAL
DEVELOPMENT ( f o u r p a r i s h e s ) :
OUR LADY OF LOURDES
OUR LADY QUEEN OF PEACE
S T . ANN'S
S T . CHARLES
NORTHERN VIRGINIA CHAPTER OF THE AMEPICAN
C IV IL LIBERTIES UNION OF VIRGINIA
PO SITIV E ACTION COMMITTEE FOR EDUCATION
ROCK SPRING CONGREGATIONAL CHURCH BOARD
OF SOCIAL ACTION
"SUPPORT CHRISTIAN ACTION" HOUSE OF THE
LITTLE FA LIS PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH

�TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
STATEMENT

3

ARGUMENT
THE ARLINGTON COUNTY SCHOOL BOARD'S PLAN FOR
DESEGREGATING THE COUNTY'S SCHOOLS DENIES TO THE
STUDENTS OF THE FORMER DREW AND HOFFMAN-BOSTON
ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS THE EQUAL PROTECTION OF THE
LAWS BECAUSE IT LAYS UPON THEM THE ENTIRE BURDEN
OF DESEGREGATION BY ELIMINATING DREW AND HOFFMANBOSTON AS ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS AND REQUIRING THE
STUDENTS TO BE TRANSPORTED BY BUS TO SCHOOIB
THROUGHOUT THE COUNTY WHILE NO WHITE CHILDREN
ARE INVOLUNTARILY TRANSPORTED TO SCHOOIS OUT
SID E THEIR NORMAL, NEIGHBORHOOD ATTENDANCE AREAS. . . . .
A.

12

The F a c ts D e m o n s tra te th e I n v id io u s
D i s c r i m i n a t i o n A g a in s t B la c k C h ild r e n
E f f e c t e d b y t h e S c h o o l B o a r d 's P l a n .............................................

15

D e c is io n s o f T h is C o u rt a n d O th e r C o u r ts
E s ta b lis h th e U n c o n s titu tio n a lity o f th e
A r l i n g t o n S c h o o l B o a r d 's D e s e g r e g a t i o n P l a n ......................

17

T he F a c t t h a t th e S c h o o l
s u l t s i n A r l i n g t o n 's N ot
S c h o o l s D o es N o t J u s t i f y
I t W orks A g a i n s t B l a c k C

B o a r d 's P l a n R e
H a v in g A ny O n e -R a c e
th e D is c rim in a tio n
h i l d r e n .......................................................

24

CONCLUSION...................................................................................................................................

26

B.

C.

INDEX TO AUTHORITIES
Cases:
A dam s v . S c h o o l D i s t r i c t N o. 5 , 4 4 4 F . 2 d 9 9 ( 4 t h C i r . 197
c e r t '. " d e n i e d , 4 0 4 u T 5 T ~ 9 l2 ( 1 9 7 1 ) ..........................................
A l l e n v . A s h e v i l l e C i t y B o a rd o f E d u c a t i o n , 4 3 4 F . 2 d 902
(4 th C ir . 1970) . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .

20

B e l l v . W est P o i n t M u n ic ip a l S e p a r a te S c h o o l D i s t r i c t ,
4 4 6 " F ;~ d " " i3 6 5 ( 5 t h ' C i r . l '9 7 l ) . .

22

�ii

Table of Contents Continued
Page

B ric e v .

L a n d i s , 3 1 4 F . S u p p . 9 7 4 (N .D . C a l . 1 9 6 9 )

B r o o k s v . C o u n ty S c h o o l B o a r d , 3 2 4 F . 2 d 3 0 3

21

(4 th C ir . 1963)

•

6

-.— -7 .........................................................................

6

B r o o k s v . C o u n ty S c h o o l B o a r d , 2 0 4 F . S u p p . 6 2 0 (E .D . V a .

--------- T962) — . . . . . .

B row n v . B o a rd o f E d u c a t i o n , 3 4 7 U.S. 4 8 3

(1 9 5 4 )

3,

B row n v . B o a rd o f E d u c a t i o n , 3 4 9 U .S . 2 9 4 ( 1 9 5 5 ) ...........................
C a r r v . M o n tg o m e ry C o u n ty B o a rd o f E d u c a t i o n , 4 2 9 F . 2 d
3 8 2 ( 5 t h C i r . 1970")......
C h a m b e rs v .

. . .

5
4
22

I r e d e l l C o u n ty B o a rd o f E d u c a t i o n , 4 2 3 F . 2 d

--------- B IT ( 4 t i m F T ~ I 9 7 T ) — ................................................

21

C h o c ta w C o u n ty B o a rd o f E d u c a t i o n v . U n i t e d S t a t e s ,
4T 7 F . 2 d b 4 5 ( 5 t h C i r . 1 9 b 9 ) ...............................................................
F e l d e r v . H a r n e t t C o u n ty B o a rd o f E d u c a t i o n , 4 0 9 F . 2 d
T 0 7 0 ( 4 'th C i r 7 1 9 6 9 ) ............................ . . ..........................................

20

G o rd o n v . J e f f e r s o n D a v is P a r i s h S c h o o l D i s t r i c t , 4 4 6
F . 2 d 2 6 6 ( 5 t h C i r . 1 9 7 1 ) .......................................... ...............................

22

G re e n v . S c h o o l B o a r d , 3 1 6 F . S u p p . 6 (W .D . V a . 1 9 7 0 )

• l8 .

1 9 , 20
26

Hamm v . C o u n ty S c h o o l B o a r d , 263 F . 2 d 2 2 6

(4 th C ir. 1959)

•

6

Hamm v . C o u n ty S c h o o l B o a r d , 2 6 4 F . 2 d 9 4 5

(4 th C ir .

•

6

1959)

H a n e y v . C o u n ty B o a rd o f E d u c a t i o n , 4 2 9 F . 2 d 3 6 4 ( 8 t h C i r .

1970-]—

7

— .................................. ........................

.

23

L ee v . M acon C o u n ty B o a rd o f E d u c a t i o n , 4 4 8 F . 2 d 7 4 6
(5th c i r . 1 9 7 1 )
. .........................................................................................

12 , 21

Mims v . D u v a l C o u n ty S c h o o l B o a r d , 4 4 7 F . 2 d 1 3 3 0
(5 tE " ~ C ir. 1 9 7 1 )— . ". '. . ’. ....................................................................

22

S c h o o l B o a rd o f C h a r l o t t e s v i l l e v . A l l e n , 2 4 0 F . 2 d 5 9
( 4 t h C i r . 1 9 5 b ) , c e r t , d e n i e d , 3 5 3 U .S . 9 1 1 ( 1 9 5 7 )

• *

5

�iii

Table o f C ontents Continued
Page

Swann v. Charlotte-Mecklenburg Board of Education,

------- ’ 02 U.5Y T (1971)
4

'...................... 8, 18

Thompson v. County School Board, 144 F. Supp. 239 (E.D.
Va“ 195 F)

5

Thompson v. County School Board, 159 F. Supp, 567 (E.D.
Va7 195?)""aff'd, 252 F.2d 929 (4th Cir. 1958), cert.
denied, 358 U.S . 958 (1 9 5 8 ) ................. ~

g

Thompson v. CountySchool Board, 166 F. Supp. 529 (e
T
)
vaT 195^)
. . . . . . ................... . .'

’ •

Wanner v. County School Board, 245 F. Supp. 132 (E.n m,
1965)
”— r : . .........
.
a*
■*
Wanner v. County School Board, 357 F.2d 452 (4th Cir. 1 9 6 6 )
Yick Wo v. Hopkins, 118 U.S. 356 ( 1 8 8 6 ) ........ 12

,

0

7

5

14,24

3

14,23

Constitution:
United States Constitution, l4th Amendment . . . .

11

Other:
Muse, Virginia's Massive Resistance (1 9 6 1 ) . .

4

�IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE FOURTH CIRCUIT

No. 71-1791

JOHN K. HART, e t a l . .
P la in t i f f s - A p p e lla n t s ,

COUNTY SCHOOL BOARD OF ARLINGTON
COUNTY, VIRGINIA, et al.,
Defendants-Appellees.

O APPEAL FROM THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
N
FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF VIRGINIA

BRIEF FOR CERTAIN ARLINGTON ORGANIZATIONS AS AMICI CURIAE

The a m ici cu ria e on whose b e h a lf t h is b r ie f

is file d

1
/

are groups and o r g a n iz a tio n s made up e x c lu s iv e ly

1 / A rlin g to n C oun cil on Human R e la tio n s; A rlin g to n
E ducation A s s o c ia tio n ; A rlin gton H ealth and W elfare C o u n cil;
A rlin g to n View C iv ic A s so c ia tio n ; League o f Women V o ters o f
A r lin g to n ; Nauck C iv ic A sso c ia tio n ; fo u r member p a r ish e s o f
th e N orthern V ir g in ia Center fo r S o c ia l Development —
Our Lady o f Lourdes, Our Lady Queen o f P ea ce, S t . Ann's
and S t . C harles; N orthern V ir g in ia Chapter o f th e American
C iv il L ib e r t ie s Union o f V ir g in ia ; P o s it iv e A ctio n Committee
f o r E d ucation; Rock S pring C ongregation al Church Board o f
S o c ia l A c tio n , and "Support C h r istia n A ction" House o f th e
L i t t l e F a lls P re sb y te ria n Church.

�2

o r in major p a rt o f r e s id e n ts o f A rlin g to n County th a t are

concerned w ith is s u e s o f p u b lic p o lic y a f f e c t in g th e
q u a lit y o f l i f e in A rlin g to n County, in c lu d in g i t s
e d u c a tio n a l system .

They b e lie v e th a t in i t s p lan fo r

e lim in a t in g d e se g r e g a tio n in A r lin g to n 's elem entary sc h o o ls
th e A rlin g to n

County S ch ool Board has tr e a te d a group

o f b la ck c h ild r e n (and t h e ir p a ren ts) u n f a ir ly .
By way o f fu r th e r in tr o d u c tio n we add on ly
th is :

By th e tim e t h is b r ie f i s f i l e d , a f u l l academ ic

sem ester w i l l have been com pleted under th e A r lin g to n County
S ch ool B oard's p la n th a t i s ch a llen g ed h e r e .

In th a t

p erio d th e S ch ool B oard's d e c is io n th a t alm ost a l l the
b la c k c h ild r e n who had been a tte n d in g Drew Elem entary
S ch o o l and Hoffman-Boston Elem entary S ch o o l must be t r a n s
p orted by bus t o oth er elem entary sc h o o ls throughout the
County has been ca r r ie d out am icably and w ith good w i l l on
a l l s id e s .

Most o f th o se who are re p resen ted on t h i s b r ie f

by membership in one or more o f th e a m ici o r g a n iz a tio n s
a re w h ite ; many o f them are p aren ts o f c h ild r e n a tte n d in g
th e p u b lic s c h o o ls ; and many o f th e se p a ren ts have been
d e lig h te d to have th e l i v e s o f t h e ir c h ild r e n en rich ed by
t h e ir a tten d an ce a t in te g r a te d sc h o o ls — some f o r th e

�- 3 -

f i r s t tim e .

These w h ite p aren ts n e v e r th e le s s remain

|o f th e view th a t th e b e n e f it s t h e ir c h ild r e n r e a liz e
I from s c h o o l in t e g r a t io n cannot r i g h t ly be had a t th e
expense o f th e b la c k c h ild r e n who* a lo n e among
A rlin g to n p u b lic s c h o o l s tu d e n ts , are made t o t r a v e l
t o sc h o o ls f a r from t h e ir homes.
STATEMENT
T his ca se concerns th e com p letion o f th e
d e se g r e g a tio n o f th e p u b lic sc h o o ls o f A rlin g to n
County more than 17 y ea rs a f t e r th e d e c is io n in Brown
v . Board o f E d u cation , 347 U .S. 483 (1 9 5 4 ).

The slow

pace o f d e se g r e g a tio n in d ic a te d by the p assage o f so
many y e a r s s in c e th e f i r s t Brown d e c is io n i s th e more
d i f f i c u l t t o understand when one c o n sid e r s th a t —
1.

An ex tr a o rd in a r y wartime and p ost-w ar

growth o f p o p u la tio n brought about by i t s co n v en ien t
n ea rn ess t o th e n a tio n a l c a p it a l has l e f t A r lin g to n ,
though s t i l l n oted in some sou rce books c h i e f l y as
th e home o f th e f i r s t s o ld ie r o f th e C onfederacy, a
community whose r e s id e n ts f o r th e most p a rt have no

�- 4 -

p a r t ic u la r attachm ent to th e southern t r a d it io n o f
se p a r a te sc h o o ls f o r b la ck s and w h ite s .
2.

Black c h ild r e n account f o r no more than

11 p erc en t o f th e t o t a l A rlin g to n p u b lic s c h o o l p opu la
tio n .

With some thought and care a tr u e u n ita r y sc h o o l

system ab sorb in g th e s e b la ck c h ild r e n could have been
cr ea ted a t any tim e in th e l a s t 17 y e a r s , and i t s
c r e a t io n i^ould have caused s c a r c e ly more than a r ip p le .
In deed , v i r t u a l l y a l l o f A r lin g to n 's b la ck c h ild r e n
have now been absorbed in to p r e v io u s ly a ll- w h i t e sc h o o ls
w ith ou t s i g n i f i c a n t in c id e n t .
To be s u r e , th e slow n ess w ith which A rlin g to n
County moved t o d ese g re g a te i t s sc h o o ls i s a t t r ib u t a b le
in p a rt to th e s t a t e p o lic y o f m assive r e s is t a n c e th a t
p r e v a ile d in th e l a t e 1 9 5 0 's .

2/

But th e r e has been l o c a l

r e s is t a n c e as w e ll , and the s to r y o f i t i s w r itte n in
o p in io n s o f t h i s C ourt.

In b r ie f summary:

2 / To A r lin g to n 's c r e d it i t s sc h o o l board announced broad
p la n s f o r d e se g r e g a tio n soon a f t e r th e second Brown d e c i
s io n , Brown v . Board o f E ducation, 349 U .S . 294 (1 9 5 5 )•
The l e g i s l a t u r e , caught up in th e b eg in n in g s o f m assive
r e s is t a n c e , r e a c te d by ta k in g away from th e r e s id e n ts o f
A rlin g to n County t h e ir p r i v i l e g e , unique among V ir g in ia
l o c a l i t i e s , o f e l e c t i n g t h e ir own sc h o o l board; th e
members o f th e sc h o o l board are now appointed by the
County Board, th e C ounty's governing body. See Muse,
V ir g in ia 's M assive R e sista n c e 24 (1 9 6 1 ).

�- 5 -

At th e tim e th a t Brown v . Board o f Education
was d ecid ed th e sc h o o l c h ild r e n o f A rlin g to n County,
l i k e th o se o f o th er V ir g in ia com m unities, were s e g r e
ga ted in t h e i r sc h o o ls by r a c e .

There were fou r b lack

elem en tary sc h o o ls - - Kemper and, n earb y. Drew ( o r ig in
a l l y known as Kemper Annex) and Hoffman-Boston in the
sou th ern p a rt o f th e County, se r v in g th e County's
la r g e s t b la c k r e s i d e n t i a l area; and L angston, se r v in g
th e b la ck r e s i d e n t i a l area in th e n orthern p a rt o f th e
County.

There was a s in g le ju n io r and se n io r h igh

s c h o o l f o r b la ck s from a l l p a rts o f th e County, a ls o
c a lle d Hoffm an-Boston.
An in ju n c tio n fo rb id d in g th e S ch ool Board in
g e n e r a l terms to deny ad m ission to any o f A r lin g to n 's
sc h o o ls on th e ground o f race was en ter ed by th e cou rt
below as e a r ly as J u ly 3 1 , 1956.

Thompson v . County

S ch ool Board, 144 F . Supp. 239 (E.D. Va. 1 9 5 6 ).
affirm ed th a t d e c r e e .

T his Court

Sch ool Board o f C h a r lo t t e s v ille v .

A lle n , 240 F.2d 59 (4 th C ir. 1 9 5 6 ), c e r t , d e n ie d , 353
U .S . 911 (1 9 5 7 )-

F urther l i t i g a t i o n fo llo w e d in v o lv in g

r e q u e sts f o r su pp lem ental d ecrees to compel th e ad m ission

�-

6

-

o f p a r t ic u la r b la c k stu d e n ts to sc h o o ls o f t h e ir ch o ic e
3/
near t h e ir homes.
As l a t e as 1963, fo u r y ea rs a f t e r
th e m a ssive r e s is t a n c e s t a t u t e s were d ecla re d u n c o n s ti
t u t io n a l and A r lin g to n was f r e e t o ch a rt i t s own c o u r se ,
p ro g re ss toward d e se g r e g a tio n was s t i l l measured by the
number o f in d iv id u a l b la ck c h ild r e n a tte n d in g p r e v io u s ly
a ll- w h i t e s c h o o ls ; th e b la ck sc h o o ls remained b la c k ,
and m ost w h ite sc h o o ls were u n a ffe c te d .

T h is Court

noted t h a t , in argu in g fo r d is s o lu t i o n o f th e 1956
in ju n c t io n , th e S ch ool Board had " c ited th e f a c t th a t
146 Negro stu d e n ts were then a tte n d in g predom inantly
w h ite sc h o o ls n e a r e st t h e ir r e s id e n c e s ."

Brooks v .
------------

County S ch o o l Board, 324 F.2d 3 03, 306-07 (4th C ir . 1 9 6 3 ).

3/

Thompson v . County School Board, 159 F. Supp. 567

JE.-D. Va. 1 9 5 7 ), a f f ' d , 2 5 2 F.2d 9 2 9 (4 th C ir. 1 9 5 8 ),
c e r t , d e n ie d , 356 U .S . 958 (1958); Thompson v . County

S ch ool Board, 166 F . Supp. 529 (E.D. Va. 19 5 8 ),
a f f ' d in p a rt sub nom. Hamm v . County School Board,
2b3 F .2d 22b (4 th d ir . 1 9 5 9 ), remanded in p a rt sub nom.
Hamm v . County S ch ool Board, 2b4 F .2d 9 4 5 (4 th C ir. 19t&gt;9) •
4 / The co u rt below d is s o lv e d th e in ju n c tio n , but t h is
Court ordered i t r e in s ta t e d b eca u se , among o th er t h in g s ,
"com pliance began o n ly l a t e l y ." Brooks v . County Sch ool
Board, 324 F .2d 30 3 , 3 0 8 (4th C ir. 1 9 6 3 ) , r e v e r sin g
204 F . Supp. 620 (E.D. Va. 1 9 6 2 ) .

V

�- 7 -

Thereafter there was further progress.

First,

the all-black Hoffman-Boston Senior High School, in
adequate as a high school, was eliminated.

Then junior

high school attendance boundaries were redrawn so as to
desegregate Hoffman-Boston Junior High School.

5/

In the

northern part of the County elementary school lines were
redrawn so as to eliminate Langston as an all-black
elementary school.

But progress was clouded by the

enlargement and modernization in 1964 of Drew School,
located in the heart of the principal black residential
area, in the face of warnings that such action would
perpetuate segregation.
the former Kemper School.

The enlarged Drew supplanted
The present litigation is a

legacy of the decision to enlarge and modernize Drew.
This suit was instituted in 1970.

The relief

initially sought was the desegregation of the Drew
School.

Appeals to the School Board to act to this end

5 / The School Board1s plan for effecting this desegrega
tion was enjoined by the court below on the complaint of
white parents whose children were affected thereby.
Wanner v. County School Board, 245 F. Supp. 132 (E.D.
Va. 1 9 6 5 ) .
This Court r e v e r se d .
Wanner v . County School
Board, 357 F .2d 452 (4th C ir. 1 9 6 6 ) .

�-

8

-

w ith ou t j u d i c i a l prodding had been u n a v a ilin g .

The

case d id not come on fo r t r i a l u n t i l th e summer o f
1971.

By th a t tim e th e Supreme Court had d ecided in

A p r il 1971 a s e r i e s o f sc h o o l d e se g r e g a tio n ca ses th a t
had been pending f o r some tim e.

The p r in c ip a l o p in io n

was th a t o f th e C hief J u s tic e fo r a unanimous Court in
Swann v . C harlotte-M ecklenburg Board o f E d u ca tio n , 402
U .S . 1 (1 9 7 1 ).

With th e d e c is io n in th e C h a r lo tte -

Mecklenburg ca se i t became obvious th a t Drew (and th e
sm a lle r Hoffm an-Boston Elem entary S c h o o l), c r ea ted as
a l l - b l a c k sc h o o ls in an era o f s ta te -r e q u ir e d se g r e g a
t io n o f th e r a c e s , could not remain s o .
The School Board acted promptly, quite in
| contrast to the attitude of silent inaction that had
characterized it for many months despite earnest citizen
pleas that something be done about Drew.

It acted,

imoreover, quietly, announcing as a fait accompli a plan
j that had not been the subject of public hearings and

I that the affected parents had not otherwise participated

�- 9 -

in fo rm u la tin g .

6/

The p la n prom ulgated in June 1971

by th e S ch ool Board t o be ca r r ie d out in th e 1971-72
sc h o o l y ea r c a lle d f o r th e co n v ersio n o f Drew t o a
3 0 0 -stu d e n t "model sch ool" and d isco n tin u a n c e o f th e

use o f Hoffm an-Boston as an elem entary s c h o o l.
K indergartens would co n tin u e a t th e two s c h o o ls .
model s c h o o l would have 60 b la ck s t u d e n t s .

The

The o th e r

700 or so f ir s t - t h r o u g h - s ix t h graders who p r e v io u s ly

atten d ed Drew and Hoffman-Boston would be d isp e rsed

6/

The conversion of the School Board from an elective

To an appointive body has by no means taken schools out

of Arlington politics.
The County Board, which appoints
the School Board members, has five members who serve
four-year terms. Their terms are so staggered that at
least one member is elected every year, and every fourth
year two seats are filled. Thus, political campaigning
in Arlington is fairly continuous, and issues relating
to the public schools are frequent campaign issues. The
Arlington electorate is rather closely balanced between
contending forces that lately have been, on the one side,
a coalition of the Democratic Party and a local party
that draws upon, among others, federal civil servants
who otherwise would be disabled by the Hatch Act from
participating in local politics and, on the other, the
Republican Party.
In 1971, the year in which the School
Board decision now challenged was made, the coalition
had a three-to-two majority on the County Board and two
of the seats it held were at stake in the November election
The School Board membership reflected the same division so
that any School Board decision to require, for example, the
transportation by bus of significant numbers of white child
ren to distant schools could reasonably have been attri
buted to the coalition in the fall campaign.

�10

among the other elementary schools in the County in
such a way as to produce, as nearly as possible, a
proportion of black children in each equivalent to the
proportion of black children in the County school
population.

The Drew and Hoffman-Boston children

would be transported by bus to schools throughout the
County, many of them to schools at a very considerable
distance from their homes.

The plan contemplated that

these children would attend the junior high schools
and senior high schools to which their new elementary
schools feed, not the junior and senior high schools
whose attendance areas include their residences.

No

white elementary children would be transported
outside their districts save as their parents might
volunteer them for the model school at Drew.

(Def.

Ex. 1 , App. 1 8 ) .
The complaint was amended to take account of
the new situation by challenging the School Board's
desegregation plan.

The court below after a brief

trial rejected the contention that to place the entire
burden of desegregation upon the black students in the

�11

way th a t p lan d id v io la t e d t h e ir r ig h t t o th e eq u al
p r o te c tio n o f laws under th e F ourteen th Amendment.
The cou rt approved th e S ch ool Board's p la n .

(App. 1 0 - 1 5 ).

I t tr e a te d th e m atter as in v o lv in g n oth in g more than a
d e c is io n o f th e S ch ool Board as to what th e m echanics
o f d e se g r e g a tio n should b e .

I t equated th e tr a n sp o r ta

t io n o f th e Drew and Hoffman-Boston c h ild r e n out o f t h e ir
sc h o o l a tten d an ce a reas t o th e lo n g -tim e p r a c t ic e in
A rlin g to n o f p ro v id in g bus tr a n sp o r ta tio n fo r some
c h ild r e n w ith in th o se sc h o o l attend ance a reas th a t are
la r g e enough t o make i t in con v en ien t f o r a l l c h ild r e n
t o walk to s c h o o l.

And i t went so f a r as to say th a t

d e se g r e g a tio n would be "accomplished w ith o u t a b o lis h in g
th e neighborhood s c h o o l concept" because Drew and
Hoffman-Boston would con tin u e to be used fo r sc h o o l
7/
p u r p o se s.

7 / In a d d itio n to th e u ses mentioned above, a p a rt o f
The Hoffm an-Boston sc h o o l p la n t w i l l co n tin u e to be
u sed , as i t has been b e fo r e , tem p orarily to house the
se v en th grade o f Thomas J e ffe r s o n Ju nior High Sch ool
u n t i l a new Thomas J e ffe r s o n i s b u i l t , and th e r e are
p r e -k in d e r g a r te n and a d u lt c l a s s e s a t Drew.

�12

ARGUMENT
THE ARLINGTON COUNTY SCHOOL BOARD'S PLAN FOR
DESEGREGATING THE COUNTY'S SCHOOLS DENIES TO THE
STUDENTS OF THE FORMER DREW AND HOFFMAN-BOSTON
ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS THE EQUAL PROTECTION OF THE
LAWS BECAUSE IT LAYS UPON THEM THE ENTIRE BURDEN
OF DESEGREGATION BY ELIMINATING DREW AND HOFFMANBOSTON AS ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS AND REQUIRING THE
STUDENTS TO BE TRANSPORTED BY BUS TO SCHOOLS
THROUGHOUT THE COUNTY WHILE NO WHITE CHILDREN
ARE INVOLUNTARILY TRANSPORTED TO SCHOOLS OUT
SIDE THEIR NORMAL, NEIGHBORHOOD ATTENDANCE AREAS.

The p r in c ip le th a t must gu id e d e c is io n in
t h i s c a se i s a sim p le one t h a t lo n g a n te d a te s the sc h o o l
d e s e g r e g a tio n c a s e s and th e body o f law , some o f i t
h ig h ly p a r t ic u la r and even r e c o n d ite , th a t th ey have
p rod uced .

Judge Wisdom, w r itin g f o r th e Court o f

A ppeals f o r th e F i f t h C ir c u it in a ca se th a t posed an
i s s u e v e r y s im ila r t o th a t posed h e r e , re co g n iz ed t h i s
f a c t when he began h is a n a ly s is w ith th e statem en t
t h a t "the eq u a l p r o t e c tio n c la u s e o f th e fo u r te e n th
amendment p rev e n ts any in v id io u s d is c r im in a tio n on the
b a s is o f r a c e ."

Lee v . Macon County Board o f E d u cation ,

448 F .2d 7 4 6 , 753 (5 th C ir. 1 9 7 1 ) .
As authority for this statement Judge Wisdom
cited Yick Wo v . Hopkins, 118 U .S . 356 (1 8 8 6 ), one of

�13 -

the great landmarks in the history of the civilizing
influence that the Constitution and particularly the
Civil War amendments as interpreted and applied by the
judges have had upon our society.

The issue there,

it will be recalled, was the constitutional validity
in their application of city ordinances that seemingly
had the legitimate purpose of guarding against the
danger of fire by prohibiting laundries in wooden
buildings except as a local governing body permitted
them.

The vice of the ordinances that the Supreme Court

perceived lay in the unbridled authority they conferred
upon the governing body to choose between one applicant
for permission to have a wooden laundry and another
and in the fact that that authority had been used solely
to exclude Chinese from the laundry business.
The facts, the Court said,
"establish an administration directed so
exclusively against a particular class of
persons as to warrant and require the con
clusion, that, whatever may have been the
intent of the ordinances as adopted, they are
applied by the public authorities charged
with their administration, and thus repre
senting the State itself, with a mind so
unequal and oppressive as to amount to a
practical denial by the State of that equal

J

�- l4 -

protection of the laws which is secured to
petitioners, as to all other persons, by
the broad and benign provisions of the
Fourteenth Amendment to the Constitution of
the United States." Id. at 373.
So here the school authorities, pursuing the
legitimate, constitutionally required, goal of elimi
nating racial segregation in a school system that had
been segregated by law, have chosen means to that end
that are "unequal and oppressive" and deny to black
students and their plaintiff parents the equal pro
tection of the laws.

The court below erred in treating

the case as one in which the school authorities had
unfettered discretion in their choice of remedies for
the unconstitutional situation they had allowed to
persist for so long.

For the Constitution says that,

whatever its goal, the School Board may not act in
such a way as to create "any invidious discrimination
on the basis of race."

The remedy chosen by the School

Board here does result in precisely such discrimination.
So we shall see in what follows.

�- 15

A.

The F a cts Demonstrate th e In v id io u s
D isc r im in a tio n A g a in st Black C hildren
E ffe c te d by th e S ch ool Board's P lan .

The f a c t s c r i t i c a l to d e c is io n are quicklys ta te d .
1.

The b la c k c h ild r e n o f Drew and Hoffman-

Boston are tra n sp o r te d by bus t o sc h o o ls o u tsid e t h e ir
atten d an ce a r e a s , some o f them fa r o u ts id e .

White

elem entary s c h o o l c h ild r e n in th e County co n tin u e to
a tten d th e sc h o o ls in t h e ir atten d an ce a r e a s , most of
them w alking to g e t t h e r e .

And t h is d isc r im in a tio n

w i l l f o llo w many b la c k c h ild r e n through t h e ir ju n io r
h igh sc h o o l and s e n io r h igh sc h o o l y e a r s; th ey w i l l be
made to a tte n d h ig h e r sc h o o ls o th er than th o se th a t
n a tu r a lly se rv e t h e ir neighborhoods w h ile w hite c h ild
ren w i l l a tte n d th e ju n io r and s e n io r h igh sc h o o ls
se r v in g th e atten d an ce a reas where th ey l i v e .
2.

Two elem entary s c h o o l p la n ts in predomi

n a n tly b la ck neighborhoods are abandoned as elem entary
s c h o o ls .

They are abandoned even though Drew, modern

iz e d and en larged in 1964 and w ith an a ir -c o n d itio n e d
wing and a sp a c io u s, w ell-eq u ip p ed gymnasium.

�-

16

-

unusual among A rlin g to n elem entary s c h o o ls , was d e s
crib ed by th e S u p erin ten d en t o f Sch ools as "among the
upper h a lf" o f A r lin g to n sc h o o ls in terms o f i t s
s u i t a b i l i t y as an elem entary sc h o o l (Tr. 4 ) , and
Hoffman-Boston was c h a r a c te r iz e d by him a s "a rea so n a b ly
good sch ool" (Tr. 5 ) .
3.

P lan s f o r th e d e se g r e g a tio n o f Drew and

Hoffman-Boston th a t would n ot have c a s t th e e n t ir e
burden o f d e se g r e g a tio n upon c h ild r e n o f th e m in o rity
race by e lim in a tin g t h e ir elem en tary sc h o o ls were
a v a ila b le to th e Board.

These am ici tak e no p o s it io n

on which o f th e s e p la n s i s most d e s ir a b le , or w hether
some oth er n ot y e t advanced may be b e s t .

I t i s enough

to note here t h a t , as i s developed in th e b r ie f o f th e
p l a i n t i f f s - a p p e l l a n t s , oth er p la n s th a t could c o n s t i
t u t io n a lly have been adopted by th e S ch ool Board e x is t e d .
These f a c t s a lo n e are enough to show an
in v id io u s d isc r im in a tio n — a r a c i a l c l a s s i f i c a t i o n in
f a c t , th e absence o f any n o n - r a c ia l j u s t i f i c a t i o n fo r
i t and n o n -d iscr im in a to ry a l t e r n a t i v e s .

Beyond th e se

f a c t s , th e r e i s testim o n y o f record to th e adverse

�- 17

e f f e c t upon th e b la ck c h ild r e n th a t th e d isc r im in a tio n
w i l l h a v e.

George R ichardson, th e former p r in c ip a l

o f Hoffman-Boston High S ch ool and s t i l l a r e s id e n t o f
th e Hoffman-Boston a tten d an ce area and w e ll-a c q u a in te d
t h e r e , t e s t i f i e d t h a t , when la r g e numbers o f c h ild r e n
are tra n sp o rted by bus in to o th er p a rts o f th e County,
"there i s a f e e l i n g th a t th e stu d e n ts w i l l r e a liz e
th a t i f th ey are th e o n ly ones d oing t h i s , th a t they
are b ein g tr e a te d d if f e r e n t [ l y ] , " and p a r t ic u la r ly i f
th ey "look around" in th e a reas in t o which th ey are
tran sp orted and se e th a t o th er stu d e n ts a re n ot b ein g
tra n sp o rted out o f them.

(Tr. 5 9 - 6 0 ).

In s h o r t ,

Mr. R ichardson s a id , th e S ch ool Board's p la n says to
b la ck c h ild r e n th a t th ey are i n f e r i o r .

(Tr. 6 1 -6 2 ).

That would not be t r u e , he added, were th e re two-way
b u s s in g .

(Tr. 6 2 -6 3 ).
B.

D e c isio n s o f This Court and Other Courts
E s ta b lis h th e U n c o n s t it u t io n a lit y o f the
A rlin g to n S ch ool B oard's D eseg reg a tio n P la n .

On f a c t s no more com p ellin g than th o se we have
j u s t summarized t h i s Court and th e co u rts o f ap peals
f o r o th er c i r c u i t s have s e t a s id e th e a c t io n of

�- 18 -

lo c a l sc h o o l boards In c lo s in g b la ck sc h o o ls as p a rt of
p lan s f o r e f f e c t in g d e se g r e g a tio n .
The d e c is io n o f t h is Court t o which we r e fe r
i s th e en banc p er curiam o p in io n in Adams v . School
D i s t r i c t Mo. 5 , 444 F .2d 99 (4 th C ir. 1 9 7 1 ), c e r t , d e n ie d ,
404 U .S . 912 (1971) (W inston Salem /F orsyth County sc h o o ls '
p e titio n ).

The o p in io n b ea rin g th a t ca p tio n covered

ap p eals r e la t in g t o fou r sc h o o l d i s t r i c t s .

A ll o f the

ap p eals were heard a f t e r th e o p in io n s in th e C h a r lo tte Mecklenburg ca se and i t s companions had been handed down.
The main d e c is io n o f th e Court was to v a ca te a l l the
judgments below t o g iv e th e d i s t r i c t co u rts in v o lv ed the
o p p ortu n ity to r e c e iv e from the sc h o o l boards new p lan s
o f d e se g r e g a tio n th a t would g iv e e f f e c t t o the Supreme
Court d e c is io n s .
The case o f th e sc h o o ls o f Roanoke, V ir g in ia ,
one o f th e fou r sc h o o l d i s t r i c t s in v o lv e d , came up on
ap p eals by both th e sc h o o l board and th e p l a i n t i f f s from
a judgment o f the D i s t r i c t Court fo r th e W estern D i s t r i c t
o f V ir g in ia , Green v . S ch ool Board, 316 F . Supp. 6 (W.D.
Va. 1 9 7 0 ).

D esp ite the g e n e r a l v a c a tio n and remand t h is

Court was s p e c i f i c in a ffir m in g , on th e sc h o o l board 's
a p p e a l, th e d i s t r i c t c o u r t 's d e c is io n th a t an a ll- b la c k

�- 19 high school that had been marked by the school board for
conversion to a vocational education center and site of
special classes should be retained as a high school.
444 F.2d at 101.
The board's good faith in providing for this
conversion was scarcely open to question; the elimina

t io n o f the black high school was recommended by con
sultants from the Department of Health, Education &amp;
Welfare and initially was not objected to by the plain
tiffs.

However, a protest meeting brought about a

change in the position of the plaintiffs, and the dis
trict court similarly took "notice of tne understandably
strong feeling in the Negro community against the
closing of what they describe as 'their' fine school."
Id. at 8.
After viewing the high school in question,
the court found merit in "the plaintiffs' objection
that the black community should not be required to
shoulder the largest part of the burden involved in
the desegregation process . . . ."

I d . at 10.

In sum,

no adequate reason for "the conversion of such a fine
facility" was advanced, id. at 11, and this Court

�20

a g reed .

8/

See a ls o F eld e r v . H arnett County Board o f

E d u cation , 409 F .2d 1070, 1074 (4 th C lr. 1 9 6 9 ) .
An e a r l i e r d e c is io n o f t h is Court, A lle n v .
A s h e v ille C ity Board o f E d u cation , 434 F .2d 902 (4th
C ir. 1 9 7 0 ), i l l u s t r a t e s circum stances in w hich, as th e
Court put i t , i t was "unable to p e r c e iv e any in v id io u s
d is c r im in a tio n in" a sc h o o l b oard 's p la n th a t i n
cluded c lo s in g two b la c k elem entary sc h o o ls because
th e r e were adequate n o n -r a c ia l reason s f o r th e a c t io n .
Id . a t 905"

That p la n covered a l l 12 sc h o o ls in a c i t y

sc h o o l system , and th e r e was b u ssin g o f c h ild r e n o f
both r a c e s .

There remained sc h o o ls th a t had been a l l

b la ck but th a t were now to be atten d ed by stu d en ts o f
both r a c e s .

The Court found t h a t , o v e r a ll, th e burden

o f d e se g r e g a tio n f e l l d isp r o p o r tio n a te ly on b la ck
ch ild r e n in th e low er grades and on w h ite c h ild r e n in
th e upper g r a d e s, and in t h is th ere was no d is c r im in a tio n .

8/
In c o n t r a s t , th e d i s t r i c t cou rt approved, over th e
p l a i n t i f f s 1 o b je c t io n , th e c lo s in g o f a b la ck ju n io r h ig h
s c h o o l, fin d in g th a t th e sc h o o l s i t e was sm a ll and near
a n o isy highw ay. Green v . S ch ool Board, 316 F. Supp.
6 , 11 (W.D. Va. 1 9 7 0 ). T his Court sa id th a t on th e
remand th e d i s t r i c t co u rt might "approve th e p resen t
ju n io r and s e n io r h igh s c h o o l p la n ." Adams v . S ch ool
D i s t r i c t No. 5 , 444 F .2d 9 9 , 101 (4 th C ir. 1 9 7 1 ).

�21

Id. a t 9 0 7 .

See also Chambers v. Iredell County Board

o f Education. 423 F .2d 613 (4th Cir. 1 9 7 0 ) .
S im ila r ly , th e Court o f Appeals f o r th e F if t h
C ir c u it has d is tin g u is h e d th o se ca ses in which the
c lo s in g o f b la ck sc h o o ls i s in v id io u s ly d isc r im in a to r y
and th o se in which th e r e are reasons o th er than race
fo r sc h o o l c lo s in g s th a t tend to b rin g about a u n ita r y
sc h o o l system .

In Lee v . Macon County S ch o o l Board o f

E d u cation , 448 F .2d 746 (5 th C ir. 1 9 7 1 ), from which we
have quoted above (p . 1 2 , su p ra) , one p la n o f d e se g r e
g a tio n th a t was b e fo r e th e cou rt fo r c o n sid e r a tio n
in v o lv ed c lo s in g th e on ly two b la ck sc h o o ls in a d i s t r i c t .
The sc h o o ls were good sc h o o ls p h y s ic a lly , and a
p r in c ip a l reason g iv e n f o r c lo s in g them was th a t o th e r
w ise w h ite stu d en ts would le a v e th e sc h o o l system . On
th a t record th e Court found th e proposed c lo s in g s
r a c i a l l y m otivated and th e r e fo r e in v id io u s ly d is c r im i
n a to r y .

Id^ a t 7 5 3 -5 4 .

I t quoted , icK a t 754 n . 1 2 ,

from B rice v . L a n d is, 314 F. Supp. 974, 978 (N.D. C al.
1 9 6 9 ) , where th e c o u r t, a ls o r e j e c t in g a b la ck sc h o o l

c lo s in g , sa id th a t t o c lo s e th e b la ck sc h o o l and bus i t s

�22

stu d en ts away means th a t "the m in o r ity c h ild r e n are
p la ced in th e p o s it io n o f what may be d escrib ed a s
s e c o n d -c la s s p u p ils ."

See a ls o B e ll v . West P o in t

M unicipal Separate S ch ool D i s t r i c t , 446 F .2d 1362
(5 th C ir. 1971)5 Gordon v . J e ffe r s o n D avis P a rish
School D i s t r i c t . 446 F .2d 266 (5 th C ir. 1 9 7 1 ).
On th e o th er hand, th e F if t h C ir c u it, w h ile
re c o g n iz in g th e r u le th a t c lo s in g s o f form erly a l l
b la ck sc h o o ls "are p r o h ib ite d where undertaken fo r
r a c ia l reason s o f th e type th a t may be equated w ith
in v id io u s d is c r im in a tio n ," Mims v . Duval County S ch ool
Board, 447 F .2d 1330, 1331 (5th C ir. 1 9 7 1 ), has approved
c lo s in g s where n o n -r a c ia l reasons f o r them were found.
Ibid . ; Carr v. Montgomery County Board of Education,

429 F .2d 382, 385 (5 th C ir. 1970) (w h ite sc h o o ls a ls o
c lo se d ! w h ite stu d en ts a tte n d in g p r e v io u sly a l l
b la ck s c h o o ls ) .

In deed, in a t le a s t one case an

i n e f f i c i e n t l y sm a ll, p h y s ic a lly in f e r i o r b la ck sc h o o l
was ordered c lo s e d to accom plish d e se g r e g a tio n .
Choctaw County Board of Education v. United States,
417 F.2d 845 (5 th C ir. 1 9 6 9 ) .

�- 23 -

F in a lly , words o f th e Court o f Appeals fo r
th e E ighth C ir c u it in r u lin g on a sc h o o l c lo s in g is s u e
a re p a r t ic u la r ly p e r tin e n t h e r e .

In Haney v . County

Board o f E d u ca tio n , 429 F .2d 3 64, 372 (8th C ir. 1 9 7 0 ),
th a t cou rt p la ced "a heavy burden on th e s c h o o l board . .
t o e x p la in the c lo s in g o f f a c i l i t i e s fo rm erly used fo r
th e in s t r u c t io n o f b la c k stu d e n ts ."

I t c a lle d upon the

sc h o o l board in th e ca se a t hand t o r e s o lv e th e m atter
o f what f a c i l i t i e s would con tin u e to be used when a
dual sc h o o l system was changed t o a u n ita r y sc h o o l system
"on some r a t io n a l n on d iscrim in a to ry b a s is . . . ."
Here th e A rlin g to n S ch ool Board, though i t
had ev ery o p p ortu n ity to do s o , has n ot been a b le to
r e s o lv e th e m atter o f how th e rem aining elem en ts o f
i t s d ual sc h o o l system are to be done away w ith on any
" r a tio n a l n o n d iscrim in atory b a s is ."

In l i g h t o f th e

p reced en ts j u s t d is c u s s e d , i t i s a p p rop ria te fo r t h is
Court to d ir e c t th e Board to re c o n sid e r th e m atter and
come forward w ith a s o lu t io n th a t squares w ith th o se
"broad and benign p r o v is io n s o f th e F ou rteen th Amendment"
gu a ra n teein g t o a l l p ersons th e eq u al p r o t e c tio n o f the

�- 2b -

laws to which the Supreme Court referred nearly a century
ago in Yick Wo v. Hopkins and which the Supreme Court,
this Court and the other federal courts have invoked so
frequently in the intervening years to protect the right
to equal treatment of members of racial minorities.
C.

The Fact that the School Board's Plan Re
sults in Arlington's Not Having Any One-Race
Schools Does Not Justify the Discrimination
It Works Against Black Children._____________

A recurrent theme in the School Board's defense
of its plan is that its plan results in the complete de
segregation of all of Arlington's elementary schools, and
no other plan that has been offered does as much.
There are two things to be said about this de
fense.

First, the Board's punctilious concern for complete

school desegregation must seem cruelly ironic to the black
parents represented by the plaintiffs and to the black
parents who have gone before them.

They have waited

patiently for the Board to end the segregation of their
children in the public schools.

Disadvantaged politically

as in most other respects, the black minority of South

�- 25 -

A rlin g to n could not arouse to a c t io n a sc h o o l board th a t
n a tu r a lly c a te r s to th e in t e r e s t s o f a predom inantly
w h ite e l e c t o r a t e .

(See p . 4 , n .2 , su p r a ).

Now th e

c h ild r e n o f th e b la ck m in o r ity have been fo rced upon the
B oard's c o n sc io u sn e ss o n ly to be made t o pay by t h e ir
d is p e r s a l the whole p r ic e o f th e com plete d ese g re g a tio n
th a t th e Board b e la t e d ly s e t up as a g o a l.

That i s not

th e e q u a lit y o f treatm en t the b la ck p aren ts a sk ed .
The o th er th in g i s t o acknowledge th a t the
r e s u lt ach ieved by th e S cn ool Board i s la u d a b le — and
then to ask w hether i t i s worth th e c o s t .

In candor,

n ot so many y ears ago th e v a s t m a jo r ity o f d e c is io n
makers and a d v o c a te s, a f f e c t e d w ith a w h ite b ia s - th e term i s used d e s c r ip t i v e ly , not p e j o r a t iv e ly
might not have thought v ery much about th e c o s t .

But

th e in c r e a sin g v i s i b i l i t y o f b lack p rid e has changed
our p erc ep tio n o f r e a l i t y and our modes o f th o u g h t.

No

lon ger can we proceed on th e assum ption th a t what th e
b la ck man wants i s m erely fo r h is c h ild r e n to be a b le to
a tten d th e w h ite man's s c h o o l.

I f th e assum ption ever

had any fo u n d a tio n , th e fou n d ation has d isa p p ea red .

�-

26

-

Integration must be a two-way street, achieved with
respect for the dignity and humanity of blacks as well
as whites.
Judge Dalton in the Roanoke case caught
something of what we are trying to say here when, in
a passage we have heretofore quoted, he noted "the
understandably strong feeling" of the black community
of Roanoke "against the closing of what they describe
as 'their' fine school."

The strong feeling of the

members of the black community of South Arlington for
their schools and for the welfare of their children
has not been respected by the School Board.

Disregard

of that feeling is, on amici's view, too great a cost
for the undoubted beneficial results of the School
Board's plan.

CONCLUSION
These amici believe that the judgment below
should be reversed, the School Board's plan of desegre
gation disapproved and enjoined and the matter confided

�- 27 -

to th e S ch ool Board f o r fu r th e r c o n sid e r a tio n and w ith
d ir e c t io n s to d e v is e , w ith th e h elp o f c i t i z e n p a r t i c i
p a tio n , a p lan th a t s a t i s f i e s c o n s t it u t io n a l req u irem en ts.
R e s p e c tf u lly su b m itted .
WILLIAM H. ALLEN
JOHN B. JONES, J r .
Covington &amp; B u rlin g
888 16th Street, N.W.
W ashington, D.C. 20006
A ttorn eys fo r Amici Curiae
February 9 , 1972

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="10">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="2122">
                  <text>RG 18: Personal Papers of Barbara Marx</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="16933">
                <text>Copy of John K. Hart, et al vs. County School Board of Arlington County, Virginia, et al, On Appeal From The United States District Court For The Eastern District of Virginia, Brief for Certain Arlington Organizations as Amici Curiae, February 9, 1972.  31 pages.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="16934">
                <text>Copy of John K. Hart, et al vs. County School Board of Arlington County, Virginia, et al, On Appeal From The United States District Court For The Eastern District of Virginia, Brief for Certain Arlington Organizations as Amici Curiae, February 9, 1972.  </text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="42">
            <name>Format</name>
            <description>The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="16935">
                <text>PDF</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="48">
            <name>Source</name>
            <description>A related resource from which the described resource is derived</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="16936">
                <text>RG 18</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="39">
            <name>Creator</name>
            <description>An entity primarily responsible for making the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="16937">
                <text>Attorneys for Amici Curiae</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="16938">
                <text>1972-02-09</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="38">
            <name>Coverage</name>
            <description>The spatial or temporal topic of the resource, the spatial applicability of the resource, or the jurisdiction under which the resource is relevant</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="16939">
                <text>1970s</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="47">
            <name>Rights</name>
            <description>Information about rights held in and over the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="16940">
                <text>This image is subject to copyright. Unauthorized use of the images in the Local History Collections of the Arlington Community Archives is prohibited.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="43">
            <name>Identifier</name>
            <description>An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="22013">
                <text>18_2_1_16_45</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="2207" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="1919">
        <src>https://projectdaps.org/files/original/0eaaba6ce9eaa60a89777656069ccea4.pdf</src>
        <authentication>b89e36b005d36c177838042230580e05</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="52">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="23684">
                    <text>OAKRIDGE ELEMENTARY SCHOOL
703-553-2350

ARLINGTON PU8LIC SCHOOLS
1414 24TH STREET SOUTH, ARLINGTON, VIRGINIA 22202

27 April 1987

RE:

Dear
On Thursday, March 19, 1987 the Arlington School Board voted
to change sane school attendance boundaries in the Arlington View
area. A surtmary of th eir action s that night and a map of the
Arlington View area showing school boundaries for September 1987
are attached.
Because of these changes, your ch ild w ill attend Thanas J effer­
son instead of Kenmore beginning in September 1987. Busing to the
new school w ill be provided. The principal of Jefferson, Ms. Sharon
Steindam w ill be in contact regarding scheduling for the school year.
Instructional transfers for children whose parents would lik e
for them to remain at Kenmore are available i f you sig n ify your in­
tentions by f i ll i n g out the necessary form which you may get fran
the principal at Jefferson. However, you w ill be responsible for
providing transportation for your child i f the transfer i s approved.
Please c a ll me at 553-2350 i f you have any questions about your
c h ild 's September 1987 placement.
Sincerely,

Helen T. B elt
Principal
cc: '/ /D r. John Crowder, Assessment Coordinator
Ms. Sharon Steindam, P rincip al, Jefferson
Sent to:

Mr.
Mrs
Mr.
Ms.
Mr.

&amp; Mrs. Frederick Stewart, 1701 S. 14th Rd.
Eunice Epps, 1608 S. 13th Rd.
&amp; Mrs. Dewey Winston, 1315 S. Pierce St.
Tawania A. White, 1407 S. Rolfe S t ., #5
&amp; Mrs. Benjamin Laws, 1735 S. 15th S t ., #2

[Clayton]
[Andrea]
[Elmore Clark]
[Karsha]
[Zeporia]

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="23677">
                <text>Copy of letter to parents of Oakridge students about boundary changes. </text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="23678">
                <text>Students will now attend Thomas Jefferson instead of Kenmore unless parents ask for instructional transfers.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="42">
            <name>Format</name>
            <description>The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="23679">
                <text>pdf</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="48">
            <name>Source</name>
            <description>A related resource from which the described resource is derived</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="23680">
                <text>RG 69, Arlington County Public Schools:  Desegregation Materials</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="39">
            <name>Creator</name>
            <description>An entity primarily responsible for making the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="23681">
                <text>Arlington Public Schools, Oakridge Elementary School, Helen T. Belt</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="38">
            <name>Coverage</name>
            <description>The spatial or temporal topic of the resource, the spatial applicability of the resource, or the jurisdiction under which the resource is relevant</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="23682">
                <text>1980s</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="47">
            <name>Rights</name>
            <description>Information about rights held in and over the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="23683">
                <text>This image is subject to copyright. Unauthorized use of the images in the Local History Collections of the Arlington Community Archives is prohibited.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="43">
            <name>Identifier</name>
            <description>An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="24403">
                <text>69_3_1_11_90</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="1657" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="1402">
        <src>https://projectdaps.org/files/original/d8e7d3e53031e3995feda27319b1bb22.pdf</src>
        <authentication>d4cb141cd63e24e5867cc3e5b997f9bc</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="52">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="16901">
                    <text>( p M \1

4969 'lock 3- r ln - load
I r lln g ta n , v a . 22207
25 Juno 1969
K rs . l u t h 0 'D o l l c^x. Chair-non
A r l l n to n iohool j o - r d
4751 N. 25 S t .
A r l l n t o n , V . 2207
?
Deer l i r a . Cox:

I hove r e e d I n th e newspaper t h a t t h e p r o o l d s n t of tho Drew Elem
e n t " ry School ITA ho 9 retrod the A r l i n g t o n Soho 1 jo - rd f o r h e lp I n
daaogi'
the Drew S chool. as • concerned o l t l z o n a n d mother of
4 c c h o o l- a g e c h i l d r e n , I a l n o a r o ly hope t h a t the A r l in g to n School
Board w i l l a c t quloYLy xx on t h i s r a q u o o t.
T
&gt;

For a number o f y e a r s no-' I t hoc been the law of the l e n d t h a t
aohoola sh o u ld be do 0 0 r a t e d . I n- aware t h a t f t r l l n ton has made
c r nges In I t s ochoolo t o o a r r v o u t d e s a g r a t l o n . I t l e I m p o r t a n t
n o t only t h a t we c o n tin u e to comply w i t h th e la w , o u t t h a t we show
our b e l i e f In e q u a l e d u o t l o n ’l o p p o r t u n i t y f o r - 1 1 our o l t l z c n c
by J o 30(7^t i n ; tha Prow ic h o o l.
In stu d ylr. tha story o f joliool o e g r e g -tlo n in t. a 00 u n it ie s o f
B e rk eley , C a lifo r n io ., Evanston, I l l i n o i s ,
V raou ae, aw orb,
you fin d t h - t the sch ool io -tIh o f those c i t i e s were behind doaogrs -tlo n -ri'-ns, -nd put c a r e fu l thought In to lo n : -range 1 1 i j for
thscBU -.1 d is t r ib u t io n of m inority stu d en ts throu, out tbs ehool
0 voter.. Co— u n it - r s i’U M BCBtt fgB from v r l o u s or--—«i_- t l iij arid
o cc u r " tl &gt;ns helped - la n th e d e e e g r a tle n md works
t the b ’ak
in . o f the ooanunlty as a w hole.
Of p a r '" i9 u n t c o n c e r n ’t o th e s e o_- • un* t i e s was the f o o t t h '- t American
s o c i e t y w i l l neve r be a b le to l i v e I n pouoo nd u n d e r u ta n d in u n l e s s
b io ok • i l w h ite poroons s t u d y , work n i ploy t o g e t h e r throughout
t h e i r school y e a rs.
lha U.3. C o i n l s s l o n on l v l l 11 h t s , In I t s c a r e f u l l y documented
stu d y on " H a d s l I a o l a t b n I n tho P u b lic d o h o o lo " , hi 1 shown t h a t
d is a d v a n t a g e d s t u d e n t s a c h ie v e c r e a t o r -endemic g a i n s I n i n t e g r a t e d
soho: 1 3 . Thi3 was ce rt- I n ly borne o u t I n the anno of ichool d e eogre " t l o n I n l y r a o u e e , N . F . , where th e q u a l i t y o f t
Lo d i d
n o t o t e r l o r a t o when t ay were I n t e g r a t e d , n o r d id th e ac h ie v e iont
l e v e l s of the p u p i l s . Mush oxtr1
m t i n t o tho d e s e g r e g a t i o n
p l a n s , so t h a t t h e r e would be a minimum o f c o n f u s io n and a l o u n d o r n t - .. l i n g .
A r l i n g t o n I s f o r t u n - t o a t tho moment, to have a e?i% ste o f enough
r o e l s l u n d e r s t a n d i n g to c a r r y o u t desegrn
a hr-r-nonlouely.
But I b e l i e v e we must s t a r t to c t now, f o r I t lo - r r e n t t h a t th o r e
I s g r e a t m o l ' - l u n r o o t i n America, and we - u - t show our d e s i r e and
f i r e . I n t e n t to o u t th e g o a l o f eq u a l e d u c a t i o n a l 0 o r t u n l t y I n t o
e o n o r e te n o t i o n .
The A r l in g to n Johool Board has a r a r e ep- o r t u n l t y t o le a d I n ti l e
v i t a l a r e - , -nd I b e l i e v e I t must ta k e thl-&gt; r c a n o n a l b l l l t y e a r l o u a l y
•nd eo--n. l a t h e r t ’vm he pushed i n t o t h i s a c t i o n by ■ c o u r t o r d e r .
I t woul 1 be ao much &gt;ett :&gt; f o r fud* fce no u n i t y r e t tlo n * I f f i e
•
6^

V '

�oohool board should taka the le a d In oe i n A
p la n n in g fo r draw's d a a eg ra ea tlo n .
Sincer-aly y o u rs.

(tirs. George I . lootli)
I

nboosaary

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="10">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="2122">
                  <text>RG 18: Personal Papers of Barbara Marx</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="16893">
                <text>Copy of letter to Ruth Cox, Chairman, Arlington County School Board from Mrs. George H. Booth, June 25, 1969. 2 pages.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="16894">
                <text>Copy of letter urging the School Board to Act on the request of the Drew PTA for help in desegregating Drew School sent to Barbara Marx for her information.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="42">
            <name>Format</name>
            <description>The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="16895">
                <text>PDF</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="48">
            <name>Source</name>
            <description>A related resource from which the described resource is derived</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="16896">
                <text>RG 18</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="39">
            <name>Creator</name>
            <description>An entity primarily responsible for making the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="16897">
                <text>Joanne Booth</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="16898">
                <text>1969-06-25</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="38">
            <name>Coverage</name>
            <description>The spatial or temporal topic of the resource, the spatial applicability of the resource, or the jurisdiction under which the resource is relevant</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="16899">
                <text>1960s</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="47">
            <name>Rights</name>
            <description>Information about rights held in and over the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="16900">
                <text>This image is subject to copyright. Unauthorized use of the images in the Local History Collections of the Arlington Community Archives is prohibited.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="43">
            <name>Identifier</name>
            <description>An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="22009">
                <text>18_2_1_16_27</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="603" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="304">
        <src>https://projectdaps.org/files/original/4ebe831c97c7cb79071cc753b1f5698b.pdf</src>
        <authentication>f7d18345326321cfbd1de90bc69ee565</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="52">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="6384">
                    <text>6897 H. Washington Blvd.,
Arlington, Virginia,
October 10, 1957
Editor northern Virginia Sun,
34-09 Wilson Blva.,
Arlington, Va.
Dear Sir:
I am surprised by Mr. Magruder's statement in your
paper that l a m

one of Mr. Herbert Brown's intimate political

advisers on integration.
X have never even met Mr. Brown.

X disapprove of

his support of the Arlington school board's stand against com­
pulsory integration.

I resigned from the ABC council last year

because of its attitude on the subject.
As far as the NAACP is concerned it is a non-partisan
organization which never supports political candidates;.
Very truly yours,
Barbara Marx

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="10">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="2122">
                  <text>RG 18: Personal Papers of Barbara Marx</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="5797">
                <text>Copy of Letter to the Editor, Northern Virginia Sun, October 10, 1957 from Barbara Marx</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="5798">
                <text>Copy of Letter to the Editor, Northern Virginia Sun, October 10, 1957 from Barbara Marx correcting a statement made by Mr. Magruder concerning Mr. Herbert Brown.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="42">
            <name>Format</name>
            <description>The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="5799">
                <text>pdf</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="5800">
                <text>1957-10-10</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="48">
            <name>Source</name>
            <description>A related resource from which the described resource is derived</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="5801">
                <text>RG 18, Personal Papers of Barbara Marx</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="39">
            <name>Creator</name>
            <description>An entity primarily responsible for making the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="5802">
                <text>Barbara S. Marx</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="38">
            <name>Coverage</name>
            <description>The spatial or temporal topic of the resource, the spatial applicability of the resource, or the jurisdiction under which the resource is relevant</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="5803">
                <text>1950s</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="47">
            <name>Rights</name>
            <description>Information about rights held in and over the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="5804">
                <text>This image is subject to copyright. Unauthorized use of the images in the Local History Collections of the Arlington Community Archives is prohibited.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="43">
            <name>Identifier</name>
            <description>An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="21015">
                <text>18_1_1_4_39</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="1382" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="1144">
        <src>https://projectdaps.org/files/original/f43e38ace7338658ac0679925a5733ad.pdf</src>
        <authentication>87800eb18117198e45a9d0d62e751c37</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="52">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="14280">
                    <text>April 16, 1961

Dear Jim:
Our score on transfers is much higher than
we had ever hoped it would be, (see memo.) Dorothy
Hamn and Bob Kldridge did swell promotion jobs.
Transfer fora* were readily available/ in
Arl.
{Al Brown says this was not so in Fairfax.)
Some of the stuff at Hoffman-boston strongly advised
children not to transfer, however this was parobably done or. their own, not on Reid's aug, estion.
As yet wo have no complaints on the administration
of the placement plan.
X am so happy that after you lawyers pried open
the school doors i* Arlington Kogroes are entering
in mass not in driblets.
Cordially yours.

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="10">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="2122">
                  <text>RG 18: Personal Papers of Barbara Marx</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="14272">
                <text>Copy of Letter, April 16 1961.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="14273">
                <text>Letter praising the transfer program in Arlington.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="42">
            <name>Format</name>
            <description>The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="14274">
                <text>pdf</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="48">
            <name>Source</name>
            <description>A related resource from which the described resource is derived</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="14275">
                <text>RG 18, Personal Papers of Barbara Marx</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="39">
            <name>Creator</name>
            <description>An entity primarily responsible for making the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="14276">
                <text>unknown</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="14277">
                <text>1961-04-16</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="38">
            <name>Coverage</name>
            <description>The spatial or temporal topic of the resource, the spatial applicability of the resource, or the jurisdiction under which the resource is relevant</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="14278">
                <text>1960s</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="47">
            <name>Rights</name>
            <description>Information about rights held in and over the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="14279">
                <text>This image is subject to copyright. Unauthorized use of the images in the Local History Collections of the Arlington Community Archives is prohibited.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="43">
            <name>Identifier</name>
            <description>An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="21752">
                <text>18_2_1_6_25</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="1417" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="1178">
        <src>https://projectdaps.org/files/original/52476604fe2d5a89c68a77b0a35790db.pdf</src>
        <authentication>cebdd1df59d8341cd92bdaa282680f3b</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="52">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="14629">
                    <text>�VOL.

1 - NO.

D em ocra tic

1

P rim a ry J u ly

13.

1965

J O H N
L.
M E L N I . C K
A N D
N E T T I E
M
.
E A K E S
C A M P A I G N
I N
G L E N C A R L Y N
p r e c i n c t
F O R
d e m o c r a t i c
DELEGATE C . HARRISON MANN
C O M M I T T E E
TO SPEAK AT MORNING COFFEE
HOURS
On J u l y 1 3 . 1 9 6 5 a t K e n m o r e J u n i o r
Two c o f f e e h o u r s w i l l b e g i v e n f o r
H ig h a l l r e g i s t e r e d v o t e r s w i l l h a v e
v o t e r s t o m e e t w i t h D e l e g a t e C.
an o p p o r t u n i t y t o c a s t t h e i r v o t e s
H a r r i s o n M an n, J o h n L. M e l n i c k a n d
N e t t i e M. E a k e s , i n G l e n c a r l y n P r e c i n c t i n t h e D e m o c r a t i c P r i m a r y .
Four
| s e a t s in th e V ir g in ia G en eral
A l l N o r t h A r l i n g t o n v o t e r s i n t h e G len -j A s s e m b ly , tw o S t a t e S e n a t e s e a t s and
tw o s e a t s o n th e D e m o c r a t i c C om m ittee
ca rly n P recin ct are c o r d ia lly in v ite d
i o f A rlin gton w i l l be d e cid e d .
t o a tte n d a c o f f e e h our b etw een th e
h o u r s o f 1 0 : 3 0 a n d 1 1 : 3 0 A. M. o n
t o a ssu r e th e e l e c t i o n in
REMEMBER
W e d n e s d a y , J u l y 7, a t 5654 8 t h R o a d ,
N o r t h , t h e h o m e o f Mr. a n d M r s . J a c k
j N ovem ber, o f th e c a n d id a te s o f your
! c h o i c e a t t h e p r im a r y , v o t e f o r tw o
E akes.
i p e o p l e f o r th e D e m o c r a tic C om m ittee
A l l S ou th A r l i n g t o n v o t e r s i n th e G len - who w i l l w ork t o g e t t h e D e m o c r a tic
ca rly n P recin ct are c o r d ia lly in v ite d
| C an d id a tes e le c te d .
T h e s e tw o
! p e o p le , and th e c h o ic e o f th e
t o a tten d a c o f f e e h our b etw een th e
i G len ca rly n P r e c in cto r , are
h o u r s o f 1 0 : 3 0 a n d 1 1 : 3 0 A. M. o n
JOHN L. MELNICK a n d N E TTIE M. EAKES.
T h u r s d a y , J u l y 8, a t 5710 1 s t S t r e e t ,
S o u t h , t h e h o m e o f M r. a n d M r s . J o h n
M eln ick .
j
COME MEET WITH YOUR CANDIDATES
OVER A CUP OF COFFEE
Ijj —? c p M e n nr s

A L90K f* TOU h
t

-4

c

JOHN L. MELNICK

JOHN L. MELNICK w h o r e s i d e s a t
5710 1 s t S t r e e t , S o u t h i s a l i f e l o n g
r e s id e n t o f A rlin gton , V irg in ia ,
a t t e n d e d W a s h in g to n L e e H ig h S c h o o l
a n d r e c e i v e d h i s B a c h e l o r a n d Law
D e g r e e s from th e U n iv e r s i t y o f V ir
gin ia .
Joh n i s m a r r ie d t o th e form er
M a rjory H e lt e r o f A rlin g to n , V ir g in ia ,
a t e a c h e r a t W a s h in g to n L ee H igh
S c h o o l f r o m 1957 t o 1960.
They h a v e
tw o s o n s , John and P a u l.
J o h n L. M e l n i c k s e r v e d A r l i n g t o n
f r o m 1961 t o 1963 a s A s s i s t a n t
C om m on w ealth A t t o r n e y and i s p r e s e n t l y
w i t h t h e law f i r m o f B a l l , M cC a rth y
&amp; B a ll.
He i s P r e s i d e n t o f t h e
Y o u n g D e m o c r a t s o f A r l i n g t o n , member
o f th e V ir g in ia A d v iso ry L e g i s la t i v e
C om m ittee, on th e B oa rd o f D ir e c t o r s
o f t h e A r l i n g t o n YMCA, m e m b e r o f t h e
E x e c u t iv e C om m ittee, A r l i n g t o n D i s t
r i c t Boy S c o u t s o f A m erica, i s a c t i v e
i n t h e K iw a n is C lu b o f A r l i n g t o n , and
i s T r e a s u r e r o f th e A r lin g t o n C ounty
Bar A s s o c i a t io n .
The M eln ick fa m ily
a t t e n d s C la r e n d o n M e t h o d is t C hurch.

NETTIE M. EAKES

;
i
j
I
j
!

N E TTIE M. EAKES h a s r e s i d e d a t
5654 8 t h R o a d , N o r t h , f o r t h e l a s t
tw elv e y ea rs.
She i s m a r rie d t o
J a ck E akes, th e u se d c a r m anager
f o r K ir b y ' s S a le s and S e r v ic e .
N e t t i e i s a n a t i v e A r l i n g t o n i a n and
a g r a d u a t e o f W a sh in g to n L ee H igh
S c h o o l and Duke U n i v e r s i t y .
She has
t h r e e c h i l d r e n , Chuck, J o h n n ie and
M argaret.
N e t t i e M. E a k e s i s a n a c t i v e
member o f t h e D e m o c r a t i c P a r t y , a
member o f t h e A r l i n g t o n W om en's
D e m o c r a t i c C l u b an d t h e Y ou n g Dem o
c r a t s o f A rlin gton .
She h a s w ork ed
a c t i v e l y i n ma ny n a t i o n a l , s t a t e a n d
lo c a l e le c tio n s .
B o t h Mr. a n d M r s .
E a k e s a r e m em bers o f t h e Kenm ore
a n d W a k e f i e l d PTA.
The E akes
f a m i ly a t t e n d s S t. A nn's C a t h o l i c
Church.

THE POLLS AT KENMORE JUNI OR HIGH
SCHOOL W ILL BE OPEN FROM 6 : 0 0 A. M.
i TO 7 : 0 0 P. M.
VOTE EARLY

a*************************---

If

you

need

a rid e

BE SURE TO VOTE ON JULY 13, 1965
t o t h e p o l l s , c a l l JA., 8-3 7 2 2
or

JA.. 8-7613

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="10">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="2122">
                  <text>RG 18: Personal Papers of Barbara Marx</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="14621">
                <text>Copy of The Glencarlyn Precinctor newsletter  re Democratic primary July 13, 1965.  Handwritten note on back.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="14622">
                <text>Copy of The Glencarlyn Precinctor newsletter  re Democratic primary July 13, 1965.  Handwritten note on back. On page, front and back</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="42">
            <name>Format</name>
            <description>The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="14623">
                <text>pdf</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="48">
            <name>Source</name>
            <description>A related resource from which the described resource is derived</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="14624">
                <text>RG 18, Personal Papers of Barbara Marx</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="39">
            <name>Creator</name>
            <description>An entity primarily responsible for making the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="14625">
                <text>Glencarlyn Precinctor</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="14626">
                <text>1965-07-13</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="38">
            <name>Coverage</name>
            <description>The spatial or temporal topic of the resource, the spatial applicability of the resource, or the jurisdiction under which the resource is relevant</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="14627">
                <text>1960s</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="47">
            <name>Rights</name>
            <description>Information about rights held in and over the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="14628">
                <text>This image is subject to copyright. Unauthorized use of the images in the Local History Collections of the Arlington Community Archives is prohibited.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="43">
            <name>Identifier</name>
            <description>An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="21786">
                <text>18_2_1_7_22</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="1956" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="1671">
        <src>https://projectdaps.org/files/original/a832786a01ed71ea4d468c0d1e0c78ee.pdf</src>
        <authentication>fec4c85d650f76722cee79ae1870223a</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="52">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="19646">
                    <text>UPI-152
UPI-152
FOR A ’S SUNDAY, FEB, 1
M
B H,L. STEVENSON
Y
UNITED PRESS INTERNATIONA!.
RICHM
OND, VA., JAN. 31 •— &lt;tIPI&gt;-•-VIRGINIA»5 PUBLIC SCHOOL EGREGATlOI! BARRIERS' WILL FALL M N A fT K M
O D Y A Y ILES FR M THE LITTLE T W W ER
O
ON H E
THE FIRST D A D FO INTEGRATION W
EM N S R
ERE M D
A E,
A GROUP OF NEGRO PARENTS A D CHILDREN FILED SUIT IN PRINCE ED A
N
U RD
COUNTY, VA,, O M Y 23, 1951, CHALLENGING THE VALIDITY O THE O D
M A
F
L
"SEPARATE BUT EQUAL" DOCTRINE OF PUBLIC SCHOOLS.
IT W S O THIS, CASE, A D FOUR OTHERS, THAT THE U.S. SUPREM COURT
A H
N
E
STRUCK D W THE DOCTRINE O M Y 17, 1950, PLUNGING VIRGINIA A D O ER
ON
H A
N TH
SOUTHERN STATES INTO A DRAW
N-OUT BATTLE TO M
AINTAIN SEGREGATIflr:.
M DAY, NEGRO A D W
M
N
HITE STUDENTS UILL G TO RIGIDLY SEGREGATED
O
SCHOOLS It! FARMVILIX A D OTHER COM UNITIffi IN PRIILCE ED A D COUNTY,
N
M
WR '
JUST A TH H V D N FO NEARLY EIGHT Y RS SINCE THE FIRST SUIT*
S EY A E O E R
EA
CO RT APPEALS A D A SEVEN CCQ} Y R D Y GRANTED-BY A FEDERAL J ’OGE
U
N
EA ELA
HV H
A E ELD UP INTEGRATION I!! PRINCE EDUARD. A APPEAL O THE L N
N
F
OG
DELAY G N
RA TED B JUDGE STERLING H TCH N IS STILL PENDING. ALL OF THE
Y
U ESO
STUDENTS IN TIE ORIGINAL CASE, H V G O N UP. M N H V PARRIED.
A E RW
AY A E
OE
M
H V M V D AUAY.
A E OE
M N A 'S INTEGRATION WILL CO E IN TH M
ODY
M
E ETROPOLITAN A S OF NORFOLK
REA
A D ARLINGTON, FAR R M V D FRO THE ROLLING FA LA D O PRINCE ED A D
N
E OE
M
RM N F
WR
COUNTY.
SEVENTEEN NEGROES A SCHEDULED TO ENTER SIP NORFOLK SCHOOL’ . FO L
RE
U
WILL ENROLL IN A ALL-WHITE JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL II! ARLINGTON.
N
W A H S THE STATE D N SINCE MAY 17, 10 5ft, TO TRY T CIRCUM
HT A
OE
O
VENT
INTEGRATION? W A W
H T ILL IT D IN THE FUTURE IP ITS DETERM
O
INATION TO,
FIND A N W BATTLEGROUND?
E
THE FIRST QUESTION C N B A SW
A E N ERED IN A M
OUNTAIN OF LEG BRIEFS,
AL
MILLIONS OF W R S O C U TR O TESTIMONY, T O CONFLICTING 3CCR- ir*S O
OD F OR OM
W
F
RESISTANCE A D TO COURT RULINGS W ICH TOPPLED THE W O W R S .
N
O
H
H LE O K
THE SE O D C N NOT B A SW
CN A
E N ERED TODAY. GOV. J . LINDSAT A M N H S
L OD A
PLEDGED THAT THE STATE WILL USE EVERY LEG M N IT CA M STER TO
AL EA S
N U
INSURE THAT INTEGRATION D ES NOT &lt;
O
PLEAD.

�AUICKD il/e STRONGLY HINTED THAT 11.:: . TATE ..A* ABANDON TAiiY 0.- ITS
*

PUBLIC ICHOOLS At!D TUB!! TO :O E COLT O PRIVATE , Y' TEH TILL TC BE
M
F
DE3IGNED BY A LEGISLATIVE COMMISSION.

IT WILL G TO VOLK It: THE NEAR
O

FUTURE.
A O D SU M N D A SPECIAL SESSION OF THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY TO TEAL
LM N
M OE
W
ITH TH CURRENT CIRIS.
E

HE PROPOSED TUITION GHAUTS FO STUDENTS TO
E

ATTEND PRIVATE SCHOOLS, AN OUTLET FO THE PARENTS W O DO NOT WISH TO
R
H
SEND THEIR CHILDREN TO INTEGRATED CLASSROOMS.
IT REPRESENTED, IN EFFECT, THE GOVERNOR’ S CONCESSION THAT TOKEN
INTEGRATION W S INEVITABLE AND HE BLUNTLY TOLD A SOM
A
BER OPENING DAY
SESSION OF THE ASSEM
BLY THAT THE STATE H
AD EMPTIED ITS LEGAL ARSENAL.
TH Oil) C M W E A SPECIAL THREE-JUDGE FEDERAL CONSTITUTIONAL
E
A E HN
COURT AND THE VIRGINIA SUPREME COURT RULED 12 DAYS A O THAT THE STATE'S
G
SO-CALLED "MASSIVE RESISTANCE" PRO RAM W S UNCONSTITUTIONAL.
G
A
"IN THIS STRUGGLE VIRGINIA H SEEN. 3 UBJECTED TO PRESSURES M R ■
AS
OE
RELENTLESS, BRUTISH A D FORMIDABLE TH N THAT APPLIED TO ANY OTHER STATE.
M
A
SHE H S PRESERVED H SYSTEM. OF PUBLIC SCHOOLS LO G TH N ANY STATE
A
ER
N ER
A
. W E E THE ISSUE H BEEN PRESSED.
HR
AS

SHE H NOT SURRENDERED AND SHE DO
AS
ES

NOT SURRENDER NOW," A O D SAID,
LM N
THE "MASSIVE RESISTANCE" PRO RAM W S EVOLVED IN 195S, LARGELY THE
G
A
RECOM ENDATION OF POW
M
ERFUL DEM
OCRATIC SEN. HARRY FLOOD BYRD.

IT’ S K Y
E

FEATURES W
ERE L W CUTTING OFF FUNDS TO SCHOOLS W
A S
HICH INTEGRATE,
TUITION GRANTS FOR PRIVATE SCHOOLS AND AUTHORIZATION TO THE GOVERNOR
T CLOSE ANY SCHOOL W ERE INTEGRATION OCCURRED.
O
H
TH LA S W
E W
ERE NOT CHALLENGED DIRECTLY AT FIRST.

FEDERAL DISTRICT

JUDGE W
ALTER E. HOFFMAN, W O O
H RDERED INTEGRATION IN NORFOLK, FIRST
OBSERVED THAT TH L W GIVING A THREE-M BER STATE BO RD THE PO E T
E A
EM
A
WR O
/ASSIGN STUDENTS FO TH ENTIRE STATE SEEMED "UNCONSTITUTIONAL O ITS
R E
N
FACE
FINALLY, IN TH A TU N OF 195S, A O D W S FORCED TO USE HIS SCHOOL
E U M
LM N
A
CLOSURE POW
ERS TO SHUTDOW SCHOOLS IN NORFOLK, CH LOTTES ’' ILLE AND
N
AR
FRONT ROYAL.
TH KEY L W W R IMMEDIATELY CHALLENGED.
E
A S EE

AND, AS A O D PUT IT,
LM N

TH "H M ER OF FEDERAL INTERVENTION FELL WITH DEVASTATING FORCE" O
E A M
N
JAN. 19, 1959.

"MASSIVE RESISTANCE" W S DEAD.
A
CM138A

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="3">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="85">
                  <text>RG 19, The Personal Papers of Elizabeth Pfohl Campbell</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
            <element elementId="41">
              <name>Description</name>
              <description>An account of the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="86">
                  <text>This collection consists of the personal papers of Elizabeth Pfohl Campbell, and  covers the period from 1945 through 1991, with the bulk of the material falling between 1947 and 1959.   The materials in this collection were generated or collected as a result of Mrs. Campbell's involvement in the Arlington County School Board, as well as her interests and  activities in education and local politics. &#13;
</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="19638">
                <text>Copy of UPI article regarding upcoming desegregation of Arlington and other Virginia schools on February 1, 1959.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="19639">
                <text>Copy of UPI article regarding upcoming desegregation of Arlington and other Virginia schools on February 1, 1959. 2 pages</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="42">
            <name>Format</name>
            <description>The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="19640">
                <text>pdf</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="48">
            <name>Source</name>
            <description>A related resource from which the described resource is derived</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="19641">
                <text>RG 19, The Personal Papers of Elizabeth Pfohl Campbell</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="39">
            <name>Creator</name>
            <description>An entity primarily responsible for making the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="19642">
                <text>United Press International</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="19643">
                <text>1959-02-01</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="38">
            <name>Coverage</name>
            <description>The spatial or temporal topic of the resource, the spatial applicability of the resource, or the jurisdiction under which the resource is relevant</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="19644">
                <text>1950s</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="47">
            <name>Rights</name>
            <description>Information about rights held in and over the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="19645">
                <text>This image is subject to copyright. Unauthorized use of the images in the Local History Collections of the Arlington Community Archives is prohibited.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="43">
            <name>Identifier</name>
            <description>An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="22257">
                <text>19_5_2_1_1</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="1201" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="997">
        <src>https://projectdaps.org/files/original/ec72171cce8a5bc3157cea443d8e709c.pdf</src>
        <authentication>9721cee4b2fef2c773081c93d1689d46</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="52">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="12723">
                    <text>VIRGINIA STATE CONFERENCE-NAACP
4042 North Second Street
Richmond, Virginia
July 29, 1959

TO

Members of Legal Staff and Board Members
Virginia State Conference-NAACP

FROM

Office of Executive Secretary

RE

Boatwright Committee Interrogatories

Attached for your information and appraisal are inter­
rogatories directed to the NAACP through its agent,
Oliver W. Hill, and to the Conference through its
Executive Secretary. As you can see, they are almost
identical except for the returnable dates (August 5
and August 10, respectively).
Will advise as to the disposition after conferences
have been held with attorneys.
WLB/oewp
Enclosures (2)

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="10">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="2122">
                  <text>RG 18: Personal Papers of Barbara Marx</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12715">
                <text>Correspondence between The Office of Executive Secretary of the Virginia State Conference-NAACP and the Members of Legal Staff and Board Members of the Virginia State Conference-NAACP, July 29, 1959</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12716">
                <text>Memo enclosing two interrogatories directed to the NAACP and the Conference. Refers to 18-1-11-1-4 and 18-1-11-1-2 </text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="42">
            <name>Format</name>
            <description>The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12717">
                <text>pdf</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="48">
            <name>Source</name>
            <description>A related resource from which the described resource is derived</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12718">
                <text>RG 18, Personal Papers of Barbara Marx</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="39">
            <name>Creator</name>
            <description>An entity primarily responsible for making the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12719">
                <text>Virginia State Conference - NAACP</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12720">
                <text>1959-07-29</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="38">
            <name>Coverage</name>
            <description>The spatial or temporal topic of the resource, the spatial applicability of the resource, or the jurisdiction under which the resource is relevant</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12721">
                <text>1950s</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="47">
            <name>Rights</name>
            <description>Information about rights held in and over the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12722">
                <text>This image is subject to copyright. Unauthorized use of the images in the Local History Collections of the Arlington Community Archives is prohibited.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="43">
            <name>Identifier</name>
            <description>An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="21598">
                <text>18_1_11_1_1</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="1256" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="1020">
        <src>https://projectdaps.org/files/original/c3f91a1507a08f3aa78cbd6e85455419.pdf</src>
        <authentication>af6b8f6f4b1413f59e7c45750844d6a5</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="52">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="13025">
                    <text>C O U N C I L OP P A R E N T - T E A C H E R A S S O C I A T I O N S
ALEXANDRIA,

VIRGINIA

March 10, 3,955

T o t h e A l e x a n d r i a C o u n c i l o f PTAs:
H e r e w i t h is s u b m i t t e d a " Pact S h e e t " i n r e s p o n s e t o the
J u n e 3, 1 9 5 4 r e s o l u t i o n o f the A l e x a n d r i a C o u n c i l of P T A s .
T h e r e s o l u t i o n d i r e c t e d t h e C o o r d i n a t i n g C o m m i t t e e to “m a k e a
study of i n t e gration in Alexai d r i a and submit a report, after
v/hieh it w o u l d b o s u b m i t t e d to t he l o c a l P T A s . "
T h e C o o r d i n a t i n g C o m m i t t e e p r e p a r i n g t his r e p o r t w a s
c o m p o s e d of the p r e s i d e n t o f e a c h P T A o r h i s r e p r e s e n t a t i v e
f r o m b o t h t h e A l e x a n d r i a C o u n c i l of P a r e n t - T e a c h e r A s s o c i a t i o n s
a nd A l e x a n d r a i C i t y - W i d e P a r o n t - T a a c h e r C o u n c i l .
Facts wore
g a t h e r e d , a m o n g o t h e r s o u r c e s , f r o m M r . T. C. W i l l i a m s ,
S u p e r i n t e n d e n t of S c h o o l s , i n A l e x a n d r i a , b o t h i n v;riting a n d
t h r o u g h p e r s o n a l i n t e r v i e w s , a n d f r o m the V i r g i n i a E d u c a t i o n
Association.
T h e C o o r d i n a t i n g C o m m i t t o o S o u n d t hat e d u c a t i o n a l f a c t o r s
w e r e c o m p l e x i n t h o m s e l v e s and i n t e r r e l a t e d w i t h e c o n o m i c
f a c t o r s , m a k i n g d i f f i c u l t the l i m i t a t i o n of f a c t s to a b r i o f ,
a d e q u a t e and o b j o c t i v o p r e s e n t a t i o n ,
Tho qu e s t i o n s considered
w e r e t h o s e w h i c h s o o m o d o f g e n e r a l i n t e r e s t to m e m b e r s of the
Coordinating Committoo.
T he C o m m i t t e e is w i l l i n g to t r y to
o b t a i n a n s w e r s t o a n y q u e s t i o n s w h i c h m a y h a v e b e o n o m i t t e d or
w h i c h m a y arise lator.
Mrs. S . W . Livingston, Chaltman
Coordinating Committoo
Alexandria
Council of ParontToachor Associations

�COUNCIL C? PtqSHT-WWACHWR ASSOCIATIONS
a l e x a : o ri a ,
t

Vi r g i n i a

Report of Coordinating Committee
(as directed by resolution or June 3. 1054)

ETnOLIiLSHT

1.

;hc present enrollment

What

Total

White
7,886
2.000

Colored
1,053
450

Total
3,039
2,450

9,806

As of February 1955
Elementary
High School

2.

udenis in Alexandria?

1,505

11,389

What are the numbers of children in oach school
number of child ren per clas spoon teachcr?

As of February 1955
Goorgo Washington I igh School
I
•-K i 'arljcr-C-ray high School
Jefferson School - 8th Grade)
elementary)
Charles Barrett
-::-Lylcs-Crouch
Theodore Pieklin
Patrick Henry
•••'Charles Houston
Minnie Howard
Stonewall Jackson
Robert E, Lee
Douglas MacArthur
George Mason
Maury
Mt.. Vernon

Total Ho,
of Children
2,000
450
866
501
3 55
405
333
700
569
296
944
462
759
•573
1,678
117359

Ho „ of
Teacher:
78
24
23
10
17
10
13
28
24
19
11
31
15
24
19
50
~393

1 the average
Average
Children
•per tanchor
25.5
18,0
25.9
27.1
29.5
35.3
51.1

29.7
2G.1
29.9
26.9
30.4
30.8
31.6
30.2
53.6

28.8

•iKColorsd )
3.

What is the rate of increase of white and colored school en
rollment?
The white enrollment increased by 901 pupils, or 10$,
from September 1953-1954, The colorod enrollment increased
by 31 pupil3, or 2$ during tho decrease from the 20$ colorod
enrollment of twenty years ago. The chiof enrollment factor
would thU3 scorn to be tho rapid increase in white enrollment.'

4.

What is tho most common age for dropping out?
Sixteen (16) years, tho ago at which compulsory attendance
snds, is the most common ago for all students to drop out.

5.

What gercontage of students drop out before finishing high
George Washington
Parker-Gray

33-1/3$
40 - 50$

�3

COURSE OF STUDY AMD ACHIEVEMENT TESTS
6,
.

Aro the courses of study tho same in all schools.?
Yes.. In both elementary and high schools, the courses
and their content are tho same. Children graduating from all
elementary or high schools have studied tho samo subjects and
are expected to havo acquirod tho same knowlodgo.

7.

Are tho materials, toxt books, e c , , studied in all schools
t..
tho samo?
You, All olamont’
-ry schools got oxactly the samo text
books and other materials. Tho texts aro soloctod from Stateapprovod lists on tho rocommondation of a committco of toachors
from all tho schools and aro used in all tho schools after
approval by tho School Board,.
In tho high schools altornativo texts aro soloctod from
State-approved lists, and individual toachors may choose from
tho soloqtion.

8.

Aro tho standards for
all schools?

promotion and graduation tho samo in

Yos,
9.

Aro both high schools accredited?
Yos. Both Goorgo Washington and Parkcr-Gray aro accrodiSchools^1 0 ®outk°rn association of Ccllogos and Secondary
1

10.

What havo boon tho results of tho national achiovomont tosts
givon in Alexandria?
In thoso tosts, which aro furnished and scored by tho
stpto, tho avorago of all children in Aloxandria is about two
months abovo tho national avorago ovor t ho last fivo yoars.,
Tho whito children havo avoragod six months ovor tho national
and tho colorod children havo avoragod 2-1/2 years bolow tho
national avorago.
Tho national achiovomont tpsts.moasuro,
primarily roading,
vocabulary-and artxthmctical abilities and do not moasuro
mechanical, artistic and human relations capacitios.' Thoro is
already within any givon classroom, whito or colorod, a range'
in ability of our to fivo grados as moasurod by thoso tests,
Thoro is also a wido rango of ability in any givon child, as
b o t w o o n roading and arithmetic, for instanco.
Thus, tho prob
lem of rango is not now and is ono with which ail public school
toachors aro prepared to work.

11,

What difforonco in avoragos in thoso achiovomont tosts oxists
now in individual classes and among schools?
Difforonccs in avoragos in thoso tosts of four to fivo'
yoars aro common within tho samo grado lovol in all schools.
HEALTH

12.

What aro tho comparative Statistics on health of colorod and
whito childron?
A lottor'from D r . T. F, MeGough, Diroctor of Public Health
in Aloxandria, prosonts tho following information in rosponso
to contain specific questions askod hinis

�4

"1) During tho last six years no active pulmonary tuber
culosis has boon ropertod in tho Alexandria City Schools
(whito or colorod),
"2) Hoad lico aro uncommon or unknown in tho colorod
school children* Ono reason for this negative finding is prob
ably tho relative shortness of hair on tho head, Hoad lico
havo boon discovered occasionally in our whito school childron.
This has not boon considorod a major problem in our school
health program*
"3) During tho past six years, no syphilis or gonorrhoas
has boon found in any of our elementary or high school childron
(whito or colored),
’
*4) Ringworm of tho scalp occurs raroly in tho v;hito and
colored childron quantitatively a minor problem,
”5) Body odors aro notod in both racos, if hygionic
practicos aro not maintained."
TEACHERS
13,

How many tcachors arc thoro in tho schools of Aloxandria?
Total classroom - 396,

14,

Aro tho qualifications for toachors tho samo in all schools?
Yos,

15,

What is tho proportion of bacholor's, master's, and doctor's
dogrocs among tho toachors?
Tho percentage of white toachors who havo at loast a
bacholor's degree is 95,5$. Tho pcrcontago of colorod toachors
witji at least a bacholor's dogreo is 91$, Twonty porcont
(20a1 of tho white toachors and 22.5$ of tho colorod toachors
)
havo master's degrees. Two whito toachors havo doctorates,

16,

What is tho cost por pupil of toachors' salaries?
These woro for tho 1953*1954 sossion as f Hows!
Colorod clomontary
Whito olemontary
Colorod high school
Whito high school

$

157.32
188,19
206.27
162,31

It should bo notod that all of tho whito special teachers
who also work with the colorod studonts (such as attendance
officer, visiting toachors, physical oducation supervisor,
director of instruction..supervisor, of industrial arts, remedial
reading, spoocn and hearing fhcragpists; aro charged against
the whito pupil costs and aro not prorated botwoon whito and
cclorod, Tho overall cost of cduca.ting tho pupil in the City
schools in 1953-J.954, high or clomontary, was :tf258,60. This
includes all costs, 3 U C h as salaries and•operation costs,
except for building costs. Incidentally^ tho X , S, avorago is
J
$247,00 and the Virginia avorago $185.00,
17,

Thcro aro a largo numbor of cities and counties intho Stato of
Virginia whoro toachors arc allowed to toach with sub-standard
certificates; aro thoro any such tcachors in tho Aloxandria
systom?
Thoro aro none, Moroovor, only 8$ of tho colorod toachors
in tho Stato hold sub-standard certificates as compared with
12$ of tho whito toachors who hold sub-standard certificates.
Of Virginia's colorod toachors, 86,8$ hold dogroos as compared
with 66,7$ hold by whito toachors; 94,4$ of all Aloxandria
toachors hold dogroos, our City ranking third in tho Stato in
this rospoct.

�5.
18,

Aro the colored students provided with as man;/ special teachors
for music, speech, remedial reading, instrumental music, and
so forth, as arc tho white students?
Yes, Tho colored pupils got tho samo scrvicos from special
personnel as others, but not necessarily from colorod special
personnel; that is, there aro special v/hito teachers who toach
at tho colorod schools, although there'aro no special colored
toachors teaching at tho v/hito schools, Tho art and music
personnel aro colorod, as aro tho shop toachors in tho colorod
schools,

19,

Aro tho principals and toachors in all schools givontho sane
in-sorivoe training?
Yos.

20,

Aro thoro any colorod administrative officors i n t h o Alexandria
schools having city-wido functions?
No, The burdon of administration and'suporvision falls
on tho principal of oach individual school. This program v/as
institutod about five years ago and actually provides bottor
suporvi'ion of toachors and bottor administration in tho schools
. than v/ould suporvidion from a contral offico of tho Superin
tendent of Schools,

21,

What is tho turnovor of toachors?
Of tho 360 white toachors in 1953 and 1954, 20 did not
return in 1954-55. In tho 1953-54 year, of tho 56 colored
toachors, only 1 did not return in 1954-55. Tho porcontago
of thoso leaving Alexandria Schools who do not continue in tho
teaching profession is 60$ for the white toachors and soro for
tho colored toachors. Inoidontally, Alexandria had the lowest
porcontago of teacher turnovor of all tho cities in tho Stato
of Virginia,
SCHOOL BUILDINGS

22,

What is tho number of schools for colorod childron, tho ago
of tho school buildings, tho safoty fcaturos?
Thcro aro throo colored schools: Parker-Gray Hifpi School
was built in 1950 - it is modern, firo-rosistant building,
Bharlos Houston was built about 1915, it is not a firo resis
tant building. This building has an auditorium, a oafotoria
in tho basement (as havo Jofforson and Jackson Schools), and
it is using basement and other rooms for class rooms (as is Mt.
Vornon). The Lylos-Crouch School was originally built as a
factory fifty yoar3 ago.

23,

Aro tho school facilitios in Alexandria equal?
The Lyles- Crouch School, as is woll known, is not up to
general standard of the City, Stops aro boing taken to remedy
this and the City Council is boing asked by the School'Board
and tho Superintendent of Schools to build a now Lyic s-Crzuch.
School. The Charles Houston School compares favorably with '
tho Joffcr3on Annox, M t . Vornon Main Building, Barrett Annex,
Stonewall Jackson and MaoArthur Annox. None of tho old buildings
compare favorably with tho now buildings. Playgrounds op most
of the older schools, althrough woll-oquippsd by tho Recreation
Dopartment, are smaller than they should be. Tho Parker-Gray
High School is more m o d e m in plant and equipment than the
George Washington High School and accomodates its enrollment
much hotter, though it has only a combination gymnasium-auditor-

�6

24.

.

Aro tho two high schools comparable as to valuo of shop equip
ment?
Tho ostimatod value of tho equipment in the Goorgo Wash
ington High School shop is much largoa than that in tho Parkor
Gray shop, though whether it is greater than tho difference in
numbers of students (2,000 compared with 450) is difficult to
state. The extra equipment at Googo Washington makes possible
wider experience in the shop, Tho larger part of tho equipment
was given by the Navy Department during the last waj» for use
in an area training center at George Washington,a t no cost to
the taxpayers of Alexandria.

25.

Are other facilities, such as libraries, cafeterias, and so
forth, comparable in tho schools?
All schools libraries aro equipped with mininum books
considered necessary by the State on the basis of enrollment.
Some of the schools havo bigger and bettor libraries, a largor
selection and greater variety of books, because many of the
PTAs buy books every year for tho schools and the PTAs which
aro able to provide more money aro ablo to buy more books.
Lunnhos for school children in all oafoterais inwall'the schools
are provided on the same basis and at similar prices.
SC H O O L ZONES

26.

If the present geographic boundaries romained tho same under an
integrated school system, what would the ratio of white to
colored students be in each school?
This is difficult to answer because present school zones,
whito and colorod, especially downtown, ovorlap'or.ch other.
In tho territory west and north of the railroad, for olomontary
schools, and using presont school boundaries, ratios aro about
as follows: Barrett and Cora Kolly would havo about three
colored studen:s; Mt. Vernon would have several; Minnie
Howard would havo a ratio of about onocolorod to eleven white
pupils; Patrick Henry would have a ratio of about ono colorod
to ninotoon whito pupils; Maury might havo ono or two colorod
pupils; tho Stonewall Jackson, George Mason and MacArthur
Schools would havo none. Tho downtown zones completely ovorlap
at present and it is impossible to assign ratios for each
school. However, tho total enrollment of the five downtown
schools - Jefferson, Houston, Ficklin, Lyles-Crouch and Robert
E. Loe - shows 1,641 white students and 1,032 colorod students,
or a ratio of about 60$ whito to 40$ colored (as'of September
1954), This, on a total basis for thoso schools, la two
colorod studonts in every group of five pupils,
For the high schools there would be a ratio of about'one
colored pupil to every six pupils onrollod. Hero, again, tho
present zones complotoly ovorlap.

27.

Are any plans being readied for relocation of the boundaries
if tho schools arc to become integrated soon?
No new zoning has been discussed by tho School Board or
the Superintondon: cf Schools,

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="10">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="2122">
                  <text>RG 18: Personal Papers of Barbara Marx</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="13017">
                <text>Council Of Parent-Teacher Association Alexandria, Virginia, March 10, 1955</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="13018">
                <text>6 page "fact sheet" document authored and issued by the Council Of Parent-Teacher Association Alexandria, Virginia, March 10, 1955 to the general Alexandria Council of PTAs, in response to a request by the Coordinating Committee to submit a report about integration of public schools in Alexandria. Includes demographic information, study and achievement tests, teachers, school buildings, and school zones.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="42">
            <name>Format</name>
            <description>The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="13019">
                <text>pdf</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="48">
            <name>Source</name>
            <description>A related resource from which the described resource is derived</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="13020">
                <text>RG 18, Personal Papers of Barbara Marx</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="39">
            <name>Creator</name>
            <description>An entity primarily responsible for making the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="13021">
                <text>Council Of Parent-Teacher Association, Alexandria, Virginia</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="13022">
                <text>1955-03-10</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="38">
            <name>Coverage</name>
            <description>The spatial or temporal topic of the resource, the spatial applicability of the resource, or the jurisdiction under which the resource is relevant</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="13023">
                <text>1950s</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="47">
            <name>Rights</name>
            <description>Information about rights held in and over the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="13024">
                <text>This image is subject to copyright. Unauthorized use of the images in the Local History Collections of the Arlington Community Archives is prohibited.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="43">
            <name>Identifier</name>
            <description>An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="21629">
                <text>18_2_1_2_25</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="1257" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="1021">
        <src>https://projectdaps.org/files/original/9fd54aa89da03f806c3c95c3a6115e26.pdf</src>
        <authentication>6855195536a4660c3d4412530477202d</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="52">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="13035">
                    <text>COUNCIL OP PARENT-TEACHER ASSOCIATIONS
ALEXANDRIA, VIRGINIA

March 10, 1955

To the Alexandria Council of PTAs:
Herewith is submitted a "Pact Sheet" in response to the
June 3, 1954 resolution of the Alexandria Council of PTAs,
The resolution directed the Coordinating Committee to “make a
study of integration in Alexandria and submit a reporl}, after
which it would bo submitted to the local PTAs.1
*
The Coordinating Committee preparing this report was
composed of the president of each PTA or his representative
from both the Alexandria Council of Parent-Teacher Associations
and Alexandrai City-Wide Paront-Teacher Council, Pacts wore
gathered, among other sources, from Mr. T. C, Williams,
Superintendent of Schools, in Alexandria, both in writing and
through personal interviows, and from the Virginia Education
Association,
The Coordinating Committoe found that educational factors
were complex in thomselves and interrelated with economic
factors, making difficult the limitation of facts to a brief,
adequate and objective presentation. The questions considered
wore those which soomed of general interest to members of the
Coordinating Committee, The Committee is willing to try to
obtain answers to any quostions which may havo beon omittod or
which may arise later,
Mrs. S. W, Liviiigaton, Chaitfcman
Coordinating Committoo
Alexandria Coqjtcil of ParentTeacher Associations

�2

c o m c iL

o f

iiy a t ^ - t e a c h e r

associatioes

a l e x a a o r i a . v i ~g i s i a

Report of Coordinating Committee
(as directed by resolution of June 3, 1954)

ESrilOLUIEHT
1.

What is the present enrollment

students in Alo:•.c.ndria?

Total

White
7,886
2,000

Colored
1,053
450

Total
8,939
2,450

9,886

As of February 1955
Elementary
High School

1,505

11,389

Vihat aro the number,s of children in each school and tho a vorogo
number of children per classroom teacher?
Average
Children
Total Ho, Ho, of
As of February 1955
of Childgon Teacher:
per teacher
2.

C-eorgo Washington High School
'-Parkcr-C-ray high School
Joffcrson School - 8th Crado)
elementary)
Charles Larrctt
'-Lyles-Crouch
Theodore Fidelia
Patrick Eonry
'-Charles Houston
Minnie Howard
Stonevfall Jackson
Robert E, Lee
Douglas MacArthur
George Mason
Maury
Mt, Vernon

2.000
450
866
501
355
405
853
700
569
296
944
462
759
•573
1^678
ITT^SsT

78
24
23
10
17
10
13
28
24
19
11
31
15
24
19
50

25.5
18.0
25.9
27.1
29.5
o 5 ,3

31.1
29.7
20.1
29.9
26.9
30.4
30.8
31.6
30.2
55.6

28.8

-^-(Colored )
3.

What is the rate of increase of white and colored school en~
rollment?
The white enrollment increased by 901 pupils, or 10%,
from September 1953-1954, The colored enrollment increased
by 31 pupils, or 2% during the decrease from the 20% colored
enrollment of twenty yoars ago. The chief enrollment factor
would thus soem to bo tho rapid increaso in white enrollment,

4.

What is the most common ago for dropping out?
Sixteen (16) years, tho ago at which compulsory attendance
ends, is the most common ago for all students to drop out,

5.

What percentage of students drop out before finishing high
school?
George 'Washington
Parker-Gray

33-1/3%
40 - 50%

�COURSE OF STUDY AMD ACHIEVEMENT TESTS
Are the courses of study the same in all schools?
Yes. In both elementary and high schools, the courses
and their content are the same. Childron graduating from all
elementary or high schools have studied the same subjects and
are expected to have acquired tho same knowledge.
Are the materials, toxt books, etc,, studied in all schools
the same?
Yes. All elementary schools get exactly tho samo text
books and othor materials. The toxts are soloctod from Stateapproved lists on tho recommendation of a committoo of tcachors
from all the schools and aro used in all tho schools a.ftor
approval by tho School Board.
In tho high schools alternative texts aro selected from
State-approved lists, and individual tcachors may choose from
tho soloqtion.
Aro tho standards for
all schools?

promotion and graduation tho samo in

Yos.
Aro both high schools accredited?
Yos. Both Goorgo Washington and Parker-Gray arc accrcdiSchcoJs^0
Association of Cc-llogos and Socondary
What havo boon tho rosults of tho national achiovomont tosts
given in Alexandria?
In thoso tests, which aro furnished and scored by tho
st-to, the avorago of all childron in Aloxanaria is about two
months ^abovo tho national avorago ovortho last fivo yoars,
The whito childron havo avoragod six months ovor tho national
and the colored childron havo averaged 2-1/2 years bolov; tho
national avorago.
Tho national chioyomont to 3 .monsuro,
primarily roading,
vocabulary and artltt
bhnotical aba fcios and do not moasuro
mechanical, artistic and human relations capacitios. Thoro is
already within any givon classroom, whito or colorod, a rangO
in ability of our to fivo grados as measured by thoso tosts.
Thoro is also a wido rango of ability in any given child, as
botwoon reading and nritbmqtic, for instanco. Thus, tho problom of rango is not now and is ono with which all public school
toachcrs a.ro proparod to work.
What difforcnco in averages in thoso achiovomont tosts exists
now in individual classes and among schools?
Difforoncos in avorages in thoso tosts of four to fivo'
yoars aro common within tho samo grado lovol in all schools.
HEALTH
What aro tho comparative statistics on hoalth of colorod and
whito childron?
A lottor'from D r . T, P. McGough, Director of Public Hoalth
in Alexandria, prosonts tho following information in rosponso
to oortain specific questions askod him:

�4

”1) During tho Inst six years nc active pulmonary tuber
culosis has boon reported in tho Alexandria City Schools
(whito or colored) .
"2) Hoad lico aro uncommon or unknown in tho colorod
school chiidron; One reason for this negative finding is probr
ably tho relative shortness of hair on tho head; Hoad lico
havo been discovered occasionally in our white school chiidron*
This has not boon considered a major problem in our school
health program;
"3) During tho past six yoars, no syphilis or gonorrheas
has boon found in any of our olomontary or high school children
(whito or colorod).
”4) Ringworm of tho scalp occurs raroly in tho whito and
colorod chiidron quantit&amp;tivoly a minor problem.
"5) Body odors aro notod in both races, if hygionic
praoticos aro not maintained *”
TEACHERS
13,

How many toaohors arc thoro in tho schools of Alexandria?

14*

Aro tho qualifications for toaohors tho samo in all schools?

Total classroom - 396,

Xos.
15;

What is tho proportion of bachelor's, mastor's, and doctor's
dogrocs among tho toaohors?
Tho porcontc.go of white toaohors who havo at least a
bacholor's dogreo is 95,5$; Tho percentage of colorod toaohors
witla at least a ba.chclnr's dogreo is 91$; Twenty percent
(20^) of the white toaohors and 22;5$ of tho colorod toaohors
have mastor's degrees. Two whito toaohors havo doctorates*

16;

What is tho cost por pupil of toaohors' salaries?
These woro for tho 1953-1954 sossion as f Hows:
Colorod olomontary
Whito olomontary
Colorod high school
Whito high school

$

157.32
188,19
206,27
162;31

It should bo noted that all of tho whito special toaohors
v/ho also work with the colorod students (such as attendance
remedial
ninst
tho whito pupil costs and arc not prorated betwoen whito and
colorod; Tho overall cost of oduoating tho pupil in the City
schools in 1953-J.954, high or olomontary; was §258*60* This
j.ncludos all costs, 3uch as salaries and operation costs,
oxoopt for building costs* Incidentally, tho U* S. averago is
#247j00 and the Virginia averago $185*00;
17.

Thcro aro a large number of cities and euntios intho Stato of
Virginia whoro toaohors are allowed to teach with sub-standard
certificates; aro thoro any such teachers in the Alexandria
systom?
There aro nono, Moroovorj only 8$ of tho colorod toachors
in tho Stato hold sub-standard certificates as compared vd th
12$ of tho whito toaohors who h-ld sub-standard cortifioatos;
Of Virginia's colorod toaohors; 86;8$ hold dogrets as compared
with 66.7$ hold by whito teachers; 94.4$ cf all Alexandria
toaohors hold degrees, our City ranking third in the Stato in
this rospoot;

�Aro the colored studonts provldod with, as many special toachors
for music, spooch, romodial reading, instrumental music, and
so forth, as are the white students?
Yes, Tho colored pupils got the same services from special
personnel as othors, but net necessarily from colorod special
porscnnol; that is, there aro special white toachors who toach
at tho colored schools, although there'aro no special colorod
toachors toaching at tho v/hito schools, Tho art and music
pcrsonnol aro colorod, as aro tho shop toachors in the colorod
schools,
Aro tho principals and toachors in all schools givontho samo
in-sorivee training?
Yes,
Aro thoro any colorod administrative officors i n t h o Alexandria
schools having city-oido functions?
No, Tho burden of administrate on and'supervision falls
on tho principal of oach individual school. This program v/as
institutod about fivo years ago and actually provides bettor
suporvi’ion of toachors and bottor administration in tho schools
than would supervision from a contral offico of tho Superin
tendent of Schools.
What is tho turnovor of toachors?
Of tho 360 white toachors in 1953 and 1954, 20 did not
return in 1954-55, In the 1953-54 year, of tho 56 colorod
teachers, only 1 did not return in 1954-55. Tho porcontago
of thoso leaving Alexandria Schools who do not continuo in tho
toaching profession is 60^ for the white toachors and zoro for
the colorod toachors. Incidentally, Alexandria had the lowest
porcontago of teacher turnovor of all tho cities in tho State
of Virginia,
SCHOOL BUILDINGS
What is tho number of schools for colorod childron, tho ago
of tho school buildings, tho safety features?
There aro throo colorod schools; Parkor-Gray High School
was built in 1950 - it is modern, firo-rosistant building,
Bharlos Houston was built about 1915, it is not a firo rosistant building0 This building has an auditorium, a cafot oria
in tho basomont (as have Jofforson and Jackson Schools;, and
it is using basement and other ro ms for class rooms (as is Mt.
Vornon). Tho Lylcs-Crouch School was originally built as a
factory fifty yoars ago,
Aro tho school facilitios in Alexandria equal?
Tho Lyles Crouch School, as is woll known, is not up to
general standard of tho City, Steps aro being taken to remedy
this and the City Council is being asked by tho School Board
and tho Superintendent jf Schools to build a now Lylo s-Cr;:uch
School, The Charlos Houston School compares favorably with •
tho Jefferson Annex, Mt. Vornon Main Building, Barrett Annex,
Stonowall Jackson and MacArthur Annox. Nona of tho old buildings
compare favorably with the now buildings. Playgrounds of most
of tho older schools, althrough woll-oquipped by tho Recreation
Dopnrtmont, aro smaller than they should bo. The Parkor-Gray
High School is more modern in plant and equipment than tha
Goorgo Washington High School and accomodatos its enrollment
much better, though it has only a combination gymnasium-auditor
ium.

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="10">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="2122">
                  <text>RG 18: Personal Papers of Barbara Marx</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="13027">
                <text>Council Of Parent-Teacher Association Alexandria, Virginia, March 10, 1955</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="13028">
                <text>6 page "fact sheet" document authored and issued by the Council Of Parent-Teacher Association Alexandria, Virginia, March 10, 1955 to the general Alexandria Council of PTAs, in response to a request by the Coordinating Committee to submit a report about integration of public schools in Alexandria. Includes demographic information, study and achievement tests, teachers, school buildings, and school zones.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="42">
            <name>Format</name>
            <description>The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="13029">
                <text>pdf</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="48">
            <name>Source</name>
            <description>A related resource from which the described resource is derived</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="13030">
                <text>RG 18, Personal Papers of Barbara Marx</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="39">
            <name>Creator</name>
            <description>An entity primarily responsible for making the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="13031">
                <text>Council Of Parent-Teacher Association, Alexandria, Virginia</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="13032">
                <text>1955-03-10</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="38">
            <name>Coverage</name>
            <description>The spatial or temporal topic of the resource, the spatial applicability of the resource, or the jurisdiction under which the resource is relevant</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="13033">
                <text>1950s</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="47">
            <name>Rights</name>
            <description>Information about rights held in and over the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="13034">
                <text>This image is subject to copyright. Unauthorized use of the images in the Local History Collections of the Arlington Community Archives is prohibited.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="43">
            <name>Identifier</name>
            <description>An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="21630">
                <text>18_2_1_2_31</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="64" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="74">
        <src>https://projectdaps.org/files/original/e3173a32ace6dc7184e68fb1f4c40683.jpg</src>
        <authentication>38b7207e5910d01280b6ab86e9ae8e3e</authentication>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="5">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="150">
                  <text>RG 307, The George Melvin Richardson Collection</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
            <element elementId="41">
              <name>Description</name>
              <description>An account of the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="151">
                  <text>Papers donated by George Melvin Richardson, former principal of Hoffman-Boston Junior-Senior High School.</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <itemType itemTypeId="6">
      <name>Still Image</name>
      <description>A static visual representation. Examples include paintings, drawings, graphic designs, plans and maps. Recommended best practice is to assign the type Text to images of textual materials.</description>
    </itemType>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="482">
                <text>Couple</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="483">
                <text>Hoffman-Boston students, one boy and one girl, sit on decorative throne at formal dress dance. Girl wears a tiara.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="42">
            <name>Format</name>
            <description>The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="484">
                <text>Black and white photograph</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="48">
            <name>Source</name>
            <description>A related resource from which the described resource is derived</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="485">
                <text>RG 307, The George Melvin Richardson Collection</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="38">
            <name>Coverage</name>
            <description>The spatial or temporal topic of the resource, the spatial applicability of the resource, or the jurisdiction under which the resource is relevant</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="486">
                <text>1950s</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="47">
            <name>Rights</name>
            <description>Information about rights held in and over the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="487">
                <text>This image is subject to copyright. Unauthorized use of the images in the Local History Photograph Collections of the Arlington Community Archives is prohibited.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="43">
            <name>Identifier</name>
            <description>An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="20819">
                <text>307_0049</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="65" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="75">
        <src>https://projectdaps.org/files/original/612d670d52d192b84a93d9928c5cd537.jpg</src>
        <authentication>78f03315d5f50bc89f28cde908830db8</authentication>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="5">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="150">
                  <text>RG 307, The George Melvin Richardson Collection</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
            <element elementId="41">
              <name>Description</name>
              <description>An account of the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="151">
                  <text>Papers donated by George Melvin Richardson, former principal of Hoffman-Boston Junior-Senior High School.</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <itemType itemTypeId="6">
      <name>Still Image</name>
      <description>A static visual representation. Examples include paintings, drawings, graphic designs, plans and maps. Recommended best practice is to assign the type Text to images of textual materials.</description>
    </itemType>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="489">
                <text>Couple</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="490">
                <text>Hoffman-Boston students in formal dress, a boy and a girl, stand arms linked, wearing crowns. </text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="42">
            <name>Format</name>
            <description>The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="491">
                <text>Black and white photograph</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="48">
            <name>Source</name>
            <description>A related resource from which the described resource is derived</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="492">
                <text>RG 307, The George Melvin Richardson Collection</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="38">
            <name>Coverage</name>
            <description>The spatial or temporal topic of the resource, the spatial applicability of the resource, or the jurisdiction under which the resource is relevant</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="493">
                <text>1950s</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="47">
            <name>Rights</name>
            <description>Information about rights held in and over the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="494">
                <text>This image is subject to copyright. Unauthorized use of the images in the Local History Photograph Collections of the Arlington Community Archives is prohibited.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="43">
            <name>Identifier</name>
            <description>An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="20820">
                <text>307_0050</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="718" public="1" featured="1">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="496">
        <src>https://projectdaps.org/files/original/538602ad249b0c5356dfdd1fba20154b.jpg</src>
        <authentication>d8e4abb3e601edb07a305fd8ee0d5656</authentication>
      </file>
      <file fileId="497">
        <src>https://projectdaps.org/files/original/31c1226d137951dbdcbbfbc929741ab7.pdf</src>
        <authentication>62669c2f55202594a7329cb99d3d61c1</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="52">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="8065">
                    <text>1 T THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE
S
EASTERN DISTRICT OF VIRGINIA
At Alexandria

CLARISSA S. THOMPSON,et al.

)

)
v.

)

Civil13^1

'i

COUNTY SCHOOL BOARD OF
ARLINGTON COUNTY,
VIRGINIA, et al

)
)
)

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Now, for the first time, this case comes before the court
upon an assignment of pupils made by State and local authorities and
founded on local conditions.
review.

Decision is reduced to an. administrative

The case signally demonstrates the soundness and workability

of these propositions! (l) that the Federal requirement of avoiding
racial exclusiveness in the public schools— loosely termed the require­
ment of integration— can be fulfilled reasonably and with justice if
the guide adopted is the circumstances of each child, individually and
relatively; (2) that it may bo achieved through the pursuit of any
method wherein the regulatory body can, and does, act after a fair hear­
ing and upon evidence; and ( 3 ) that when a conclusion is so reached in

sp

good faith, without influence of race, though it be erroneous, the
assignment is no longer a concern of the United States courts.
In this court's 1956 opinion, referring to the right of the
pupils to seek enforcement of the injunction, those same propositions
were suggested.

But in 1957 no ground whatsoever was tendered for such

considerations.

The opinion then commented, "x x x we have no administra­

tive decision with which to commence, save in one instance".

Now the

premises are offered.
Weighing those, the court cannot say that as to twenty-six of
the thirty pupil-plaintiffs their applications for transfer to "white"

�schools wore refused without substantial supporting evidence.

As to

the remaining four, refusal of their applications for transfer is not
justified in the evidence.

They are Honald Deskins, Michael Gerard

Jones, Lance Dwight Newman and Gloria Delores Thompson.
These four are all applicants for Stratford Junior High
School; they have asked to enter the seventh grade, the first year of
junior high.

Before this decision con be effectuated by a fino.1 decree,

ten days or more would routinely elapse, carrying the effective date
into October.

In the judgment of the court it would bo unwise to make

the transfers as late as that in the term.

The decree, therefore, will

be made effective at the commencement of the next semester, January,
1959«

This short deferment will not be hurtful.

Indeed, if the basic

problem can bo solved by time, the price is not too dear.
I.

The evidence upon which the assignments wore made was

taken subject to several motions and these should bo passed upon before
tho evidence is considered.

Counsel for the Pupil Placement Board,

appearing in association with the attorneys for the defendants, has
moved the court tc dismiss tho entire proceeding on the ground that
his client is an indispensable party to an a.ction
never been brought into tho case.

f this kind and has

He relies on tho Pupil Placement

act of Virginia, 1958 Acts of tho General Assembly, c. 500, 1950 Code of
Virginia, as amended, 22-232.1, supplementing the 1956 Pupil Pla.cenent
Act.

This legislation purportedly vests in tho Pupil Placement Board,

exclusively, all authority to determine the school to which any child
shall be admitted.

It is argued that as the present action involves

the admission of the plaintiff-pupils into the schools, the Board
should be a party.

The motion must bo denied.

While the Pupil Placement Act ha.s been amended, since the
1957 holding of this court that the procedure there stipulated was not
an adequate administrative remedy,.it is still net expeditious.

Tho

student would be too far delayed into the session before his application
would be finally determined.

Then, at tho end, the school closing and

�fund-cut-off statutes automatically shut tho school, and withhold any
nonoy for its operation, should tho student he assigned to a school
then teaching children of the other race.

Acts of the General Assembly

of Virginia, 1956, Ex. Session c. 68, 1950 Va. Colo, as mended,
22-188.5j Acts, 1958, c. 6 k 2 , Item 129 (Appropriations for schools).
It nay be, however, that tho first sta.go prescribed in the
Aot i3 ad ptable— s j e State or local authority must process the appli­
cations and make the assignments— but the point is moot.

The applica­

tions in suit were considered by the Placement Board and the Arlington
County School Board together.

The results, the refusals to grant the

transfers, were in effect assignments.

There is no reason to decide

now whether this was Placement Board or School Board action.
Nevertheless, in no event need tho Placement Board be inpleaded hero.

The inpa.ct of any decree would be upon tho persons

immediately in charge of the schools.
or reject tho students.

They it is who actually admit

Ordinarily they would be the employees of the

School Board, such as the principals and the teachers.

Fron tho faot

that the School Board and its employees may be controlled in their
acceptance of students by the Pupil Placement Board, it dees not follow
tha.t the court cannot judge of the validity of such regulations without
having the Placement Board before it.
Tho plaintiffs move to strike from the evidence the findings
of the Director of Psychological Services of the Virginia State Depart­
ment of Mental Hygiene in regard to the psychological problems of certain
of the applicants.

It is conceded that tho School Board or the Placement

Board had the right to consider this report.

The objection is that in

trial it is hearsay, because the Director was not called as a witness.
So for, the notion is good.

However, it does not preclude the c_urt

fron considering the report in measuring the evidence that was before
the Boards.
XI,

By the assignments of the Boards, thirty Arlington

County Negro pupils have boon refused transfer from the previ usly all-

- 3-

�Negro schools to several previously all-whito schools.

The assignments

were the result of a screening of the pupils against criteria of five
categories designated as:

Attendance Area, Over-crowding at Washington

and Lee High School, Academic Accomplishment, Psychological Problems,
and Adaptability.

Five of the thirty are the children who wore ordered

admitted by this court in September 1957&gt; hut the order was stayed
pending appeals.

Contrary to their argument, however, these pupils

have not by virtue of that order a vested position for this session.
Admissions must be judged on current conditions, the rule to be applied
to all students.

In this discussion the children will be designated

according to the laters and numbers used in the trial.
A:

Attendance Area— Pupils 2. 3. k , 9. O u
2&lt;f ^

^

19. 17. IS. 23.x
, ■ ■ A"
■■

On the Attendance Area tost elcvon transfers were declined—
students Nos* 2, 3, k 9 9, 1^, 15, 17, 18, 23, 2k and 25*

With tho

slight exceptions hereinafter noted, tho school districts have remained
the sene since the linos were fixed long prior to tho Supreme Court*s
decision of May 17, 195^-•
Hoffnan-Boston School.

o

Those pupils have "boon attending the

It has beon housing elementary grades, as well

as both junior and senior high schools, but solc-ly for Negroes.

Tho

Hcffman-Bcston lines were originally drawn to embrace an area occupied
almost entirely by Negroes.

In fact, save for a very small area known

as the n:-rth Hoffnan-Bost^n district, it is tho only Negro residential
section in the County.

These eleven pupils (2, 3, 15 and 25 being

senior high school students and k 9 9 * 1^, 17, 18, 23 and 2k junior
high school students) live in the Hoffman-Bost m area#
There is no other high school, white or colored, nearer to
then than Hoffnan-Boston*

Nos. 2, 3, 15 and 25 applied for admission

to Wakefield High School,

nnong other adjustments this change would

neon the establishment of a new bus route and would moan a longer haul
than the bus ride now afforded then to H -ffnan-Boston.

-4-

�Tho others sought entry into either Kennore Junior High School,
Gunston or Thomas Jefferson.

In distance all of those schools ore slightly

closer to their residences then Hoffnan-Boston.

However, the school

authorities had other factors to consider, such as the adoption of present­
ly established school bus routes, walking distances and the crossing ■
-.£
highways, as well as that Hoffnan-Boston was but a twenty-minute bus ride
for those pupils.
B: ncader.iio Accomplishment Deficiency of These and .'.Iso B, C, B,
E, 5. 6 . 8 . 10. 11. 12. 21 and 22

Excepting He. 18, a.ll of the immediately considered pupils—

2 , 3, k , 9&gt; 1^&gt; 15&gt; 17&gt; 23, 2k and 25— wore also refused transfer because
of their acadenic standing.

Besides these, pupils B, C, D, E, 5&gt; 6 , 8 ,

10, 11, 12, 21 and 22 were likewise found to be ineligible, on account
of acadenic deficiency, for the transfers requested.
In naking the acadenic determinations tho California Achievement
Tost wa.s tho principal factor.
experience.

Other factors were tho sch'ol records and

While among those twonty-twe pupils sene wore listed on thoir

student report cards as naking lew scholastic averages, just about as
nany had high averages and others were "cn grade level".
gence quotients are not low.
evaluations.

Their intelli­

The school authorities do not deny these

But they emphasize that those standings are related only to

the then grade and school of the children.
transfers was not those standings.

Tho basis for refusal of the

Tho basis was that the scholastic

standing in the classes to which they asked entry was above the individual
standings of the applicants to the extent that the transfers could not
be justified under sound educational principles.
The nodian .achievement level in the schools to which entrance is
sought, the evidence sh ws, is appreciably higher than tho national norm.
On the other hand, the median of the schools fron which the applicants
would cone, is more than a year below this n o m ,

More..vor, in tho

schools applied 1 r, tw..-thirls of the pupils have .achievement ratings ab.vo
the national n raj while in the schools of

-5-

rigin, four-fifths of tho

�students ore well below the national norm#

So a transfer night result

in placing the pupil in an achievement group one or more years above
the achievement category of his present gr-up.
With the exception of pupil 18, all of the applicants now in
discussion— 2, 3, 4, 9, 14, 15, 17, 23, 24, 25, B, C, D, E, 5, 6, 8,

10, 11, 12, 21 and 22, totaling twenty-two— wore below the median
achievement of the ad-scho^ls*

Fifteen— 22, 11, 14, 2*f, E, C, 10, 5&gt;

8 , 25, 15, D, 21, 12, 3— of them were below the national ncrn.

Two of

them were three years below and five others as much as a year or more.
It must be remembered, though, that some of the ad-scho.l students are
also below the national n-rn.
grade f.r

In the table of average mental maturity,

;rade, the Hoffman-3-ston is shown to be more than fifteen

points under the other sch^. Is, the one about 90 and the other 105 plus,

L.
3(
t
Psychol j ;ical ? . b e . s Pu, ils C, 1, 2, 6, 8, 21 and 2k
.
roli:—

C:

J l.t“

5t&gt;\

Sevan api lications were declined because

'
'

p

' '
'

S .^ -.

U AJU Z

f psychological

Of these seven, six— C, 2, 6 , 8 , 21 and 24— wore mono" these

preblecs,

just noted as rejected fer acr.dor.iic deficiency.
•group..

"

*

Ho. 1 was not in that

For this classification the Boards chiefly relied upon the

conclusions of the State Director of Psychological Services.
the school records of these children were also at haul.

Of c.urso,

In substance,

the opinion of the Director was that "it would be unwise and possibly
hornful t

this child to subject hin to the pressures which night result

fron attending a school" havin'; children of a different or an thor race.
Instability, lack of solf-contr 1 , extreme sliyness and difficulty of
mingling or making friends arc the circumstances generally named by
hin for his conclusions, persuading hin that entry i n t . such a echo :
1
would result in severe difficulty in the sen .Is r,s well as t: the
subject pupil.
D:

Thus the Director's determinations do involve race.

Overcrowding at V'ashin ion and Lee— Pupils D. 1. 12. 19
and 21

For soni &lt;r high sch ol attendance allocations, Arlington
County has been for nany yoars divided int
-

6-

three districts.

The

�Washin ton m d L o g District, taking the nane fr.n the high school
located in the north center cf the County, originally embraced approxi­
mately the north half of the county.

The second district is Wakefield,

named for another high school situated on the extreme western boundary
of the county and in the southwest section.

The third district is

Hoffman-B oston, already described, and forcing an enclave within the
Wakefield District,
Before the corxicncement of this litigation and without antici­
pation of it, a largo area in the northwest c o m e r of the County was
taken out of the Washington and Lee District, because of the over­
population of that hi; h school.

The severed area, is net contiguous to

but well north of the lino between the Washington-Lee and the Wakefield
districts.

Since the inception of the present controversy the northern

district of H ffiaan-Bostcn has been va.ca.ted.

It was entirely surr unded

by We.shin ~ n-Lee District; hence it is n&gt;vw thrown int. that district.
t
This s::a.ll territ:ry is contiguous t - that part of Washin t n and Lee
.
just described as taken .ff from the latter.

Pupils D, 1, 12, 19 and

21 reside within the territ ry formerly comprising the northern district
of Hcf fnan-Bcst on.

They have boon assigned to the Hoff non-Best on Hi-^i

School,
Washin ’
ton and Lee High Sch„ 1 is much nearer t - their resi­
dences than is H ffnan-Best-n,

Indeed, it lies between the residences

and H ffman-Boston, away fr m the residences about one-f.urth of the
total distance*

Overcrowding of Washington and Lee is the basis f.r

the assignment ^f these pupils t

H.ffnan-Bost:n*

Before the necessity arose for considering the assi.-71r.ent of
senior high school pupils residing’ in the former northern HoffnanBoston District to any high school other than H ffran-B ston, the
Washington and Lee High Scho. 1 had become c ngested.

The present

p pul at i n is 2600 as a ainst a naxir.iun capacity of 2000,
B-st on, the current p pul at i on is

575»

with a capacity

.Pt Hcffnan-

f 375&gt;

augmented

new ly f ur temporary cla.ssro ms accc 01 dating 100 m^re pupils m d t

-7-

be

�increased, further, by the addition of five classrooms n .w under construc­
tion, for completion in January 1959, to care for 125 pupils.
facilities at Hcffnan-Beston will thus bo 600.

The total

Wakefield is constructed

for 2000 but presently has 25*10 students.
In maintaining the assignment of these students to HoffoanBoston, rather than to Washington-Loe, the defendants referred to
corresponding treatment of Caucasian pupils.

They point to the students

living in the territory severed from Washington-Lee.

Those white pupils

in the tenth cpra.de (the first year of the senior high school) must g*» to
Wakefield Hl;h School.

This is a distance as groat, if not cheater,

than tho trip to Hoffman-Boston from its former northern district.
ncte still another comparable transportation of white students.

They

Those

living at Fort Myer, in the southeast port of the county, ore not per­
mitted to go to tho nearer Washin ; on-Lee High School but are required
t
to attend Wakefield, on the other side of the county.

Tho Hoffman-

Boston School is superior to any of the other schools in the county in
its 18.5 pupil-teacher ratio.
E:

Adavtal ility— Pupils . . 7. 15. 16 and 20
.

Thus, eighteen -f tho thirty applicants have toon found dis­
qualified upon at least two, and sometimes throe, of the criteria, and
seven for tho sole reason of overcrowding, attendance area, or academic
standing.

The remaining five applicants— A, 7, 13, 16 and 20— were re­

fused transfer for failing tho test of Adaptability.
On this last criterion the principal witness was the Superin­
tendent of Schools.

With thirty-two years in segregated schools, his

experience covers both Negroes and Caucasians, though separately.

He

defines adaptability as including the ability to accept or conform to
now and different education environnent,

In reference to these fivo

pupils he readily concedes that their places of residence would entitle
then t: go to the schools of their application— Pupil A to Patrick Hcniy
Elementary Sohool, and 7, 13, 16 and 20 to Stratford Junior H l h School.

�But the point nr.de by the Superintendent is that these students
would, respectively, be injured by placement in Patrick Henry cr in
Stratford Junior High School.

His reason is that they would lose their

present position of school superiority and leadership.

At Hoffman-

Boston 7» 15&gt; 16 and 20 rate about two years above the school norm of
achievement.

They are nearly a year ahead cf the national norm.

How­

ever, if they enter Stratford, they will not, as they arc- in Hofftaaa-Boston,
be in the top group, but just above the achievement median of that school.
They will not be aaotus the leaders.
A at Patrick Henry.,

Analogous reasoning is applied to

The Superintendent feels that this would te dis­

couraging and possibly emotionally disturbing to then.

Race or color

is not the basis for his opinion, though, he owns, the necessity for
his decision is occasioned by the removal of racial boors.
Conclusion
1.

The very formulation and use of the criteria is pleaded

by the plaintiffs as racial discrimination.
agrees.

With this the c u r t dis­

True, previously no such tests were kn ,wn; they cane into

being in the latter part of August 1958 in connection with the instant
school assignments.

But this does not prove discrimination.

Those tests wore not used previously because there was no
necessity.

The removal of the rule and custom of segregation was an

abrupt change.

It was a social epoch, beginning a new era.

Accommo­

dation to its demands meant now methods as well as facilities.
assignment cf pupils took on an added obligation.
place, assignment regulations had to be adopted.

The

At some time and
Therefore, the instant

criteria are not discriminatory as b e m of a social change.

Otherwise,

after the erasure of race as a factor in pupil placement, no assignment
plan could over be validly adopted.
2,

This recital of the evidence is not written with the

implication that the evidenoo as to the tests wae not questioned.

In

refutation the plaintiffs offered evidence of considerable weight and
relevance.

But the court does net in a case

9

- -

f this kind resolve such

�differences..

It examines the conflicting evidence only to see if the

rebuttal evidence destroys any weight that night be given to the defen­
dants' proof.

Its inquiry is to ascertain if the defendants' evidence,

independently of influence of race or color, was sufficient to sustain the
action of the Placement Beard and the School Board.
3.

The reasons given for disqualifying the seven students

upon the test of the Psychological Problems obviously give consideration
to raco and color*

On the other hand, the rejection was not due solely

to those features.

The court, however, does not rule on the weight to

be accorded this test because the evidence before it upon the point is
toe scant.

The psychologist was not ca.llod as a witness and the court

does not have the benefit of his exposition.

Therefore, this test must

bo disregarded for this case.,

b.

Plaintiffs urge that invalidity of the assignments is

conclusively established by the result, that is, that all Negro pupils
remain in the Hoffnan-Bcston School.
is not s.und,

Though plausible, the argument

Actually, the principal reason for the result is the

geographical location of tho residences of the plaintiffs, indeed of
the entire Negro population in ..rlington County..

It is confined to

two sections, the Hoffnan-Bcston area and tho previous, small northern
division of the Hoffcan-Boston, several miles apart.
by far tho larger Negro area.

Hoffnan-Bcston is

This situation seemingly would be frequent­

ly found in areas, like Arlington County, urban in character.
It occurs, too, from the relatively sna.ll Negro population
in the County.. Tho condition now does not differ greatly from that
noted in this court's opinion of September 1957*
Negroes in all of the County's schools.
white students.

Then there were 1^32

This compared to some 21,000

Tho latter are scattered throughout tho County.

The

concentration of Negro peculation is confirmed in this or.se by the fact
that only one white-sch .ol parent was available t

testify r s a resident
. .

f H.ffnan-Bcston district.
N . r is disorinina.ti n proved by tho stipulation that 100 Negro
.,

-

10-

�pupils are transported to Hoffnan-Boston from the now dissolved northern
division of Hoffnnn-Boston,.

As many as 250 white pupils are carried fron

the severed portion of Washingten-Lee District to Wakefield,
of these Negroes are complainants here.
E, 5, 6 , 7, 8 , 10, 11, 13, 16, 20 and 22.

Only eighteen

They are D, 1, 12, 19, 21, B, C,
Without ignoring the record

and without presuming bad faith in the Boards, it cannot be said that
they wore sent to Hcffnon-Eoston simply to segregate the Negro children,
For example, D, 1 , 12, 19 and 21 wore sent specifically because of the
overcrowding at Washington and Leo.

Either those or sone other pupils,

white or colored, had to bo rejected at Vfcshin.rton-Loo.

It was not

illogical to turn away those who had ncro recently bocone eligible, in
favor of those who were already in, or had studied for entrance into,
Washington and Lee,

...gain, proof that the assignments to the Hoffnan-

Boston School wore not arbitrary is seen in the specific finding in
respect to E, C, D, E, 5, 6 , 8 , 10, 11, 12, 19, 20, 21 and 22— want of
academic accomplishment.
5«

The court is of the opini ai that Attendance Area, Over­

crowding at Washington and Loo, and Academic Accomplishment clearly are
valid criteria, free of taint of race or color.

It concludes also that

these criteria, have been applied without any such bias.

It cannot say

that the refusal of transfers on these grounds is not supported by
adequate evidence.
The court may ha.ve made a different decision an this evidence),
.
it nay not a.gree with the conclusions of the- Boards.

But tha.t is of no

oonsequenco once it is found that the administrative action is not
arbitrary, capricious ,r illegal.

Thus the denial of twenty-five of

the applications must now bo sustained.

6 , The remaining five applications— A, 7, 13 &gt; 16 and 20—
failed on the test of Adaptability,
to evaluate.

This is the most difficult criterion

It is certainly not frivolous, especially when it is the

Opinion of an educator of thirty-tw

years experience.

In certa.in cir­

f donaroatien 1etween it and racial

cumstances, undoubtedly, the line

-

11-

1

�discrimination can be

clearly drawn, that it can be the f:undaticn

for withholding a transfer.

Pupil A exemplifies this hypothesis.

Ten or eleven years old, with an academic achievement "on a
grade level", this boy wishes to transfer from Ecffman-Boston Slenentary
School to Patrick Henry, also elementary.
residence than is Hoffnan-Boston.
of all pupil-teacher rcatio.

The latter is nearer his

But he loaves a school with lowest

His only advantage is one of distancej in

good weather and subject to pedestrian traffic dangers, he could walk
to Patrick Henry, about a half mile away, while the school bus would take
him to Hof fmon-Boston, 1,2 miles off, in perhaps less than his walking
time.
The median of academic achievement for his .radio at HcffnanBoston is 3,9.
ing.

As he is "on grade level" this would indicate his stand­

In Patrick Henry the sane median is 6,0.

The average mental

maturity for the fifth .grade in Hoffnan-Boston is 87, while in Patrick
Henry it is 113, a difference of twenty-six.

Laying aside the physical

circumstances, the court cannot say that adaptability, in view of the
intelligence factors, is a capricious standard when applied to A.

His
\

transition could well be discouraging, if not disparaging, one from which
a student may be lawfully saved by the judgment of the more experienced.
The circumstances of 7&gt; 13&gt; 16 and 20 are different from A's.
They live in the former northern district of ILffnan-1ost^n; their homes
are near Stratford Junior High School and within its re gion.

Each of

them stands above the median achievement score of Stratford,

They have

a common ago of twelve years and they all would enter the first year of
junior hi. ;h school.

They arc a group formerly attending Langston

Elementary School together, presumably friends having cannon interests.
In these circumstances, having in mind also their relative
academic standing, Adaptability could harlly bar them.

The court finds

no ground in the record t. uphold the Boards' refusal of the transfers
of 7 , 13 1 16 and 20— Ronald Deskins, Michael Gerard Jones, Lance Dwight
Newman and Gloria Delores Thompson.

-

12-

�Colophon
The length and detail of this statement were necessary to
assure core and solicitude for the actions of State and local administra­
tive agencies*

It is an effort, too, to establish for cases of this

character sene design for decision.

_____ /s/ ,
ilbort V. Bryan
United States District Judge

September 17th, 1959.

-13-

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="10">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="2122">
                  <text>RG 18: Personal Papers of Barbara Marx</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="7914">
                <text>Court Case, Clarissa S. Thompson, et al. v. County School Board Of Arlington County, Virginia, et al, Civil 1341</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="7915">
                <text>Document, Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law in Court Case, Clarissa S. Thompson, et al. v. County School Board Of Arlington County, Virginia, et al, Civil 1341, in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia, dated September 17, 1958.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="7916">
                <text>1958-9-17</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="42">
            <name>Format</name>
            <description>The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="7917">
                <text>pdf</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="48">
            <name>Source</name>
            <description>A related resource from which the described resource is derived</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="7918">
                <text>RG 18, Personal Papers of Barbara Marx</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="39">
            <name>Creator</name>
            <description>An entity primarily responsible for making the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="7919">
                <text>nited States District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="38">
            <name>Coverage</name>
            <description>The spatial or temporal topic of the resource, the spatial applicability of the resource, or the jurisdiction under which the resource is relevant</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="7920">
                <text>1950s</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="47">
            <name>Rights</name>
            <description>Information about rights held in and over the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="7921">
                <text>This image is subject to copyright. Unauthorized use of the images in the Local History Collections of the Arlington Community Archives is prohibited.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="43">
            <name>Identifier</name>
            <description>An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="21129">
                <text>18_2_1_4_24</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="972" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="769">
        <src>https://projectdaps.org/files/original/582bde5c8141ebf61bb2520af694fc5e.pdf</src>
        <authentication>670023fcf24f76ac59467456f6d2dcd0</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="52">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="10440">
                    <text>'Boeoir ▼.

B U T T

Cite na 285 F.2d 43 (1960)

43

o f C iv il P ro c e d u r e , 28 U .S .C .A ., a
p a r t y is r e q u ir e d to m a k e k n o w n h is
o b je c tio n a n d g ro u n d s th e r e f o r .
S u b s ta n c e in h e r e s in t h i s r e q u i r e
m e n t a n d o b s e rv a n c e th e r e o f is e s
s e n tia l to th e a d m in is tr a tio n o f th e
b u s in e s s o f th e c o u rts .”

t h a t p a r a g r a p h w h ic h s e t f o r t h r a c ia l
g ro u n d s a s v a lid c o n d itio n to s u p p o r t a n
a p p lic a tio n f o r t r a n s f e r .
•

T h e j u d g m e n t is affirm ed .

1. Schools a n d Sch o o l D is tr ic ts ^ l S
S t a tu t e r e s p e c tin g h o ld in g o f local
o p tio n e le c tio n s a s to c o n tin u a n c e o r a b o
litio n o f d u a l school s y s te m co u ld n o t be
m a d e a c o n d itio n o f a p la n o f d e s e g r e g a
tio n , s in c e r e c o g n itio n a n d e n fo r c e m e n t of
c o n s titu tio n a l r ig h t s could n o t be m ad e
c o n tin g e n t u p o n r e s u lt o f a n y e le c tio n .
V e r n o n 's A n n .C iv .S t.T e x . a r t . 290 0 a.

S a n d r a C ra ig BO SO N e t al., A p p e lla n ts,
v.
D r. E d w in L. R IP P Y , A s P re s id e n t o f th e
B o a rd o f T r u s te e s o f th e D a lla s In d e
p e n d e n t School D is tric t, D a lla s C ounty,
T e x a s, e t al., A ppellees.
D r. E d w in L. R IP P Y , A s P r e s id e n t o f th e
B o a rd o f 'T r u s t e e s o f th e D a lla s In d e
p e n d e n t S chool D istrict, D a lla s C ounty,
T e x a s, e t al., A p p e lla n ts,
v.
S a n d r a C ra ig BO SO N e t al., A pp ellees.
N o. 18467.
U n ited S ta te s C o u rt of A p p e a ls
F i f t h C ircu it.
N ov. 30, 1960.
S u p p le m e n ta l O pinion D ec. 7, 1960.
R e h e a rin g D e nied J a n . 5, 1961.

R e v e rse d a n d re m a n d e d w ith d ire c
tio n s .

2. Sch o o ls a n d School D is tric ts &lt; ^ 1 3
P la n f o r in te g r a tio n o f school d is
t r i c t s u n d e r w h ic h t h e r e w a s p ro v is io n
f o r s e p a r a tin g a n d g r o u p in g o f sc h o o ls
in to w h ite , N e g ro , a n d m ix e d sch o o ls a n d
f o r c a n v a s s in g p a r e n t s a n d p u p ils in
o r d e r to le a r n w h o d id a n d d id n o t w a n t
in te g r a tio n , w o u ld c o n tin u e p r a c tic e o f
e n fo rc e d s e g re g a tio n , a n d d id n o t a c co rd
w ith th e c o n s titu tio n a l r ig h t s o f N e g r o
p la in tiffs ..
3. C o n s titu tio n a l L a w •3=220
Sch o o ls a n d School D is tric ts &lt;3=13
N e g ro c h ild re n h a v e n o c o n s titu tio n
al r i g h t to a tte n d a n c e o f w h ite c h ild re n
w ith th e m in p u b lic sch o o ls a n d t h e i r c o n
s ti tu t i o n a l r i g h t to e q u a l p r o te c tio n o f
law s is th e r i g h t to s ta n d e q u a l b e fo re
law s o f s ta te , t h a t is, to b e t r e a te d sim p ly
a s in d iv id u a ls w ith o u t r e g a r d to r a c e o r
color.

4. C o n s titu tio n a l l a w @
==&gt;220
S t a te s u p p o rt o f sch o o ls in w h ic h
A c tio n to e nd e n fo rc e d r a c ia l s e g re
s e g re g a tio n o f p u p ils is r e q u ir e d b y law
g a tio n in p u b lic schools. F r o m o r d e r o f
d oes n o t s q u a re w ith th e c o n s titu tio n a l
th e U n ite d S t a te s D i s tr i c t C o u rt f o r th e
r e q u ir e m e n t o f e q u a l p r o te c tio n o f th e
N o r t h e r n D i s tr i c t o f T e x a s , T. W h itfield
law s.
D a v id so n , J ., e n te r e d o r d e r r e je c tin g p lan
o n e a n d a p p ro v in g p la n tw o a n d p a r tie s
5. Sch o o ls a n d School D is tric ts «§=13
a p p e a le d . T h e C o u r t o f A p p e a ls, R ives,
A f t e r a p p ro v a l o f p la n f o r i n te g r a
tio n o f sch o o ls c o m m e n c in g w ith th e f ir s t
C h ie f J u d g e , h e ld t h a t p la n w h ic h w ould
g r a d e , D i s tr i c t C o u rt r e t a in i n g j u r i s d ic
r e q u ir e o p e ra tio n o f m ix e d sch o o ls w h e re
p a r e n t s o f p u p ils o f b o th r a c e s so d e s ire d
tio n o f a c tio n d u r in g t r a n s it i o n s h o u ld b e
w o u ld c o n tin u e th e p r a c tic e o f e n fo rc e d ^ g o v e rn e d b y ru le t h a t b u rd e n r e s t s u p o n
d e fe n d a n ts to e s ta b lis h t h a t su c h tim e to
s e g re g a tio n a n d p la n f o r d e s e g re g a tio n
s t a r t i n g w ith t h e f ir s t g r a d e w ou ld be a p - . acco m p lish t r a n s it i o n is n e c e s s a ry in th e
.p u b lic in te re s £ a n d is c o n s is te n t w ith good
p ro v e d u p o n e lim in a tio n th e r e f r o m q £

�44
f a i t h c o m p lian c e a t t h e e a r l ie s t p r a c tic a
b le d a te .
*

S u p p le m e n ta l O p in io n
6. S ch o o ls a n d School D is tr ic ts &lt;£=13
T h a t p o rtio n o f d e s e g r e g a tio n p la n
p ro v id in g f o r in te g r a tio n o f p u b lic
schools c o m m e n c in g w ith th e f ir s t g ra d e
w h ic h m ad e r a c ia l g ro u n d s v a lid c o n d i
tio n s to s u p p o rt a p p lic a tio n f o r t r a n s f e r
w o u ld b e s tr ic k e n sin c e i ts a p p lic a tio n
m ig h t te n d to p e r p e tu a te r a c ia l d is c r im
i n a tio n a n d w a s a t v a ria n c e w ith . T e x a s
s t a t u t e g iv in g school b o a rd w id e d is c re
tio n in t r a n s f e r r i n g p u p ils.
V e rn o n ’s.
A n n .C iv .S t.T e x . a r t . 2900a. .

W . J . D u rh a m , C. B. B u n k le y , J r . , D a l
la s , T ex., T h u rg o o d M a rs h a ll, N ew Y o rk
C ity , E lw o o d H . C hisolm , N e w Y o rk C ity,
o f co u n sel, f o r a p p e lla n ts .
H e n r y W . S t r a s b u r g e r , M a rk M a rtin ,
D a lla s, T e x ., R o y al H . B r in , J r . , D allas,
T e x ., S t r a s b u r g e r , P r ic e K e lto n , M ille r &amp;
M a rtin , D allas, T ex., o f c o u n s e l,'f o r app e lle e s-a p p e lla n ts , D r. E d w in L. R ip p y ,
a n d o th e rs .

t o d e s e g r e g a te t h e (schools u n d e r t h e i r
ju r i s d ic t io n “ w ith a ll d e lib e ra te s p e e d .” 5
T h e d i s t r ic t c o u r t c o n s tr u e d s u c h d ire c
tio n s to r e q u i r e im m e d ia te en m a s s e de
s e g re g a tio n , a n d , a c c o rd in g ly , a g a in s t i ts
o w n e x p re s s e d b e tt e r ju d g m e n t, e n te r e d
a n o r d e r e n jo in in g t h e d e fe n d a n ts “ f ro m
r e q u i r in g o r p e r m i tt in g s e g re g a tio n o f
t h e r a c e s in a n y school u n d e r t h e i r s u p e r
v isio n , b e g in n in g a n d n o t b e fo r e th e m id W in te r school te r m o f 1 9 5 7 -5 8 .” T h a t
o r d e r w a s a g a in re v e r s e d b y t h i s C o u r t
w ith m o re specific d ire c tio n s to a c c o rd
th e school a u th o r i ti e s “ a re a s o n a b le f u r
t h e r o p p o r tu n ity p ro m p tly to m e e t t h e i r
p r im a r y r e s p o n s ib ility in th e p re m ise s ,
a n d th e n if th e p la in tiffs , o r o th e r s s im i
la rly s itu a te d , sh o u ld c la im t h a t th e school
a u th o r i ti e s h a v e fa ile d in a n y r e s p e c t to
p e rf o r m t h e i r d u ty , t h e r e s h o u ld be a fu ll
a n d f a i r h e a r i n g in w h ic h ev id e n c e m a y
be o ffered b y a n y a n d all p a r tie s , a n d f u r
t h e r t h a t th e C o u r t sh o u ld r e t a in j u r i s d ic
tio n to r e q u ir e co m p lian c e w ith i t s j u d g
m e n t.” fl

A f t e r h e a r in g t h e te s tim o n y , th e d is
t r i c t c o u rt a g a in d ism is s e d th e a c tio n
w ith o u t p r e ju d ic e .4 T h is C o u rt re v e rs e d
w ith d ire c tio n s t h a t th e d i s t r ic t c o u rt
e n te r a n o r d e r r e q u i r in g th e d e fe n d a n ts

T h e d i s t r ic t court* th e n e n te r e d a g e n
e ra l o r d e r r e q u i r in g d e s e g r e g a tio n “ w ith
all d e lib e ra te s p e ed .” N o f u r t h e r c o u rt
p ro c e e d in g s a p p e a r u n til som e th ir te e n
m o n th s la te r, w h e n th e p la in tif fs filed
t h e i r “ m o tio n f o r f u r t h e r r e l i e f ” p r a y in g
f o r im m e d ia te d e s e g r e g a tio n o f th e p u b lic
schools. T h e d i s t r ic t c o u rt d e n ie d im m e
d ia te d e s e g r e g a tio n , b u t r e ta in e d j u r i s
d ic tio n a n d rec e sse d th e h e a r in g f ro m
A u g u s t 4, 1959, to th e f ir s t M o n d a y in
A p ril 1960. U p o n a p p e a l th is C o u rt m o d i
fied th e o r d e r o f th e d i s t r ic t c o u r t “ so a s
to r e q u ir e th e d e fe n d a n ts to ‘m a k e a
p r o m p t a n d re a s o n a b le s t a r t to w a rd fu ll
c o m p lian c e ’ w ith i t s in ju n c tio n o r d e r o f
A p ril 1 6 th , 1958, a n d to t h a t e n d , w ith in
t h i r t y d a y s fro m t h e d a te on w h ic h th e
p r e s e n t ju d g m e n t o f t h is C o u r t o f A p
p e a ls b eco m es final, to s u b m it a p la n f o r
e ff e c tu a tin g a tr a n s it i o n to a r a c ia lly n on-

1. Bell v. Rippy, D.O.N.D.Tex.1955, 13.1 F.
Supp. 811.

4. Boll v. Rippy, D.C.N.D.Tex.1956, 146
F.Supp. 4,85.

Brown v. Rippy, 5 Cir., 1900, 233 F.2d
790.

5. Borders v. Rippy, 5 Cir., 1907, 247 F.
2d 268, 272.

B e f o re R I V E S , C h ie f J u d g e , a n d
T U T T L E a n d J O N E S , C ir c u it J u d g e s .
R IV E S , C h ie f J u d g e .
T h is a c tio n s e e k in g a n e nd to e n fo rc e d
r a c ia l s e g re g a tio n in th e p u b lic sch o o ls o f
t h e D a lla s In d e p e n d e n t School D is tr i c t
w a s f ir s t d ism is s e d w ith o u t p r e ju d ic e by
th e d i s t r ic t c o u rt in S e p te m b e r 1955.1
T h is C o u r t re v e rs e d w ith d ire c tio n s to
a ffo rd th e p a r t i e s a fu ll h e a r in g .2 T h e
S u p re m e C o u r t d e n ie d c e r t io r a r i .3

2.

3. Rippy v. Brown. 1056, 352 U.S. 878, 77
S.Ot. 99, 1 L.Ed.2(i 79.

6. Rippy v. Borders, 5 Cir., 1957, 250 F.
2d 690. 604.

�b o s o n t . E rro r
Clteas-285 P .2d 43 (1900)

45

d i s c r im in a to r y school s y s te m ; a n d f u r
t h e r t h a t th e D i s tr i c t C o u rt, w ith in t h i r t y
d a y s a f t e r th e s u b m is s io n o f su ch p lan ,
hold a fu ll h e a r in g u p o n th e p la n so s u b
m itte d a n d on a n y o b je c tio n s w h ic h m a y
be filed th e r e to .” 7 I n c o n fo r m ity w ith
su ch a n o r d e r , th e d e fe n d a n t school a u
th o r i ti e s filed in th e d i s t r ic t c o u rt a
tw e lv e -y e a r, " s ta i r - s te p ” p la n o f d e s e g r e
g a tio n s t a r t i n g w ith th e f ir s t g r a d e in
S e p te m b e r 1961, a n d p ro c e e d in g b y th e
d e s e g r e g a tio n o f o ne a d d itio n a l g r a d e a
y e a r u n til a ll tw e lv e g r a d e s in a ll p u b lic
schools h a v e b e e n d e s e g re g a te d .8

b y e lim in a tin g t h e p a r a g r a p h s w h i c h
m ak e a n e le c tio n a n d f a v o r a b le r e s u l t c o n
d itio n s o f th e p la n . I n c o n fo r m ity w i t h
su ch o p in io n a n d o r d e r , t h e d e fe n d a n ts
re - s u b m itte d b o th p la n s a m e n d e d so a s
n o t to d e p e n d u p o n th e o u tco m e o f a n e le c
tio n . T h e d i s t r ic t c o u rt a g a in r e je c te d
P la n N o. 1, o v e rru le d t h e o b je c tio n s o f
t h e p la in tif fs to P la n N o . 2 a s a m e n d e d ,
a n d a p p ro v e d t h a t p la n . T h e p la in tif fs
a p p e al f ro m th e a p p ro v a l o f P la n N o . 2 a s
a m e n d e d , a n d th e d e fe n d a n ts a p p e a l f ro m
th e d isa p p ro v a l o f P la n N o. 1 a s a m e n d
ed.

T h e d i s t r ic t c o u rt d isa p p ro v e d th is p lan
a n d r e q u ir e d th e d e fe n d a n ts to file " a n
a lt e r n a t e d e s e g r e g a tio n p la n m o re in
k e e p in g w tih th e C o u r t’s o r a l o p in io n .” 9
T h e a lt e r n a t e p la n w a s p ro m p tly filed,
p ro v id in g f o r th e s e p a r a tin g a n d g r o u p
in g o f th e schools in to w h ite , N e g ro a n d
m ix e d schools, a n d f o r c a n v a s s in g p a r e n ts
a n d p u p ils in o r d e r to le a r n "w h o does
a n d w h o d o es n o t w a n t in te g r a tio n , a n d
th e r e b y g iv e all c o n c ern e d w h a t th e y p r e
f e r , a s f a r a s is p r a c tic a l a n d p o ssib le .” 10

[1 ] W e a g r e e w ith th e d i s t r i c t c o u rt
t h a t th e h o ld in g o f a n e le c tio n u n d e r A r
tic le 29 0 0 a o f th e R e v ised C iv il S t a tu t e s
o f T e x a s sh o u ld n o t b e m a d e a c o n d itio n
o f a p lan o f d e s e g r e g a tio n . I t g o e s w i t h
o u t s a y in g t h a t r e c o g n itio n a n d e n fo r c e
m e n t o f c o n s titu tio n a l r ig h t s c a n n o t b e
m ad e c o n tin g e n t u p o n th e r e s u l t o f a n y
e le c tio n .11

T h e d i s t r ic t c o u rt e x p re s s e d th e o p in io n
t h a t th e h o ld in g o f a n e le c tio n u n d e r
A r tic le 2900a o f V e rn o n ’s A n n .R e v ised
C ivil S t a tu t e s o f T e x a s sh o u ld n o t be
m a d e a c o n d itio n o f a p la n o f d e s e g r e g a
tio n , a g a in re je c te d P la n N o . 1, a n d o r
d e re d th e d e fe n d a n ts to a m e n d P la n N o. 2
7. Boson v. Hippy. 5 f ir ., 1000, 275 F.2d
850, 853.
*

8. Tin's will be referred to as Plan No. 1.
It is essentially the same as the "Nash
ville Plan" approved in Kelley v. Board
of Education of City of Nashville, etc.,
6 Cir., 11150. 270 F.2d 200. certiorari
denied .{ U.S. 924, 80 S.Ct. 293, 4 L.
‘ 111
Ed.2d 240.
9. The district court’s orul opinion includ
ed the following:
‘‘Some educator hns advanced the fol
lowing plan which has an appeal: That
the school authorities set aside schools
within tiie city limits in which all those
of either race who desire integration may
be enrolled by placement arrangement
and transportation given to th at school
and that other liko schools for different
grades be set aside maybe elsewhere in
the city. S 'f e the children would be
there together by their parents’ consent

[ 2 - 4 ] P la n N o . 2 a s a m e n d e d , w h ic h
w a s a p p ro v e d b y th e d i s t r ic t c o u rt, w o u ld
c o n tin u e th e p r a c tic e o f e n fo rc e d s e g r e g a
tio n in th e a ll w h ite a n d a ll N e g r o sch o o ls
a n d w ould r e q u ir e th e o p e ra tio n o f m ix e d
sch o o ls i f p a r e n t s a n d p u p ils o f b o th r a c e s
so d e s ire d . T h a t p la n ev id e n c e s a to ta l
m isc q n c e p tio n o f th e n a tu r e o f th e c o n s ti
tu tio n a l r ig h t s a s s e r te d b y th e p la in tiffs .
N e g ro c h ild re n h a v e no c o n s titu tio n a l
there is a t least one reason why good
will would prevail in these schools th at
might not prevail in schools where chil
dren are brought together by force and
without the approval of their parents.
“If the plan proved popular, then ad
ditional integrated schools would through
the years follow, not more than 12
years."
10. This will ho referred to as Plan No. 2.
11. See Borders v. Iiippy, 5 Cir.. 1957, 247
F.2il 2&lt;&gt;S, 272. opinion on rehearing;
Dallas Independent School D istrict v.
Edgar. 5 Cir.. 1958. 255 F 2d 455; Hous
ton Independent School D istrict v. Ross,
5 Cir., I960. 282 F.2d 95, approving opin
ion of the district court. We are further
advised th at the Attorney General of
Texas “
has ruled that Article 29t:0a is
not applicable where a school district
desegregates pursuant to court order.

�46

285 F E D E R A L R E P O R T E R , 2d S E R IE S

r i g h t to th e a tte n d a n c e o f w h ite c h ild re n
w ith th e m in th e p u b lic sch o o ls. T h e ir
c o n s titu tio n a l r i g h t to “ th e e q u a l p r o te c
tio n o f th e la w s ” is t h e r i g h t to s ta n d
e q u a l b e fo re th e law s o f th e S t a te ; t h a t
is, to be t r e a te d sim p ly a s in d iv id u a ls
w ith o u t r e g a r d to ra c e o r c olor. T h e d is
s e n tin g v iew o f t h e e ld e r M r. J u s tic e
H a r la n in P le ss y v. F e r g u s o n , 1895, 1G3
U .S . 537, 559, 16 S .C t. 1138, 1146, 41
L .E d . 256, h a s b e e n p ro v ed b y h is to r y to
e x p re s s th e t r u e m e a n in g o f o u r C o n s titu
t io n :
“ * * * T h e r e is no c a s te h e re .
O u r c o n s titu tio n is c o lo r-b lin d , a n d
n e ith e r k n o w s n o r to le r a te s cla sse s
a m o n g c itiz e n s . I n re s p e c t o f civ il
r ig h t s , all c itiz e n s a r e e q u a l b e fo re
th e law . T h e h u m b le s t is th e p e e r o f
th e m o s t p o w e rfu l. T h e law r e g a r d s '
m a n a s m an , a n d ta k e s no a c c o u n t o f
h is s u rr o u n d in g s o r o f h is co lo r w h en
h is c iv il r ig h t s a s g u a ra n te e d by th e
s u p re m e law o f th e la n d a r e in
v o lv ed .”
I n s te a d o f r e m o v in g th e f o rb id d e n c la s s i
fic a tio n a c c o rd in g to ra c e o r color, t h a t
12. A full discussion of a similar plan is
contained in the opinion of Judge Wil
liam E. Miller in Kelly v. Board of Edu
cation of City of Nashville, I).('.M.I).
Tenn.1958, 159 F.Supp. 272, 27S:
* • * * It would sanction by law. if
*
approved, the separation of schools in
accordance with racial distinctions and
once, the schools were separated, Negro
children because of their race alone
would be excluded by operation of luw
from schools designated for white chil
dren only. The discrimination would not
be removed simply by providing a third
school or group of schools which could
be attended by members of both the
white and colored races. It is a mis- ,
taken interpretation of the segregation
decisions of the Supreme Court to argue
that the doctrine of those cases applies
only to an entire school system and not
to individual schools. The fundamental
basis of the decisions is that members
of the Negro or miuority race are de
nied the equal protection of the law if
they are denied admission to public
schools which they are otherwise quali
fied to attend solely upon grounds of
their race. The discrimination is ebarly not eliminated by maintaining and op
erating some schools in the system ou a

p la n a d d s a n o th e r s u c h c la s s ific a tio n .
V ir tu a lly th e s a m e p la n h a s a lr e a d y b e e n
co n d e m n e d in t h e S o u th e rn D i s tr i c t o f
T e x a s a n d b y t h is C o u rt. H o u s to n In d e
p e n d e n t School D is tr i c t , e t a l. v . R osa, 5
C ir., 1960, 28 2 F .2 d 95, 96. S t a te s u p p o rt
o f schools in w h ic h s e g re g a tio n o f th e
p u p ils is r e q u i r e d b y la w c a n n o t b e
s q u a re d w ith th e c o n s titu tio n a l co m m a n d
o f e q u a l p r o te c tio n o f th e law s. C o o p e r v.
A a ro n . 1958, 358 U .S . 1, 19, 78 S .C t. 1401,
3 L .E d .2 d 5 , 19.1 T h e d i s t r ic t c o u r t’s a p
15
*
2
p ro v a l o f P la n N o. 2 a s a m e n d e d m u s t be
re v e rs e d .
A s to P la h N o. 1 a s a m e n d e d w e a r e o f
t h e o p in io n t h a t p a r a g r a p h 6, q u o te d in
th e m a r g i n ,'3 sh o u ld b e s tr ic k e n b e c a u se
i t s p ro v is io n s rec o g n iz e r a c e a s a n a b s o
lu te g ro u n d f o r th e t r a n s f e r o f s tu d e n ts ,
a n d i ts a p p lic a tio n m ig h t te n d to p e r p e tu
a te r a c ia l d is c r im in a tio n . C o m p a re K el
ley v. B o a rd o f E d u c a tio n o f C ity o f
N a s h v ille , 1959. 361 U .S . 924, 80 S .C t.
293, 4 L .E d .2 d 240.
T h e b r i e f on b e h a lf o f th e school a u
th o r i ti e s s t a t e s : “ P la n N o. 1 r e p r e s e n ts
th e f ir s t choice a n d b e s t ju d g m e n t o f th e
racially segregated basis and others with
the discrimination removed.
“Another objectionable feature of the
plan is th at it does not ofFer in any
realistic sense an alternative o r choice
to the members of the minority race.
To hold out to them the right to attend
schools with members of the white race
if the members of th at race consent is
plainly such a dilution of the right itself
ns to rob it of meaning or substance.
The right of Negroes to attend the pub
lic schools without discrimination upon
the ground of race cannot be made to
depend upon the consent of the mem
bers of the majority race."
13.

“6. The following will be regarded as
some of the valid conditions to support
application for transfer:
“a. When a white student would oth
erwise be required to attend a school
previously serving colored students ouly;
“b. When a colored student would
otherwise he required to attend a school
previously serving white students only:
“&lt; When a student would otherwise
•.
be required to attend a school where
the majority of stu d en ts'in th at school
or in his or her grude are of a different
race.”

�fa

«bsbS*T:t£fcrt^
C ite an 285 F .2d 43 (I960)

School B o a rd in e x e rc is in g ‘th e p rim a ry re s p o n s ib ility f o r e lu c id a tin g , a s s e s s in g
a n d s o lv in g ’ th e ‘v a rie d local school p ro b
le m s,’ p lac e d u p o n local school a u th o r i ti e s
b y th e S u p re m e C o u r t’s o p in io n in th e
B ro w n c a se .” O n th e o t h e r h a n d , th e a p
p e lla n ts i n s i s t t h a t th e d i s t r ic t c o u rt
‘‘sh o u ld h a v e o rd e r e d th e D a lla s School
a u th o r i ti e s to a d m it a p p e lla n ts a n d all
o t h e r N e g ro e s s im ila r ly s itu a te d to p u b lic
schools u n d e r t h e i r s u p e rv is io n on a r a
c ia lly n o n d isc rim in a ito ry b a s is a t th e s t a r t
o f th e e n s u in g school te r m .” T h e a p p e l
la n ts f u r t h e r p r a y — a n d w ith m u ch r e a
so n , in v iew o f th e f r u s t r a t i n g h is to r y o f
th is lit ig a t io n — t h a t th is C o u rt sh o u ld
h e re r e n d e r a d e fin ite ju d g m e n t. W e a r e
r e lu c ta n t to s u b s ti tu t e o u r ju d g m e n t f o r
t h a t o f th e d i s t r ic t c o u rt, a n d a r e w illin g
to do so o nly to th e e x te n t n e c e s s a ry to
a s s u r e a p ro m p t s t a r t to w a rd fu ll co m p li
a n c e a n d r e a s o n a b le , even th o u g h con
s e rv a tiv e , p ro g re s s to w a rd b r in g in g
a b o u t th e e nd o f r a c ia l s e g re g a tio n in th e
p u b lic schools “ w ith all d e lib e ra te s p e e d .”
S ee B ro w n v. B o a rd o f E d u c a tio n , 1955,
349 U .S . 294, 299, 75 S .C t. 753, 99 L .E d .
1083. T o t h a t e nd w e d ir e c t t h a t th e d is
t r i c t c o u rt a p p ro v e P la n N o . 1 a s a m e n d
ed, e lin y n a tin g th e r e f r o m p a r a g r a p h 6
q u o te d in fo o tn o te 13, s u p ra .
[ 5 ] I n so d ire c tin g , w e do n o t m e a n
to a p p ro v e th e tw e lv e -y e a r, s ta i r - s te p p lan
“ i n s o f a r a s i t p o s tp o n e s fu ll i n te g r a tio n .”
S e e E v a n s v. E n n is . 3 C ir., 1960, 281 F .2 d
385, 389. T h e d i s t r ic t c o u r t h a s n o t e x
p r e s s ly p a s se d on w h e th e r t h a t m u ch de
la y is n e c e s s a ry , o r w 'h e th e r t h e sp e ed is
to o d e lib e ra te . I t r e t a in s j u r is d ic tio n o f
th e a c tio n d u r in g th e tra n s it i o n .
See
K elley v. B o a rd o f E d u c a tio n o f C ity o f
N a s h v ille , s u p r a ; A a ro n v . C oop er, 8 C ir.,
1957, 243 F .2 d 361, 364. A f t e r th e a p
p ro v a l o f P la n N o. 1 a s a m e n d e d , w ith th e
e lim in a tio n o f p a r a g r a p h 6, th e f u tu r e
o r d e r s o f th e d i s t r ic t c o u r t sh o u ld be gov
e rn e d b y th e ru le so w ell s ta te d in B ro w n
v. B o a rd o f E d u c a tio n , 1955, 349 U .S . 294,
30 0 , 801, 75 S .C t. 753, 756, 99 L .E d . 1083:
“ T h e b u r d e n r e s t s u p o n th e d e
f e n d a n ts to e s ta b lis h t h a t su c h tim e
is n e c e s s a ry in th e p u b lic i n te r e s t
a n d is c o n s is te n t w ith good f a ith

c o m p lia n c e a t t h e e a r l ie s t p r a c tic a b le
d a te . T o t h a t e n d , th e c o u r ts m a y
c o n s id e r p ro b le m s r e la te d to a d m in
is t r a t i o n , a r i s in g f ro m t h e p h y s ic a l
c o n d itio n o f th e school p la n t, th e
school tr a n s p o r t a ti o n s y s te m , p e rs o n
nel, r e v is io n o f school d i s t r ic t s a rid
a tte n d a n c e a r e a s in to c o m p a c t u n i ts
to a c h ie v e a s y s te m o f d e te r m in in g
a d m is s io n to th e p u b lic sch o o ls on a
n o n r a c ia l b a s is , a n d re v is io n o f local
law s a n d r e g u la tio n s w h ic h m a y b e
n e c e s s a r y in s o lv in g th e fo re g o in g
p ro b le m s. T h e y w ill a lso c o n s id e r th e
a d e q u a c y o f ai^y p la n s th e d e fe n d a n ts
m a y p ro p o se to m e e t th e s e p ro b le m s
a n d to e ffe c tu a te a tr a n s it i o n to a r a
cia lly n o n d is c r im in a to r y school s y s
te m . D u r in g t h is p e rio d o f t r a n s i
tio n , th e c o u rts w ill r e t a in j u r i s d ic
tio n o f th e s e c a se s.”
R e v e rse d a n d r e m a n d e d w ith d ire c tio n s
a n d f o r f u r t h e r p ro c e e d in g s.
S u p p le m e n ta l O p in io n .
F u r t h e r c o n s id e ra tio n h a s p e rs u a d e d us
to e la b o r a te u p o n t h a t p a r t o f th e o p in io n
w h ic h r e a d s :
“ A s to P la n N o . 1 a s a m e n d e d , w e
a r e o f th e o p in io n t h a t p a r a g r a p h 6,
q u o te d in th e m a r g in ,13 sh o u ld b e
s tr ic k e n b e c a u se i t s p r o v is io n s re c o g
n ize ra c e a s a n a b s o lu te g ro u n d f o r
th e t r a n s f e r o f s tu d e n ts , a n d i ts a p
p lic a tio n m ig h t te n d to p e rp e tu a te
r a c ia l d is c r im in a tio n . C o m p a re K el
ley v. B o a rd o f E d u c a tio n o f C ity o f
N a s h v ille , 1959, 361 U .S . 92 4 , 80
S .C t. 293, 4 L .E d .2 d 240.
“ n ‘6. T h e fo llo w in g w ill b e r e g a r d
ed a s so m e o f th e v a lid c o n d itio n s to
s u p p o rt a p p lic a tio n f o r t r a n s f e r :
“ ‘a. W h e n a w h ite s tu d e n t w ould
o th e r w is e be r e q u ir e d to a tt e n d a
school p re v io u s ly s e rv in g c o lo re d s tu
d e n ts o n ly ;
“ ‘b. W h e n a co lo red s tu d e n t
w o u ld o th e rw is e b e r e q u ir e d to a t
te n d a school p r e v io u s ly s e rv in g
w h ite s tu d e n ts o n l y ;
“ ‘c. W hen a s tu d e n t w ould o th e r
w is e b e r e q u ir e d to a tt e n d a school

�48

2 * F E D E R A L R E P O R T E R , 2d S E R IE S

(

w h e r e th e m a j o r it y o f s tu d e n ts in
t h a t school o r in h is o r h e r g r a d e a re
o f a d iff e re n t r a c e .’ ”
T h e c a se c ite d , w h ile n o t a u th o r ity , ex
p r e s s e s t h e d o u b t o f th e J u s tic e s w h o
th o u g h t t h a t c e r t io r a r i sh o u ld be g r a n te d
a s to w h e th e r s im ila r p r o v is io n s o f th e
N a s h v ille p la n a r e c o n s titu tio n a lly in
v a lid . W e a r e so d o u b tfu l o f th e v a lid ity
o f th e p ro v is io n s o f P a r a g r a p h 6 t h a t w e
t h in k th e y s h o u ld n o t be in c lu d e d in th e
p lan .

“ D is tin c tio n s
b e tw e e n
c itiz e n s
so lely b e c a u se o f t h e i r a n c e s tr y a r e
b y t h e i r Very n a tu r e o d io u s to a f r e e
people w h o se in s t it u t io n s a r e fo u n d
ed u p o n th e d o c tr in e o f e q u a lity .
F o r t h a t re a s o n , le g is la tiv e c la ssifica
tio n o r d is c r im in a tio n b a s e d on ra c e
a lo n e h a s o f te n b e e n h e ld to b e a
d e n ia l o f e q u a l p ro te c tio n . Y ic k W o
v. H o p k in s . 118 U .S . 356 [6 S .C t.
10G4. 30 L .E d . 2 2 0 ] ; Y u C o n g E n g
v. T r in id a d , 271 U .S. 500 [4 6 S .C t.
619, 70 L .E d . 1 0 5 $ ] ; H ill v. T e x a s ,
316 U .S . 400 [6 2 S .C t. 1159, 86 L .E d .
15591.”

W e fu lly re c o g n iz e th e p r a c tic a lity o f
th e a r g u m e n t c o n ta in e d in th e o p in io n o f
th e S ix th C ir c u it h o ld in g t h a t s im ila r
K iy o sh i H ir a b a y a s h i v . U n ite d S ta te s ,
p ro v is io n s a r e n o t u n c o n s titu tio n a l. K el
1943. 320 U .S . 81, 100, 63 S .C t. 1375,
ley v. B o a rd o f E d u c a tio n o f C ity o f
1385. 87 L .E d . 1774.
N a s h v ille , 6 C ir., 1959, 270 F .2 d 209, 228
T h e s p e cia l p ro v is io n s o f th e e lim in a te d
229, 230. In d ee d , th is C o u r t h a s a d o p te d
p a r a g r a p h 6 a r e o b je c tio n a b le a ls o on
th e r e a s o n in g in B r ig g s v. E llio tt, D.C.
a n o th e r sc o re . T h e y w ould a p p ly a ru le
E .D .S .C .1955, 132 F .S u p p . 776, re lie d on '
o f law to th e d e s e g r e g a te d p u b lic sch o o ls
b y th e S ix th C ir c u it,1 a n d h a s f u r t h e r
o f th e D a lla s School D is tr i c t d iff e re n t
s a id :
f ro m t h a t a p p lic a b le to o t h e r p u b lic
“ T h e e q u a l p r o te c tio n a n d d u e
sch o o ls in th e S t a te o f T e x a s . T h a t p a r a
p ro c e s s c la u s e s o f th e f o u rte e n th
g r a p h w ould a p p a re n tly d e p riv e th e D a l
a m e n d m e n t do n o t a ffirm a tiv e ly com
la s B o a rd o f all d is c re tio n a n d p lac e i t
m an d in te g r a tio n , b u t th e y do fo rb id
u n d e r th e a b s o lu te d u ty to t r a n s f e r th e
a n y s ta t e a c tio n r e q u i r in g s e g re g a
p u p il u p o n a p p lic a tio n w h e n o n e o f th e
tio n on a c c o u n t o f t h e i r ra c e o r color
“ valid c o n d itio n s,” e n tir e ly ra c ia l, e x is ts .
o f c h ild re n in th e p u b lic schools.
O n th e o th e r h a n d , u n d e r th e la w g e n e ra l
A v e ry v. W ic h ita F a lls In d e p e n d e n t
ly a p p lic a b le , th e B o a rd h a s a w id e d is c r e
School D is tr ic t, 5 C ir., 1957, 241 F .2 d
tio n in t r a n s f e r r i n g p u p ils fro m school to
230, 233. P u p ils m ay , o f c o u rse , be
school. A s w a s n o ted in S h u ttle s w o r th
s e p a r a te d a c c o rd in g to t h e i r d e g re e
v. B irm in g h a m B o a rd o f E d u c a tio n , D .C.
o f a d v a n c e m e n t o r r e t a r d a tio n , t h e i r
N .D .A la . 1958, 162 F .S u p p . 372, 378, a f
a b ility t o le a rn , on a c c o u n t o f t h e ir
firm ed , 1958, 358 U .S . 101, 79 S .C t. 221,
h e a lth , o r f o r a n y o th e r le g itim a te
3 L .E d .2 d 1 4 5 : “ B y v i r t u e o f i t s a u th o r i
re a s o n , b u t e ach c h ild is e n title d to
ty to a d m i n i s t e r a n d s u p e rv is e th e p u b lic
be t r e a te d a s a n in d iv id u a l w ith o u t
schools, th e d e fe n d a n t B o a rd m ig h t p r o
r e g a r d to h i s ra c e o r c o lo r.”
v id e f o r th e a s s ig n m e n t o f p u p ils to p a r
B o r d e rs v. R ip p y , 5 C ir., 1957, 247 F .2d
t ic u la r sch o o ls u p o n a n y re a s o n a b le a n d
268, 271.
le g itim a te b a s is .” In th e p u b lic schools
o f T e x a s g e n e ra lly , th e s u b je c t o f t r a n s
[ 6 ] N e v e rth e le s s , w ith d e fe re n c e to
f e r is co v e re d by th e p ro v is io n s o f A r tic le
th e v iew s o f th e S ix th C ir c u it, it seem s to
2901a, S e c tio n 4, V e rn o n ’s T e x a s C iv il
u s t h a t c la ssific a tio n a c c o rd in g to ra c e f o r
S ta tu te s :
p u rp o s e s o f t r a n s f e r is h a rd ly less u n
c o n s titu tio n a l th a n such c la s s ific a tio n f o r
p u rp o se s o f o r ig in a l a s s ig n m e n t to a p u b
lic school.
I.

“ Sec. 4. S u b je c t to a p p e al in th e
re s p e c t p ro v id e d , ea ch Local B o a rd o f
School T r u s te e s s h a ll h a v e fu ll a n d

Avery v. \V „ liiu i Knits Ii&gt;.l-|MMi.lont S.-hoot D istrict,

24
3.

5 C ir.. 1"&gt;7 21 K._M 2 0 2 3
9. 4
3. 3.

�bo so w t

. a rre t

C ite u 285 T .2d t t (1000)

fin al a u th o r i ty a n d r e s p o n s ib ility f o r
th e a s s ig n m e n t, t r a n s f e r a n d con
tin u a n c e o f all p u p ils a m o n g a n d
w ith in th e p u b lic schools w ith in i ts
ju r is d ic tio n , a n d m a y p r e s c r ib e ru le s
a n d r e g u la tio n s p e r t a in i n g to th o se
f u n c tio n s . S u b je c t to re v ie w b y th e
B o a rd a s p ro v id e d h e re in , th e B o a rd
m a y e x e rc ise th is re s p o n s ib ility d i
r e c tly o r m a y d e le g a te i ts a u th o r i ty
to t h e S u p e r in te n d e n t o r o th e r p e r
so n o r p e rs o n s em ployed b y th e
B o a rd . I n th e a s s ig n m e n t, t r a n s f e r
o r c o n tin u a n c e o f p u p ils a m o n g a n d
w ith in th e schools, o r w ith in th e
c la s s ro o m a n d o t h e r f a c ilitie s t h e r e
o f, th e fo llo w in g f a c to r s a n d th e e f
f e c t o r r e s u lts th e r e o f sh a ll be c on
s id e re d , w ith r e s p e c t to t h e in d iv id u
al p u p il, a s w ell a s o t h e r re le v a n t
m a t t e r s : A v a ila b le ro o m a n d te a c h
in g c a p a c ity in th e v a rio u s sc h o o ls;
th e a v a ila b ility o f tra n s p o r t a ti o n
f a c i l i t i e s : th e e ffe c t o f t h e a d m is s io n
o f n e w p u p ils u p o n e s ta b lis h e d o r
p ro p o se d a c ad e m ic p r o g r a m ; th e
s u it a b il it y o f e s ta b lis h e d c u rr ic u la
f o r p a r t i c u l a r p u p ils ; th e a d e q u a c y
o f th e p u p il’s a c ad e m ic p r e p a r a tio n
f o r a d m is s io n to a p a r t i c u l a r school
a n d c u rr ic u lu m ; th e s c h o la s tic a p ti
t u d e a n d r e la tiv e in te llig e n c e o r
m e n ta l e n e rg y o r a b ility o f th e p u p il;
th e psy c h o lo g ic al q u a lific a tio n o f th e
p u p il f o r th e ty p e o f te a c h in g a n d
a s s o c ia tio n s in v o lv e d ; th e e ffe c t o f
a d m is s io n o f th e p u p il upon th e a c a
d e m ic p ro g re s s o f o t h e r s tu d e n ts in
a p a r t i c u l a r school o r fa c ility t h e r e
o f ; th e effect o f a d m is s io n u p o n p r e
v a ilin g a c ad e m ic s ta n d a r d s a t a p a r
t ic u l a r s c h o o l; th e psy c h o lo g ic al e f
f e c t u p o n th e p u p il o f a tte n d a n c e a t
a p a r t i c u l a r s c h o o l; th e p o s s ib ility
o r t h r e a t o f f r ic tio n o r d is o r d e r
a m o n g p u p ils o r o t h e r s ; th e p o s s i
bility o f b re a c h e s o f th e p eace o r ill
w ill o r econom ic r e ta lia tio n w ith in
th e c o m m u n ity ; th e hom e e n v iro n p sy c h o lo g ic al
r e la tio n s h ip s
w ith
2. We intimate no opinion an to the con
stitutionality of any particular provision
of that law. except to say that the law
286 F .2 d —4

o t h e r p u p ils a n d w ith t e a c h e r s ; th e
ch o ice a n d i n te r e s t s o f th e p u p i l ; th e
m o ra ls, c o n d u c t, h e a lth a n d p e rs o n a l
s ta n d a r d s o f th e p u p il; th e r e q u e s t
o r c o n s e n t o f p a r e n ts o r g u a r d ia n s
a n d th e re a s o n s a s s ig n e d th e r e f o r .
“I n c o n s id e r in g th e f a c to r s a n d th e
e ffe c t o r r e s u lts th e r e o f th e B o a r d
o r i t s a g e n ts sh a ll n o t c o n s id e r a ru i
8h all n o t u s e a s a n e le m e n t o f i t s
e v a lu a tio n a n y m a t t e r r e la tin g to th e
n a tio n a l o r ig in o f th e p u p il o r th e
p u p il’s a n c e str a l la n g u a g e.
“ Local B o a rd s m a y r e q u i r e th e a s
s ig n m e n t o f p u p ils to a n y o r all
sch o o ls w ith in t h e i r ju r i s d ic t io n on
th e b a s is o f sex , b u t a s s ig n m e n ts o f
p u p ils o f th e s a m e s e x a m o n g sch o o ls
r e s e rv e d f o r t h a t sex s h a ll be m ad e in
th e l ig h t o f th e o t h e r f a c to r s ' H erein
s e t f o r t h .” 2 ( E m p h a s is o u r s .)
T h e e lim in a te d P a r a g r a p h 6 s e e m s to
u s to c o n flic t w ith th e T e x a s s t a t u t e j u s t
q u o te d . W h e th e r so o r n o t, h o w e v e r, t h a t
T e x a s s ta t u te m a k e s i t c le a r t h a t th e
e lim in a te d P a r a g r a p h 6 is s u p e rflu o u s .
T h e B o a rd a lr e a d y h a d a m p le a u th o r i ty
to t r a n s f e r p u p ils f ro m school to school
u p o n a n y re a s o n a b le a n d le g itim a te b a s is .
O f c o u rs e , th e e lim in a tio n o f P a r a g r a p h
6 in n o w a y a ffe c ts o r d e tr a c ts f ro m t h a t
a u th o r ity . T o a v o id a n y p o ssib le m is
u n d e rs ta n d in g , h o w e v e r, i t se em s a p p ro
p r ia t e to c all a tt e n tio n to th e c a v e a t e m
p h a s iz e d b y th e S u p re m e C o u rt in a ffirm
in g th e S h u ttle s w o r th d e c is io n :
“ A ll t h a t h a s b een s a id in th is
p r e s e n t o p in io n m u s t b e lim ite d to
th e c o n s titu tio n a lity o f th e law u p o n
i t s fa c e . T h e School P la c e m e n t L a w
f u r n is h e s th e leg a l m a c h in e ry f o r a n
o rd e rly a d m in is tr a tio n o f th e p u b lic
sch o o ls in a c o n s titu tio n a l m a n n e r b y
th e a d m is s io n o f q u a lifie d p u p ils
u p o n a b a s is o f in d iv id u a l m e r i t
w ith o u t r e g a r d to t h e i r ra c e o r color.
W e m u s t p re s u m e t h a t i t w ill b e so
a d m in is te re d . I f n o t, in so m e f u tu r e
p ro c e e d in g i t is p o ssib le t h a t i t m a y
as a whole appears to be constitutional
on itft face.
Compare the Shuttelsworth cash, supra.

�T
O

285 FEDERAL SHPORTBR, 2d SERIES

b e d e c la re d u n c o n s titu tio n a l in i ts
a p p lic a tio n . T h e r e s p o n s ib ility r e s ts
p r im a r i ly u p o n t h e local school
b o a rd s , b u t u ltim a te ly u p o n all o f th e
p eo p le o f th e S t a te .”
S h u ttle s w o r th v. B ir m in g h a m B o a rd o f
E d u c a tio n , D .C .N .D .A la.1958, 162 F .
S u p p . 372, 384, affirm ed, 1958, 358 U .S .
101, 79 S .C t. 221, 3 L .E d .2 d 145,
I n v ie w o f t h is e x te n s io n o f th e opin io n ,
i t is o rd e r e d t h a t th e m a n d a te n o t iss u e
u n til tw e n ty -o n e (2 1 ) d a y s f ro m th is
d a te , a n d th e tim e f o r filin g a n y a p p lic a
tio n f o r r e h e a r in g is e x te n d e d a c c o rd in g
ly.

F r a n c is X a v ie r LOfTM A NN , A pp e lla n t,
v.

U N IT E D S T A T E S o f A m e ric a ,
A ppellee.
N o. 16446.
U n ited S ta te s C o u rt o f A p p eals
N in th C ircuit.
Dec. 6, 1960.
R e h e a rin g D enied J a n . 11, 1961.

T h e d e fe n d a n t w a s c o n v ic te d o f
t r a n s p o r t i n g w o m an in i n te r s t a te com
m e rc e f o r p r o s titu tio n .
T h e U n ite d
^ S ta te s D i s tr i c t C o u r t f o r th e D is tr i c t o f
N e v a d a , J o h n R. R oss, J ., e n te r e d j u d g
m e n t, find d e fe n d a n t a p p e ale d .
The
C o u r t o f A p p e a ls, C h a m b e rs , C ir c u it
J u d g e , h e ld t h a t th e p la in e r r o r ru le
w otild n o t b e in voked to c o n s id e r d e fe n d
a n t 's p o in t t h a t t h e r e w a s no d ire c t e v i
d e n c e to c o rr o b o r a te t h e c o n fe ssio n o f
tr a n s p o r t a ti o n , w h e re t h e r e w a s c re d ib le
ev id e n c e to s u p p o r t a ll e le m e n ts o f th e
c rim e .
A ffirm ed.

1. C rim in a l L a w C=S61
D e f e n d a n t’s m o tio n , m a d e a t co n clu
sio n o f g o v e rn m e n t’s c a se , f o r d is m is s a l
o n g ro u n d o f in su ffic ien c y o f ev id e n c e w a s
w a iv e d w h e re d e f e n d a n t w e n t a h e a d a n d
p u t on a d e fe n se .
2. C rim in a l L a w 0=1083
O r d in a r ily , t h e r e is n o re a s o n f o r a
t r i a l c o u r t to c o n s id e r a s ta t e m e n t o f
p o in ts on ap p e al.
.3. C rim in a l L a w 0=1030(1)
B e fo re a p p ly in g th e F e d e ra l R u le o f
C rim in a l P ro c e d u re t h a t p la in e r r o r a f
f e c tin g a s u b s ta n tia l r i g h t m a y be n o tic e d
a lth o u g h n o t b r o u g h t to a tt e n ti o n o f
c o u rt, th e C o u rt o f A p p e a ls sh o u ld b e c o n
v in ced t h a t a n i n ju s tic e w a s d o n e th e d e
f e n d a n t. F e d .R u le s C r im .P ro c . r u le 52
( b ) ,.1 8 U .S.C .A .
4. C rim in a l L a w 0=1036(8)
C o u rt o f A p p e a ls w o u ld /n o t invoke
p la in e r r o r r u le to c o n s id e r d e f e n d a n t’s
p o in t t h a t t h e r e w a s no d ire c t ev id e n c e to
c o rr o b o r a te th e c o n fe ssio n o f t r a n s p o r t a
tio n , w h e re t h e r e w a s c re d ib le evid e n c e to
s u p p o rt all e le m e n ts o f c rim e o f tr a n s p o r
ta tio n o f w o m an in i n te r s t a te c o m m erce
f o r p r o s titu tio n . F e d .R u le s C rim .P ro c .
r u le 5 2 ( b ) , 18 U .S .C .A .; 18 U .S .C .A . §
2421.

H a r r y E . C la ib o rn e , L a s V e g a s, N ev.,
f o r a p p e lla n t.
H o w a rd W . B abcock, U . S. A tty ., L a s
V e g a s, N ev., H e r b e r t F . A h lsw ed e, A s s t.
U . S. A tty ., R eno, N ev ., f o r appellee.
B e fo re C H A M B E R S , H A M L E Y a n d
H A M L IN , C ir c u it J u d g e s .
C H A M B E R S , C ir c u it J u d g e . In th e v o lu n ta ry w r i tt e n c o n fe s s io n o f
L o h m a n n (re c e iv e d in ev id e n c e in t h is
ju d g e - trie d c a se ) th e r e is e n o u g h to con
v in ce one b ey o n d a re a s o n a b le d o u b t t h a t
L o h m a n n “ d id * * * tra n s p o r t in in
t e r s t a t e co m m erce, f ro m H ollyw ood, C a li
f o rn ia , to C la rk C o u n ty , S ta te a n d D is
t r i c t o f N e v a d a , a w o m an , n a m e ly M a r
g a r e t W ells, f o r th e p u rp o se o f p r o s titu -

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="10">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="2122">
                  <text>RG 18: Personal Papers of Barbara Marx</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="10432">
                <text>Court Opinion, Boson v. Rippy, Federal Register, 1961</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="10433">
                <text>US Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit, finding in Boson v. Rippy, published in the Federal Register #285, Second Series. Case relates to integration plans for Dallas Public Schools, specifically assignment of students to public schools to attain full desegregation. Eight pages.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="42">
            <name>Format</name>
            <description>The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="10434">
                <text>pdf</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="48">
            <name>Source</name>
            <description>A related resource from which the described resource is derived</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="10435">
                <text>RG 18, Personal Papers of Barbara Marx</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="39">
            <name>Creator</name>
            <description>An entity primarily responsible for making the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="10436">
                <text>Federal Register</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="10437">
                <text>1961</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="38">
            <name>Coverage</name>
            <description>The spatial or temporal topic of the resource, the spatial applicability of the resource, or the jurisdiction under which the resource is relevant</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="10438">
                <text>1960s</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="47">
            <name>Rights</name>
            <description>Information about rights held in and over the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="10439">
                <text>This image is subject to copyright. Unauthorized use of the images in the Local History Collections of the Arlington Community Archives is prohibited.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="43">
            <name>Identifier</name>
            <description>An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="21373">
                <text>18_1_1_8_24</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="1159" public="1" featured="1">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="955">
        <src>https://projectdaps.org/files/original/0e5b8a060db69230cdffb81a18bf722e.pdf</src>
        <authentication>55c4ff87ade4a4124786e7cbcdd9c099</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="52">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="12296">
                    <text>CS1U0406
FORM C-136

T h e C o m m o n w e a l t h o f V i r g i ^ i m o p arlukjton
To the Sheriff of the-City-of^'F^cfini^nd— Greeting;
We coprfnand you to summon
ySj&amp;rbara S. Marx_______________ 6397 Worth Washington Boulevard
uj

S?

E. Leslie Hamm

1900 North Cameron Street

^ i ^ d w a r d D. Strother
a: u- — i
« &lt;
—

&lt;
f&gt;

2319 South i8th street

e

Jack c - O m d o r f f

5200 North Carlin Spring Road

^
=»
CD

Ladle

5200 North Carlin Spring Road

if. O m d o r f f

ZL
Z
all of Arlington, Virginia

to appear before the Judge of our Circuit Court of the City of Richmond, at the court
301
room of said Court, Rooift^lS, City H ^ i ^ g the City of Richmond, on the 11th
day o f Novem ber,
in behalf of the.

, 19' '

, a'p¥ en o ’
clock A. M., to testify and the truth to say

d e fen d a n ts
in a certain matter of controversy in our said

Court, before the said Judge depending and undetermined
betweeM•A. A. C . P . and N*A*A« C*P* LEGAL DEFENSE, ETC*, ET AL
a m f i lb e r t l s 3. H a r r is o n , J r . , e t c . ,
And have t h e n j f l f ^ j g ^ g g ^
Witness,
4 th
day of
Commonwealth.

et al

defendant.

JR&gt;
Clerk of our said Court,

N ovem ber

plaintiff,

j$ 8

at Richmond, the

and in thi32nd

year of the

LUTHER LIBBY, JR.
Clerk.

___________ %

�CIRCUIT COU RT

V }
s.

Spa. for witness

to .....
/ im S R IIS S&gt; HAHKISOlIf JIU*
\VOt f
X«

■ Hi*.
*
p.q.

B a r b a r a S. M a r x
6897 N o r t h W a s h i n g t o n B o u l e v a r d
Arlington, Virginia

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="10">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="2122">
                  <text>RG 18: Personal Papers of Barbara Marx</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12297">
                <text>Court Summons for Barbara Marx</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12298">
                <text>Summons for Barbara Marx to testify in behalf of the defendants at the Circuit Court for a case concerning the NAACP, plaintiffs, and Albertis S. Harrison, Jr., defendant. Appearance is scheduled for November 11, 1958. 2 pages</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="39">
            <name>Creator</name>
            <description>An entity primarily responsible for making the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12299">
                <text>The Commonwealth of Virginia Circuit Court</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="48">
            <name>Source</name>
            <description>A related resource from which the described resource is derived</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12300">
                <text>RG 18, Personal Papers of Barbara Marx</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12301">
                <text>11/11/58</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="38">
            <name>Coverage</name>
            <description>The spatial or temporal topic of the resource, the spatial applicability of the resource, or the jurisdiction under which the resource is relevant</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12303">
                <text>1950s</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="43">
            <name>Identifier</name>
            <description>An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="21556">
                <text>18_1_7A_1</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="1304" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="1067">
        <src>https://projectdaps.org/files/original/b565d51ccb8add45ab75ab76b4eaf5d9.pdf</src>
        <authentication>b5f6924acbfd2a97c14a2cab3d5ce83f</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="52">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="13502">
                    <text>E X E C U T IV E

O F F IC E R S

LEGAL

VIRG INIA STATE CONFERENCE
National Association for th
&lt;
^ ' o i Colored Peo

TREASURER
DAVID E. LQ N G LEY
R I C H M O N D , VA.
AND

Y O U T H C O U N C IL S
COLLEGE CHAPTERS
S E N I O R A DVI S ER
H. A. MARSHALL
N ORF OL K, VA.

PRES IDENT
L I NW O OD P A R S O N
VI RGI NI A STATE C O L LE GE
P E T E R S B U R G , VA.
BOARD

OF

EXECUTIVE SECRETARY
LESTER BANKS
FALLS C

D IR E C T O R S

^
N O R T H S E C O N D S'
IC H M O N D , V IRGIN IA
DIAL 7 - 5 6 7 B

DR. J. M. TI NS LEY
R I C H M O N D , VA.
DR. S . F. C O P P A G E
NORF OL K, VA.
C. C L AYBOU RN E B US H
CO V IN G TO N , VA.
J . B. C A R R I NG T ON
S O U T H B O S T O N , VA.
MRB. NORVLEATE DOWNI NG
NE WP OR T NEWS, VA.
J AMEB A. DUVALL
P E T E R S B U R G , VA.
C H A R LE S D. FDWLER, JR.
C HAR LOTTEBVILLE, VA.
R. J. B. H E N D E R S O N
NORF OL K, VA.
REV. W. J . H O D G E
L YNC HBU RG, VA.
M R S. BARBARA B. MARX
A R L IN G TO N , VA.
MR S. JULI A E. TUCKER
E MPORI A, VA.

January 23, 1957

confident:

Members of Executive Board
and Legal Staff
Virginia State Conference-NAACP

Enclosed'-are copies of two letters marked

MR S. BURNETTA B. WEST
CU MBER LAN D, VA.
MRB. S A D I E D. WYCHE
IVOR, VA.

Upon receipt of exhibit "A" by registered mail on
January 15, the Secretary consulted with the chairman
of the Legal Staff, Mr, Hill. A conference was held on
the same afternoon with Staff members Robinson, Tucker,
Ealey, Martin and Hill.
President Henderson, executive secretary Roy Wilkins,
and general counsel - Robert Carter were apprised of the
receipt of the letter. The Chairman of the Legal Staff,
members of the Virginia Legal Staff, and members of the
national Legal Staff engaged in further conferences on
Friday, Saturday, and Sunday. As indicated in exhibit
"B", the national Board of Directors will consider the
requests contained in exhibit "A" at its February 11th
meeting.
In order that you may be fully apprised of the
interim developments and give counsel as to the defini
tive action that may be taken; by order of the Presi
dent, you are requested to be present at a joint meeting
of the Board and Legal Staff, at Conference Headquarters,
on Saturday, February 2nd, 12 ot clock noon.

PAY Y OU R

P D L L TAX, R E G I S T E R

AN D VDTE

SU PPO R T THE

FDR

FREEDOM

FIR ST
FOND

CLASS

C ITIZE N SH IP

STAFF

�COPy:

EXHIBIT "A"
January 1U, 1957

Virginia State Conference of N.A.A.C.P. Branches
North 2nd Street
Richmond, Virginia

hOks

Gentlemen:
At the direction of the legislative Committee on Offenses Against the
Administration of Justice, I request you to furnish for the calendar year 1956,
the following information within two weeks from the date hereof:
(1) The names and addresses of the principal, officers of your organisation
and also the names and addresses of the agents, servants, employees, officers
and voluntary workers and associates through whom your organization carries on
its activities in this State, and also the names of your members in this State,
together with the last known addresses of all of the above designated persons;
(2) A certified statement showing the location of each office, branch,
division, council, subsidiary, or other agency through or by which your organi
zation engages in ary activity in this State and the nature of such activity
and the names and addresses of the officers, or other persons in charge of each
such office, branch, division, council, subsidiary, or other agency through or
by which your organization engages in any activity in this State, and the rela
tion of each such office, branch, division, council, subsidiary, or other agency
to your organization;
(3) A certified statement showing in detail by each transaction all con
tributions, donations, gifts, or other income received by your organization
during the year 1956 from sources in this State, together with the names and
addresses of the persons; firms, corporations, and associations from whom such
contributions, donations, gifts, or other income was received; and
(U) A certified statement showing in detail by each transaction all ex
penditures and disbursements made by your organization within this State during
the year 1956, together with the names and addresses of the persons, firms,
corporations, and associations to whom such expenditures and disbursements were
made, and, the names and addresses of the persons, firms, corporations, asso
ciations, and partnerships on whose behalf such expenditures and disbursements
were made.
KLease send this material to the undersigned at the third floor. State.
Capitol Building, Richmond, Virginia.
Tour cooperation in letting me have this information as soon as possible
will be greatly appreciated.
Very truly yours,
/S/

JBBjr:ega

JOHN B. BOATWRIGHT, JR.
John B. Boatwright, Jr., Secretary
Committee on Offenses Against
Administration of Justice

�COPY!

EXHIBIT "B"

January Twenty-second
1
9
5
7

Legislative Committee on Offenses
Against the Administration of Justice
c/o Mr. John B. Boatwright, Jr.
SecretaryState Capitol
Richmond, Virginia
Gentlemen:
Pursuant to my conference of today with Mr. John B. Boatwright,
Jr., I am writing this letter for the purpose of formally requesting an
extension of time for giving you a definitive answer as to whether or not
the Rational Association for the Advancement of Colored People and the
Virginia State Conference of MAACP Branches will voluntarily comply with
the requests contained in a letter dated January ll* addressed to these
respective organizations by your secretary.
Upon receipt of these said letters, staff members of both
organizations conferred with me and after due consideration of the male
factors involved, including the expenses incident to the collection of
this material, it was our considered opinion that a number of questions
of policy are created by this situation and, therefore, these matters
should be submitted to the respective boards of directors.
The national board of directors meets on Monday, February
11, 1957. Thus I request an extension of time until February ill, 1957,
for an initial reply to the said letters of January lU.
I call your attention to the fact that the Virginia State
Conference of MAACP Branches has only two salaried employees— an
executive secretary and a stenographer-clerk. Thus, assuming volun
tary compliance with the requests of your committee, we will need
considerable more time than was originally granted in your letter of
January lit, or than has been asked for in this request for an extension.
However,
submit this matter
will be lost, as I
that they commence
this time in order

if we are granted the extension of time in which to
to the national board, I can assure you that no time
have recommended to both the state and national offices
assembling as much of the material as is possible at
that it may be submitted as expeditiously as possible.

As prompt a reply to this request as can be reasonably obtained
will be greatly appreciated.
Very trulv yours.

Oliver W. Hill, Counsel for
Rational Association for the
Advancement of Colored People
and The Virginia State Con
ference of MAACP Branches

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="10">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="2122">
                  <text>RG 18: Personal Papers of Barbara Marx</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="13494">
                <text>Cover letter to "Members of Executive Board and Legal Staff Virginia State Conference-NAACP", January 23, 1957, from W. Lester Banks, Executive Secretary and Exhibits A and B.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="13495">
                <text>Request for members to attend a "joint meeting of the Board and Legal Staff, at Conference Headquarters, on Saturday, February 2nd, 12 o:clock noon". Concerns "Exhibits A and B". Exhibit A: letter requesting NAACP Board and Legal Staff to submit specific information to John B. Boatwright, Jr., Secretary, Committee on Offenses Against Administration of Justice, January 14 1957. Exhibit B: Letter requesting and extension of time to fulfill requirements in letter (Exhibit A), from Oliver W. Hill, Counsel for National Association for the Advancement of Colored People and the Virginia State Conference of NAACP Branches, January 22, 1957. 3 pages.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="42">
            <name>Format</name>
            <description>The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="13496">
                <text>pdf</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="48">
            <name>Source</name>
            <description>A related resource from which the described resource is derived</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="13497">
                <text>RG 18, Personal Papers of Barbara Marx</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="39">
            <name>Creator</name>
            <description>An entity primarily responsible for making the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="13498">
                <text>Virginia State Conference, National Association for the Advancement of Colored People</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="13499">
                <text>1957-01-22</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="38">
            <name>Coverage</name>
            <description>The spatial or temporal topic of the resource, the spatial applicability of the resource, or the jurisdiction under which the resource is relevant</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="13500">
                <text>1950s</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="47">
            <name>Rights</name>
            <description>Information about rights held in and over the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="13501">
                <text>This image is subject to copyright. Unauthorized use of the images in the Local History Collections of the Arlington Community Archives is prohibited.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="43">
            <name>Identifier</name>
            <description>An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="21676">
                <text>18_2_1_3_38</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="1194" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="990">
        <src>https://projectdaps.org/files/original/9a5fb10f9b88d97ac858fe9a4e402344.pdf</src>
        <authentication>70f2f5f6b5e00d01b470d895e94540a0</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="52">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="12653">
                    <text>VIRGINIA STATE CONFERENCE - NAACP
ItOltJ North Second Street
Richmond, Virginia

December 31, 1959

TO s

Members of Executive Board and Legal Staff of the
Virginia State Conference-NAACP

FRCM 8

W. Lester Banks, Executive Secretary,
Virginia State Conference-NAACP

SUBJECTS

Report of the Committee on Offenses Against the
Administration of Justice (The Boatwright Committee)

Attached is the correct reproduction of the full report as submitted to the Honorable J„ Lindsay Almond, Jr., Governor of the Commonwealth
of Virginia.
Because the report, in the main, is a direct attack on the Asso­
ciation, the Conference and the Fund, we deemed it expedient to place copies
in hands of the officials concerned prior to the printing of the report which
will not be available for general distribution until some time after mid
January i960.

WLB/gsp

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="10">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="2122">
                  <text>RG 18: Personal Papers of Barbara Marx</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12645">
                <text>Cover Letter to Board and Staff of Virginia NAACP from W. Lester Banks, December 31. 1959</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12646">
                <text>Cover letter to Virginia NAACP Executive Board and legal staff from W. Lester Banks, Executive Secretary, dated December 31, 1959. Letter came with copy of full report of the anti-NAACP and segregationist Committee on Offenses Against the Administration of Justice, also known as the Boatwright Committee).</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="42">
            <name>Format</name>
            <description>The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12647">
                <text>pdf</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="48">
            <name>Source</name>
            <description>A related resource from which the described resource is derived</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12648">
                <text>RG 18, Personal Papers of Barbara Marx</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="39">
            <name>Creator</name>
            <description>An entity primarily responsible for making the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12649">
                <text>W. Lester Banks</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12650">
                <text>1959-12-31</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="38">
            <name>Coverage</name>
            <description>The spatial or temporal topic of the resource, the spatial applicability of the resource, or the jurisdiction under which the resource is relevant</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12651">
                <text>1950s</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="47">
            <name>Rights</name>
            <description>Information about rights held in and over the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12652">
                <text>This image is subject to copyright. Unauthorized use of the images in the Local History Collections of the Arlington Community Archives is prohibited.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="43">
            <name>Identifier</name>
            <description>An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="21591">
                <text>18_1_9_1_28</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="1024" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="821">
        <src>https://projectdaps.org/files/original/0ee5c09f204b8aa952923ec9b359ad4f.pdf</src>
        <authentication>932f6f8283ba1c4c10ba86018d76dd81</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="52">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="10959">
                    <text>V I R G I N I A

1 9 6 2
S TAT E

BUDGET
CONFE R E N C E - N A A C P

19 6 1
P rojected
D is b u r s e m e n t s
(Based on 10 months
I T E M ___________________ e x p e n d i t u r e s )

Recommended
by
Approved
Budget Committee_____ Amount

2.

3.

S alaries:
A. E x e c u t i v e S e c r e t a r y
B. O f f i c e S e c r e t a r i e s
C. J a n i t o r i a l S e r v i c e

$7,000.00
6 ,1 8 5 . 0 7
60 0 .0 0

$7,500.00
4,500.00
60 0 .0 0

$7,000.00
4,500.00
6 0 0 .0 0

T o ta l S a la r ie s

1.

1 3 ,7 8 5 .0 7

1 2 ,6 0 0 .0 0

1 2 ,1 0 0 .0 0

65 0 .0 0

8 3 0 .0 0

83 0 .0 0

A c c o u n tin g S e r v i c e :
T r e a s u r y and A u d i t i n g
E x p en ses
Bond Premiums
A. T r e a s u r e r
B. E x e c u t i v e S e c r e t a r y

6 7 .5 0
12.50

67.50
12.50

6 7 .5 0
12.50

4.

Rent - M a in te n an ce

1 , 2 2 1 .8 5

1,200,00

1 , 2 0 0 .0 0

5.

U tilitie s

1 , 6 2 5 .1 9

1 , 6 0 0 .0 0

1 , 6 0 0 .0 0

6,

O f fic e Supplies

2 ,3 0 1 . 4 9

2,300.00

2,300.00

7.

T ravel

3 , 3 9 2 .5 3

4,300.00

4,300.00

8.

L e g a l F ees and E xpenses

9,695.56

1 5 ,0 0 0 .0 0

1 5 ,0 0 0 .0 0

9.

S pecial P ro je c ts

8 ,6 1 4 . 8 7

9,000.00

9,000.00

10.

P ublic R e la tio n s

871 .46

8 7 5 .0 0

87 5 .0 0

11.

Suf f r ag e

1,329.69

2,000.00

2,000.00

12.

S o c i a l S e c u r i t y Taxes

347 .5 5

3 0 0 .0 0

30 0 .0 0

13.

R e ser v ed f o r C o n t i n g e n c i e s

61 5 .9 9

915 .0 0

91 5 .0 0

$ 4 4 ,5 3 1 .2 5

$ 5 1 ,0 0 0 .0 0

$50,500.00

TOTALS

•

�VIRGINIA STATE CONFERENCE OF BRANCHES, N A A C P

A N T I C I P A T E D

I NCOME

f o r
CAL E NDAR

YEAR

REGULAR MEMBERSHIPS

1 9 6 2

$ 12,000.00

(Based on 30 ,0 0 0 members @ $ . 4 0 p e r member)
FREEDOM FUNDS
SPECIAL PROJECTS

TOTAL INCOME

30,000.00
9,000.00

$ 51,000.00

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="10">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="2122">
                  <text>RG 18: Personal Papers of Barbara Marx</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="10951">
                <text>Cover Page and Chart: "Virginia State Conference of Branches, NAACP Anticipated Income of Calendar Year 1962", "1962 Budget Virginia State Conference-NAACP", no date. 2 pages.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="10952">
                <text>1961 Projected Disbursements (Based on 10 months expenditures) with monies recommended by Budget Committee and Amount Approved.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="42">
            <name>Format</name>
            <description>The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="10953">
                <text>pdf</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="48">
            <name>Source</name>
            <description>A related resource from which the described resource is derived</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="10954">
                <text>RG 18, Personal Papers of Barbara Marx</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="39">
            <name>Creator</name>
            <description>An entity primarily responsible for making the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="10955">
                <text>NAACP</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="10956">
                <text>1961</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="38">
            <name>Coverage</name>
            <description>The spatial or temporal topic of the resource, the spatial applicability of the resource, or the jurisdiction under which the resource is relevant</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="10957">
                <text>1960s</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="47">
            <name>Rights</name>
            <description>Information about rights held in and over the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="10958">
                <text>This image is subject to copyright. Unauthorized use of the images in the Local History Collections of the Arlington Community Archives is prohibited.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="43">
            <name>Identifier</name>
            <description>An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="21424">
                <text>18_1_1_9_1</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="2270" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="1982">
        <src>https://projectdaps.org/files/original/ec79a2b62af27dde6c56171dad25f8d0.pdf</src>
        <authentication>1c2441abd94c33805651e1ee561707d8</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="52">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="24248">
                    <text>United States Court of Appeals
F O R T H E F O U R T H C IR C U IT

No. 71-1791
JO H N K. HART,

et

a l

.,

A p p e lla n ts,
v.

C O U N T Y SCH O O L BOARD OF
A R L IN G T O N CO UN TY , e t a l .,
A p p ellees.

Appeal from the United States District Court for the
Eastern District of Virginia a t Alexandria —

cC ti ClCc '-£&lt;___

BRIEF FOR APPELLEES

ISSU E PRESENTED FO R REVIEW

The sole issue presented for review in this case is whether
or not the desegregation plan adopted by the Arlington
County School Board and put into effect in September,
1971, is constitutionally valid.
STA TEM EN T OF T H E C.ASE

On M ay 6, 1970, plaintiffs initiated this action to com
plete the elim ination of racial segregation in the public
schools of A rlington County (App. 5) .l .An answer on behalf
1 All references App. are to pages in the printed appendix

�Felder v. I I n ih 'U (anility lSt&gt;is &gt; of Edncnlinii, Ill9 l ‘.?il 10/0 ( ,'ih
1
Cir., 1969) .............................................................................. iv», | ?J&lt;

I.S.iU B I'KlttiKrfTKW f u l l K liV IB W .............................................................. ;................

1

.Si-Ari::ii-..\ r o v t u b ( U : i k .........................................................................

1

Given v. County School Board of New Kent County, 391 U.S. 190
(
............................................................................................ . ..8 , 27

St

3

Creen v. School Hoard of City of Roanoke, 316 F.Supp. 6 (W .ll.
Va. 1970) ..................................... /....................................................... 21

a t k mk n t

u i'

t u b

Fa

c t s

............ ..................................................................

Ak o iim b n t

The. Desegregation Plan Adopted And Pul Into Ell'ccl By Tlic
Arlington County Scliool Board Is Constitutionally Valid..........
C o n c i.iis io n

llancy v. County Board of Education of Sevier County, 429 l\2 d
361 (8th Cir., 1970) ...............................................
21
7

............... - ............................................................................ 26

ClCilYll-TUATK .....................................................

'i A u /.ii

o f

28

c a ses

denied 10! ll.S. 912 (1971) ..........4, 8, 9, 10, 12, 19, 22, 23, 26
All-.'.and. t v. Holme.. County Boaul of Education, 396 U.S. 19
(1969) .................................................................................................. 8
Allen v. A.lievillc City Hoard of Education, 434 l''.2d 902 (4lli Cir.,
1970) ................................................................................. 17, 19, 20, 25
Bindley v. School Hoard of City of Richmond, 323 1\ Snpp. 828
(li.n . Va., 1971) ...........
25
V.

I.andis, 314 F. Sup. 971 (N .l). Cal., 19G9) *............ 14, 20, 22

r.u.v.o v. i:.»..d of l'aliu.'liiHi, 317 U.S. 188 (I9 .il) ....................

8

"

8

I

n v. I'.oaol of I'.ilui'.iliiui, a!9 U.S. 2 ''I (lOn.'i) ...................
3 .uni.' i .
( ••!' «

i*

v. f.
In ' I I .

lo » II f'oiiiiiy P.Mid of V'di.t' ilio.i, !‘'3 l'.2d til3
l*
I’liMj
l!i, 19, ■
'.&lt;
.1 I ■
.1 . ■
. . (I •/ I f

Mims v. Duval County School Board, 329 F. Supp. 123 (M l).
Fla., 1971) v.;..................................................................................23, 21
Swann v. Charlottc-Mccklcnburg Board of Education, 402 U.S. I
(1971) .................................................. 2, 4, 8, 9, 10, 12, 19, 22, 27

A il. 'ms V. S il'.i.n l I tistiii.l No. 5, I!! F.2d 99 ( l i l t Cir., 1971) cert,

Brim

Lee v. Matron County Board of Education, 418 l\2 d 716 (5th Cir.,
1971) .........
:........................................ 21

'

I I

11.

Walton v. Nashville, Arkansas, Special School D i'tiiit No. I, -101
F.2d 137 (8th Cir., 1969) ................................................................. 26
Wanner v. County School Board of Arlington County, 337 F.2d 152
(4th Cir., 1966) ................................................................................. 16

�3

2

of i!u‘ ('.ouuty School .Hoard ol Ailiuglon County and the
Divi- i. a Superintendent of Schools of Arlington County
was timely hied (App. 8 0), and discovery procedures in
volving interrogatories to defendants and requests for (lie
production of documents wore thereafter initiated by the
plaint ills (App. 1).
On March 5, 19VI, a pre-trial conference was held, at
which time a hearing on the merits was scheduled for July
26, 1971 (R. 70).2 The hearing in this case was deliberately
postponed by the District Court to await the decision of the
United States Supreme Court in Swann v. Charloltc-McckIcnbur» Board of Education, 402 U.S. 1, and its companion
cases (App. 10).^
On June.20, 1971, the Arlington County School Board
adopted and filed in the District Court its plan for the estab
lishment of a unitary school system throughout the county,
which plan was to be pul into effect in September, 1971
(App. 19 2.9). On the morning of the hearing, plaintiffs
aiiundcd their complaint to state their objections to the
plan (App. 6-7, 11), which objections were subsequently
oveiruled and the school board’s plan approved by the Dis
trict Court in its memorandum opinion and order of August
10, 1971 (App. 10-15). Sec, 329 I\ Snpp.953.
On August 12, 1971, plaintiffs filed in the District Court
their notice of appeal (R. 67) and on August 20, 1971 also
filed an application for injunction pending appeal which
was denied by the District Com I the same day. Thereafter,
plaiiitilis filed a similar application in this Court, w'liich
apphea-jon was denied on September 3, 1971. See, Record
in i\o. /I-1/92 (4 flir., 1971). A fm Iher.such application
v. ■| • ‘ ill• d to the (llii. f justice of the I htiled Stall » e.
,
(an &gt;i• jn tin: fi« ihe 15an ill ( ui cuil, and deni.. I him on
•
.
by
!a pi* i..!»• i !. l'i/1. Sec, r!o. A 2t&gt;’', I1 I &lt;n.i,
. )/1
■ i
I

*

i i.«* I1 .‘i** l &gt;&gt; |.
.,

1 i!
.1

i.*i»i*l.

.j I A l b m I*., i i O i'

j

11 !* ,*/ f; i ,S
j

'I he Arlington Comity Si.liool Divi.ion m .brace., ih, inlire county of Arlington and has an area of 25.7 squam
miles, ft is less than one-half the size of the City of l-’iiii
mond which has an area of 63 square miles, and les than
one-tenth the size of the adjacent county of Fairfax which
has an area of 402 square miles (App. 41).
For the school year 1971-72, the total elementary school
population of the Division was estimated to be 11,233 stu
dents, of which number 9,903 w'crc while and 1,250 uric
Negro. Thus the racial ratio in the elementary schools was
09% white and 11% black (App. 15, 22), which ratio is
substantially identical to that for the preceding years. See,
Answers to Interrogatories (R. 19).
At the beginning of the 1969-70 school year, the high
schools and junior high schools of the county had been de
segregated, while the elementary schools were being operated
on the basis of geographic attendance zones established for
each school. Under this arrangement, two of the twentynine elementary schools in the system-—
Drew' aiul 1IoffmauBoston-- -were attended solely by Negro students, as the
geographical boundaries of those schools encompassed all
Negro residential areas, while eleven of the twenty-nine were
attended by all, or virtually all, white students (App. 15, 35,
42). The IIofTmnn-Boston school also housed seventh grade
students, of which some 70% were white students h.i- ed in
from other districts in the comity (App. 12). On Dee. ml . i
18, 1969, the school board adopted a res.&gt;h.!ion dinning
the Division Superintendent and his si.ill t« prepare a si • i
*
study of the various alternatives available for de-egi. ,i
the Drew Kir nent.uy .Vhnol (App. 29 50). I li; i, !i.• . ■i
‘
suggested e. ■ 'illation with appropriate haler d . .. • '. . a
%
step win. I. ha ! .the :d) Iie&gt; n taken by toe 1' i- .« i * .
■ •

�•I

tendenl who (1) li:ul discussed the matter generally with
representatives of the Department uf Health, Education and
Welfare (lil'AV) earlier in llio month (2) had caused data
requested by 1I1CW to be compiled by his stall and sub
mitted and (3) was awaiting return of specific suggestions
from HEW for consideration by his stalT and the school
board (App. 13). In the interim, the Division Superintend
ent directed his research department to begin its own study
of the problem in line with the school board’s resolution
(App. 13).
No response was ever received from IIEW, and shortly
after the research department had assembled its own data
and begun a consideration of alternatives, the instant suit
was filed (App. 44). Thereafter, the school board was ad
vised of the. pendency of the Charlotlc-Mecklcnburg litiga
tion which would in all probability shed light on the prob
lem the board was considering, and the board decided to
await the outcome of that litigation before determining the
method of desegregating Drew Elementary School (App.
41). No attempt was made by the plaintiffs to seek a hear
ing of this matter for the 1970-71 school year.
On April 20, 1971, the Swann ease was decided. There
after the school board and its staff returned to a consider
ation of the Drew school situation, but this time did so in
the huger context of establishing a unitary school system
throughout the county in compliance with Swann (App.
41). On June If), 1971, while these deliberations were going
on, i 1 i . flout t derided a seiiex of cases under the style of
Attains v. School District j\'o. !&gt;, O rangeburg Co., S.C ., 4 14
V»&gt; •i,, &lt;ilii dly Ci uphn ■i/.iiig for district com ls and
.
1
■1
1
11. \\* • 1 iir: rep. &gt;l ; of So',m i l and D o r i s V l i n o n l
1

/&lt;&lt;/../
r'.// •» i IS n j . \ i , , l n h C o u n t y , 101 I).
1.. •&lt; V • i ! . ..ft. , . 1t i n , ii \, ilit-: rh&lt;mi! 1•• ‘.iid ad*&lt;pli d end
.

filed in the District (limit its plan for the operation of a
unitary system in Arlington County (App. 19).
As staled by the Division .Superintendent, the purpo.es of
the school board’s plan were “first of all, primarily to elimi
nate all vestiges of a dual sysli m, to move to establish a u ue
unitary system throughout the county, to provide and to
establish racial balanced schools, and I think, then, to gd
on with the primary purpose of the school system which is
the education of young people.” (App. 40). These objec
tives would be accomplished by converting both the Drew
and IIufirnan-Boston schools to specialized pre-kindergarten
and kindergarten facilities. In addition, the Drew school
would also house an experimental model elementary school
to be conducted on an integrated basis and utilizing imagi
native new approaches to elementary education, as well as
for adult education and other school programs. The 1lolTman-Boston school would also be utilized, as in previous
years, for the integrated seventh grade of the Thomas JcITerson Junior High School (App. 10, 19-20). Former Drew
and IIofTman-Boston students in grades one through six
would be assigned to other elementary schools in the county
in accordance with the following criteria (App. 21):
A. The added students would not cause the receiving
school to have an enrollment exceeding its established
rated capacity by more than 5%,
B. The ratio of black to while pupils in each school
would be as close to 11 % as practical, u ilhin a range of
7 % to 15%, with the exception of four element uy
schools whose cut rent enrollment already exceeded
15% (i.c. I5»% to 22%).
C. Family groupings would be taken into .itv.-i ei ni
assignments to a particular school, s o that I m i!;, e m .
would not he broken up.
I). T ran .jiort.ilion would he provided a*, u. .d .l

�G

V

lim in' lln' school board's plan, all oiie-racc schools in
Arlington County aiv eliminated there remain no one ran:
white schools aiul no one-race black schools. Moreover, stu
dents advancing from an elementary school will attend ihc
junior l»i?_;h school serving thal clcmcnlary school and, in
turn, will advance to the high school serving that particu
lar junior high school (App. 20, 24). This feeder system
insures that for the 1971-72 school year, and for every school
year thereafter, every child in Arlington county will receive
his elementary and secondary education in an integrated
facility (App. 39-10). In addition, nineteen of the twentythree elementary schools affected by the plan will have racial
ratios which fall within the 7% to 15% range established
by the board as a target deviation from the 11% racial
ratio of the system as a whole (App. 15, 22). Indeed, seven
teen of these nincti on schools fall within one percent of the
1 1% racial ratio in the system as a whole (App. 15). Finally,
faculty di x'gregation is achieved by establishing a ratio in
each sc In ml as close to the ratio of black to white teachers
in the school system as a' whole, as is practical (App. 25).
In no case is there more than a •!% deviation from the sys
tem wide ratio (App. 25).
The longest bus ride (in terms of lapsed time) fpr the
former Drew and 1 loffman-Bostnu pupils i.&lt; 29 pinnules,
while the average bus ride for such children isT?2 minutes
(App. 12, '10-11). Similarly, the average bus ride for ele
mentary children in the system as a whole is also 22 minutes
(App. II). The additional transportation costs involved in
the i hi o! lai id’s plan is appro, imately .$11,000 per year.
Adoj•t'i mi iif an all cinale p Ian to achieve the same dr give of
..f lh. |)i. vv and
inlegi i: " a would involve hii-ing 90
ill
1hili’i, i !’•• M ' 1udi ills to III III 1 ' 1IIIml. uid i• | il.il ill;;
ill. Ill '.Mil .ill 1•|1li. di nl in'.ill.i i i.f \. hile ‘ t.i'l- ill . 111III 1
1
i
1 .III
1. 1 ' 1 . • ■ * l • 1 1 , .i,l.| , in i •1 . .i i. i.: ■ 1 M. i i.l
. •

and an additional cost of 0 1iff),000 per yini i l ni e a f n r for
transportation. Thirteen new buses, plus ihiveis, would b :
required for such an alternative “90% out 90% in” plan
(App. 12, 45-48). Sec also, Jhief fur the Appellants, p. 17.
No alternate plan .submitted by the plaintiffs would ilinnnatc all one-race schools in the county, nor achieve as mueli
actual desegregation as the school board’s plan (App. 50,
64).
ARGUMENT
Tlic Desegregation Plan Adopted And Put Into F.flcct Hy The
Arlington County School Hoard Is Constitutionally Valid.

Plaintiffs in the ease at bar arc Negro children who had
been assigned to the Drew Elementary School when this
suit was instituted and the parents or guardians of such chil
dren. Asserting that all, or virtually all, of the pupils a- signed
to the Drew Elementary School were Negioes, plnintiils
alleged that the Arlington County School Poarcl hail failed
to adopt and execute a plan “to c o m p le te ly c o u n c il said
public school system to a u n ita r y n o n ra cia l s y s te m ." (App.
4 ). (Emphasis supplied.) They sought an order from the
District Court requiring the defendant school hoard “to
adopt and forthwith implement” such a plan (App. 5 ).
Even before this suit was filed, the school hoard had been
aware of the Drew situation and had, by formal resolution,
directed a stall study to be made of various alternatives for
desegregating the Drew School. This resolution, however,
did not .specifically embrace the 1 Inffm.m Po»lon f l u : , ,i
tary School, the only oilier all Negro school in the Coe .&gt; ,
nor did it envision ilie desegregation of the view i .ill
or virtually all while, elementary schools in die i . . .
.school system.
After the study co-ilvni| I lied by the i&gt; o*. . i '■ I t , i
iiiiii-i. d and piior to tee dale set lq the 1' ’
. t'

�9

8
hearing of this matter (July M 1 9/1), IIn* Supreme (loitrl
l*,
the S w a n n ami / h.vy’.v cases, s u p ra , (/\p» il M , 1971),
O
mwl this Court decided tho A d a m s cases, s u p ra , (June 10,
1971). Because of the existence of A ih n n s , no independent
analysis need now be made of S w a n n and D a v is, nor of their
progenitors, B r o w n , G re e n and A le x a n d e r .* In A d a m s , this
Court remanded a series of school desegregation cases to
their respective district courts with instructions to receive
from the various school boards “new plans” which would
give effect to S w a n n and D a v is. I d ., at 100. During the
course of its opinion, this Court spelled out what is now
required of district courts and school authorities in the fol
lowing explicit language (M 1 1\ 2d at 100-1.01):

d e c id e d

“It is now clear, we think, that in school systems that
hav e previou ly been operated separately as to the races
by reason of slate action, “the district judge or sch o o l
a u th o r itie s .should m a le, e v e r y r fj o i l to a c h ie v e th e
"rea li st possible d e g re e o f a c tu a l d e seg re g a tio n , tairing
in to a c c o u n t th e p r a c tic a litie s o f th e s itu a tio n .” Davis,

supra at ..... 91 S.Ct. at 1292. We remand these cases
because the respective district judges did not have the
benefit of the Supreme Court mandate that a d e q u a te
c o n sid e ra tio n be g iv e n " t o th e possible use o f bus tra n sp o llu tio n a n d sp lit z o n i n g Davis, supra at ...... , 91

S.Ct. til 1292. Wherever schools arc “all or predomi
nately of one race in a district of mixed population
(there will be required) close scrutiny to determine
t h a t m I i o o I assignments are not part of stale-enforced
si egalion.” Swann, supra at ......, 91 S.Ct. at 1281.
Although the existence of “some small number of nuei:&gt;&lt;e, or vitlnally one-race, schools within a district is
o'.t in and o f h .\e |f die maik of a system which still
■■
■!•
11

i

..,

■ .i

I/

t:
o,

■•

.

i ■ • i • .'')

c

•,

&gt; /:

f.s .
. &lt;■
:■ .&lt;

( f i i i) if) t is.'/&gt;&lt;i i
V. . . - t : . , a

i.

./ / ' .

"ui

i,

practices segregation by law,” fiwanii, supra at ... , 91
S.Ct. at 12b I, b o th th e s c h o o l a iil.'io iily a n d th e d i //&lt;■ l
ju d g e m u s t n e v e r th e le s s be c o n c e r n e d w ith th e e l i m i
n a tio n o f o n e -ra c e sch o o ls.

The school authorities and the district court should
consider the use of till techniques for desegregation, in
cluding pairing or grouping of schools, n o n c o n tig u o u s
a tte n d a n c e zo n e s, restructuring of grade levels, a n d th e
tr a n s p o r ta tio n o f p u p ils .” (Italicssupplied.)
Emphasizing the imperative nature of the commands itali
cized above was (1) (he specific authorization conferred
upon district courts to employ independent educational
experts at the expense of any local school board which sub
mitted a plan that did not comply “with the directions set
forth in this opinion . . .” and (2) the requirement that any
district court which approved a plan achieving lc.-s actual
desegregation than would be achieved under an alternative
plan must find facts that made impracticable the achieving
of a greater degree of integration " e s p e c ia lly i f th e r e re m a in
a n y schools a ll or p r e d o m in a n tly o f o n e ra ce.” I d ., at 101.
(Emphasis supplied.)
■/ With the prescriptions of S w a n n and D a v is thus focused
in the commands of A d a m s , it was obvious that any plan for
the establishment of a unitary school system in Arlington
County which contemplated the desegregation of Do w
School only and which left another elementary seb.e.l
with an all-Negro student body and eleven other element u v
schools with all-while, or virtually all-white, student I .-.I;. '
—could not possibly survive judicial appraisal. U a unit uy
j'/slem was to be eslabli-.hed, all of the t le.e.eni u s -e!
comprising that sjsle.n would have in be coudde. -I
I
desegregated il rea.-.on.iblj po« ible. Conti n \ to a; . !!

�10

11

assertion, this was not a “self-imposed objective” of the
defendant school board; it was a judicially imposed impera
tive. See, Brief for the Appellants, p. 16. The command that
the Arlington County School Board must “be concerned
with the elimination of onc-race schools” could hardly be
complied with merely by passing a resolution expressing
such concern and taking no other action, especially when the
elimination of all onc-race schools in the county was not only
possible, but feasible. A d a m s , su p ra , at 101.
In this setting, the school board adopted and submitted to
the District Court a plan which (1) achieved the greatest
possible degree of actual desegregation, taking into account
the practicalities of the situation (2) eliminated all onc-race
schools, both white and Negro (3) insured that every child
in the Arlington school system will receive both his elemen
tary and secondary education in an integrated facility (4)
established in substantially all of the elementary schools a
student racial ratio which reflects the racial ratio of the
system as a whole (5) racially balanced the faculties in each
elementary school in the county so that the ratio of white to
black faculty members in each school is substantially the
same as the ratio of white to black faculty members in the
system as a whole and (6) established in Arlington County
a unitary school system which has neither “white” schools
nor “black” schools—just schools.
Achievement of the above stated objectives in compliance
with the prescriptions of S w a n n and D a vis and the com
mands of A d a m s was possible in only two ways. One method
— that adopted by the school board- entailed the conversion
of the Drew and HofFman-Boston ehools from traditional
elementary facilities to other educational programs anti the
&lt;-nahlishment within the all-Negro v&lt; ographic areas of those
.schools of a series of “satellite” /&lt; i.' by which elementary

pupils formerly assigned to Drew and HolTman-Boston
would be assigned to various all-white, or predominantly
white, schools in the county in accordance with criteria
which would not only integrate every elementary school in
the system, but would indeed racially balance substantially
all of such schools. Bus transportation would be provided by
the school board for all the pupils thus reassigned, 704 in
number, and no such pupil would be required to be bused
for as much as one-half hour to reach his newly assigned
school. Indeed, since Arlington County is only seven miles
long and slightly more than three miles wide, the average
bus ride for such children would be the same as that for ele
mentary pupils in tbe county generally. Care was taken to
insure that no family groups would be disturbed by the new
plan, and a feeder system was adopted to insure that the
racial balance achieved in the elementary schools would be
preserved, and even heightened, over the years.
No overcrowding results under the school board’s plan,
and the additional transportation cost incurred would be
approximately $11,000 per year. In addition, the plan en
ables the school board to utilize the existing Drew and
HofTman-Boston facilities for other innovative and highly
desirable educational programs designed to increase the
already outstanding excellence of the Arlington school sys
tem. In this connection, it should be emphasized that the
Drew and HofTman-Boston schools arc n o t being closed or
removed from the public school system or converted to
administrative or non-cducational uses. On the contrary,
these facilities have been reprogrammed under the school
board’s plan to serve exclusively educational functions in
the emerging fields of pre-kindergarten instruction for chil
dren three and four years of age, model elementary school
experimentation in ungraded education and for adult cdu-

�12

13

cation. In this setting, appellants’ assertion that the school
hoard's plan must be examined as if the Drew school was
being “used to store furniture” is surely wide of the mark.
See, brief for the Appellants, p. 24.
Essentially the school board’s plan for establishing a uni
tary system of elementary schools in Arlington County tracks
that utilized for the junior high schools in the CharlottcMecklenburg school system in S w a n n , which was subsequently approved by this Court and the Supreme Court. As
stated by the Supreme Court (402 U.S., at 9 ):

and replacing them with an equal number of white students
drawn from the various predominantly white schools in the
county. Mathematically, such a plan would require (a) re
moving 102 of the 114 Negro elementary pupils at lloflmanBoston, leaving 12 Negro pupils there to be joined by 102
replacement white students from other schools in the county
and (b) removing 530 of the 590 Negro elementary pupils
at Drew, leaving 60 Negro pupils there to be joined by
530 replacement white students also drawn from other
schools throughout the county. Such a plan (1) would sub
stantially double the amount of busing necessary to achieve
a unitary system (2) would entail an initial expenditure of
$206,000 (including thirteen new buses) for the first year
and an expenditure of $130,000 per year thereafter and
(3) would, by unnecessarily continuing Drew and HoffmanBoston as traditional elementary schools, deprive the school
board of facilities for its pre-kindergarten, model elemen
tary school and adult education programs.
By contrast to the plans described above, it is manifest
at a glance that neither of the plans espoused by the appel
lants in their brief even remotely approaches compliance
with the controlling constitutional requirements. Sec, Brief
for the Appellants, Appendix A. The first of these plans en
visions the desegregation of Drew School by pairing or
clustering it with five other elementary schools in the vi
cinity, and is based upon a working paper prepared by the
staff of the defendant school board pursuant to the resolu
tion previously mentioned. While the plan effectively de
segregates the Drew school, it falls far short of establishing a
unitary school system in Arlington County. Under this plan,
the elementary portion of the Hoffinan-Boston school re
mains an all-Negro facility, while four other schools in the
county (Custis, Jamestown, Madison and Woodmont) re-

“The Finger plan for the junior high schools employed
much of the rezoning plan of the board, combined with
the creation of nine “satellite” zones. Under the satel
lite plan, inner-city Negro students were assigned by
attendance zones to nine outlying predominantly white
junior high schools, th e r e b y s u b s ta n tia lly d e se g re g a tin g
e v e r y ju n io r h ig h sc h o o l in th e s y s t e m (Italics sup
plied.)
In addition, the feeder system aspect of the school board’s
plan (1) counters the specific objection expressed by this
Court in F e ld e r v. H a r n e tt C o u n ty B o a rd o f E d u c a tio n , 409
F. 2d 1070, 1075 (4 Cir., 1969) that the plan there under
consideration did “not eliminate the possibility that what
ever feeder system is adopted to effect this transition will not
recreate a dual system at the high school level” and (2)
further evidences the school board’s awareness of, and intent
to comply with, the teachings of the decisions of this Court
in school desegregation cases.
The only other plan which would achieve the results of
the school board’s plan and honor the prescriptions of
S w a n n and D avis, as well as the command of A d a m s , would
be one which entailed assigning 90% of the black students
in Drew and I Tollman-Boston to other schools in the county

�14
main a l white, five other schools (Barcroft, Jackson, Nott­
l
ingham, Page and Tuckahoo) remain 99% white and two
schools (Key and Maury) remain 98% white. Thus, twelve
of the twenty-nine elementary schools in the county would
remain one-racc, or virtually one-race, schools under this
plan (App. 16, 38-39).
The appellants’
suggested plan for the desegregation of
Hodman-Boston i even more inadequate. It i the result
s
s
of “
hasty preparation”by Mr. Richardson, a witness for
the plaintids, and manifestly represents an cdort to bring
this case within the scope of Brice v. Landis, 314 F. Supp.
974 (W.D. Cal. 1969) by attempting to show that a reason­
able alternative to the school board’plan exists. It contem­
s
plates pairing Hodman-Boston with three other elementary
schools in the vicinity. While edectivcly desegregating the
Hodman-Boston Elementary School and the previously a l
lwhite Custis Elementary School, i makes no provision for
t
the Drew school which would remain all-black, nor for ten
of the eleven all-white, or virtually all-white, elementary
schools mentioned in the preceding paragraph, which
schools would retain their 98-100% white status (App. 17,
62-63).
Moreover, utilization of both of these plans simultaneously
would not discharge the school board’
s obligation to establish
a unitary system. Combination of the appellants’
suggested
plans would indeed eliminate al one-race black schools;
l
however over onc-third (ten of twenty-nine) of the county’
s
elementary schools would s i l remain 98-100% white. And
tl
no racial balancing of the county’
s elementary schools would
even be attempted, much less achieved. Obviously, even
i combined, the plans which appellants put forth as alter­
f
natives to the school board’plan (1) would not achieve
s
a unilniy system (2) would not eliminate a one-race,
ll

15
or virtually one-race, schools (3) would not achieve the
greatest possible degree of actual desegregation taking into
account the practicalities of the situation and, accordingly,
would not honor the prescriptions of S w a n n and D a vis
nor comply with the commands of A d a m s . It i also inter­
s
esting to note that 1,664 pupils would be bused under
these alternative plans which do not meet constitutional
standards, while only 704 pupils would be bused under the
school board’plan which docs meet these standards. If the
s
defendant school board had adopted both of the appellants’
suggested alternatives, we submit that i would have been
t
required, as were the various school boards in A d a m s , to
prepare a “
new”plan which would “ effect to S w a n n
give
and D a v is ” according adequate consideration to the “
by
use
of bus transportation and split zoning.”A d a m s , su p ra , at
100- 101.

In light of the legal deficiencies in the appellants’
suggested
alternatives and the demonstrated drawbacks of the “
90%
out 90% in”plan, i i difficult to conceive how the plan
t s
adopted by the school board can be said to be invidiously
discriminatory. In this connection, certain aspects of the
case at bar must be emphasized. First, this case does not
involve the clo sin g of any school, merely the c o n v ersio n of
facilities from one type of educational program to another.
Second, this case does not involve even a suggestion of “
white
flight,”and neither that term nor that concept was ever
mentioned by any party at any point in these proceedings.
Third, this case docs not involve any reluctance on the part
of the school board to assign and bus white children to
formerly all-black schools located in a l or predominantly,
l,
Negro neighborhoods. On the contrary, the record discloses
that a majority (70%) of white students have for yeais
been transported to the formerly all-black 1InlTmnn Iuslon
’

�16

17

Junior High School (JelTcrson Annex) located in that com­
pletely Negro residential area (App. 42). See, W a n n e r v.
C o u n ty S c h o o l H oard o f A r lin g to n C o u n ty , 357 F. 2d 452,
156 (4 Cir., 1966). Moreover, the plan adopted by the
School Board envisioned the enrollment of a majority of
white students in the model elementary school to be housed
in the converted Drew facility which i located in an alls
Negro residential area, and that feature of the school board’
s
plan i even now in effect. See, Brief for the Appellants, p. 7
s
.
Significant in this context, i the decision of this Court in
s
C h a m b e r s v. Ir e d e ll C o u n ty B o a r d o f E d u c a tio n , 423 F.2d
613 (4th Cir., 1970). Under consideration in that case was a
school desegregation plan in which one school, Unity School,
remained a l black with 285 students. That facility was to be
l
replaced the following school year by a new school which
was then under construction. When completed, the new
facility would absorb Unity’285 black students and some
s
475 white students from three other schools, at which time
the formerly all-black Unity School would be closed. Plain­
t f sthere alleged that the decision to close Unity was racially
if
motivated “
because i arose out of a disinclination to put
t
white pupils into a previously all-black school.” d ., at 616.
I
Rejecting this contention, this Court stated (423 F.2d at
616):
“
This contention i not persuasive in light of the fact
s
that the school board has already integrated Amity
School, which was previously all-black and i now twos
thirds white. There appears to be no pattern of simply
closing black schools because they have been black.”

school i not indicative of racial motivation when a school
s
board has integrated another previously all-black school in
the same system, then the mere conversion of a previously
all-black school to a different educational program and (he
enrollment of a majority of white students in that identical
facility, coupled with the previous assignment of a majority
of white students to another formerly all-black school, can­
not be said to be racially motivated.
Even more nearly in point and controlling i the decision
s
of this Court in A lle n v. A sh e v ille C ity B o a rd o f E d u c a tio n ,
434 F.2d 902 (4th Cir., 1970). In that ease, the Asheville
School Board decided that i was necessary to close two
t
formerly all-black elementary schools and one formerly a l
lwhite elementary school to achieve racial balance. After
plaintiffs objected to the proposed plan on the basis of the
closing of the two all-black schools, the school board modi­
fied the plan to provide for the continued operation of the
formerly all-white school, with the two formerly all-black
schools remaining closed. During the course of i s opinion,
t
this Court stated the plaintiffs’
objection to the plan and the
reason therefore in the following language (434 F.2d at 905,
906):
“
Able counsel for plaintiffs arc unable to fault the
Board’
s plan other than a complaint with respect to the
closing of two previously all-black schools and the im­
pact of their closing, in the context of the rest of the
plan, upon black students.

Similarly, in (he case at bar, the Arlington County School
Board long ago integrated the 1foffman-Boston Junior High
School “
which was previously all-black and i now twos
ihiids while.”We submit that i the closing of an all-black
f

*

*

*

“
Plaintiffs i s s , however, that the school board’true
nit
s
reason for selection i undisclosed and i simply i s ‘
s
s
t re­
luctance to send primary grade white children into
traditionally all-black schools located in all-black neigh­
borhoods.’
”

�19

18

Rejecting plaintilTs’
contention that the Asheville School
Board luil unfairly discriminated against black students in
the closing of the two schools there in question, this Court
enunciated the following principles governing such situ­
ations (131 F.2d at 905, 906):
In the f r t place, we think th e m e c h a n ic s o f in te g r a
is
tio n , where the purpose i obviously to implement the
s
B r o w n I I principle and effectively achieves that end, is
o r d in a r ily a m a tte r w ith in th e d isc re tio n o f s c h o o l a d
m in istr a to r s. T h e q u e stio n is n o t w h e th e r w e m ig h t h a v e
s e le c te d d iffe r e n t sch o o ls f o r e x tin c tio n , n o r e v e n
w h e th e r s u b s ta n tia l e v id e n c e s u p p o r ts th e B o a rd ’s d e c i
sio n , b u t is in ste a d w h e th e r th e B o a r d ’s d e c isio n is so
p la in ly u n fa ir th a t it c le a r ly a m o u n ts to in v id io u s d is
c r im in a tio n in v io la tio n o f th e e q u a l p ro te c tio n clause.
*

#

#

. .Moreover, the situation of which plaintiffs complain
.
cannot possibly be changed except at the cost of in­
creasing the transportation of pupils approximately 40
percent. T h i s is so b e c a u se i f th e tw o b la ck sch o o ls th a t
h a v e b een clo sed w e re r e o p e n e d , 70 p e r c e n t o f th e b la c k
s tu d e n ts fo r m e r ly in e a c h s c h o o l w o u ld h a v e to be
m o v e d o u t in to o th e r sch o o ls a n d th is 70 p e r c e n t re
p la c e d b y w h ite stu d e n ts .
*

#

*

I i urged upon us that even so, both schools that
t s
were closed are newer and physically better than most
of the other schools retained. W e agree that this i a
s
relevant factor. But neither alone nor in context docs i
t
establish invidious discrimination. Such a factor i only
s
one of many that enter into a school closing decision.
W e r e p e a t th a t w e d o n o t sit to re v ie w s ta te a d m in is
tr a tiv e d ecisio n s b e y o n d th e v e r y lim ite d rea ch o f th e
C o n s titu tio n . (Italics supplied.)

Similai ly, in the ease at bar, as previously pointed out, i
f
Drew and I lolfinaii-Uoston had been retained as traditional

elementary schools, or i they were reconstituted as such, 90
f
percent of the black students formerly in each school would
have to be moved out into other schools and this 90 percent
replaced by white students. Moreover, the purpose of the
school board’plan here i not merely to implement the
s
s
B ro w n I I principle, but also to implement S w a n n , D avis
and A d a m s . That the plan “
effectively achieves that end”
i acknowledged even by the appellants. Sec, Brief for the
s
Appellants, p. 19. In addition, the school board’
s plan i the
s
only demonstrably rational and practical plan that will
comply with the requirements of S w a n n , D a vis and A d a m s .
In C h a m b e r s , this Court expressed doubt that many
school systems had achieved a higher degree of integration
than then prevailed in Iredell County. Subsequently, in
A lle n , this Court stated that Asheville was “ or near the
at
pinnacle of arithmetical desegregation in America.” d ., at
I
903. So far as we arc aware, Asheville i sil n e a r the pin­
s tl
nacle of arithmetical desegregation in America; however,
we submit that a t the pinnacle of arithmetical desegregation
in America i Arlington County. Here again, i should be
s
t
pointed out that this distinction was achieved without closing
any school, while in the C h a m b e r s and A lle n cases, the all­
black facilities there under consideration were selected “
for
extinction” were removed from the public school system.
and
A lle n v. A s h e v ille C ity B o a rd o f E d u c a tio n , su p ra , at 905.
None of the cases relied upon by appellants derogates
from the principles enunciated in the C h a m b e rs and A lle n
cases. In F e ld er v. I l a r n e t t C o u n ty B o a rd o f E d u c a tio n ,
su p ra , the basis of this Court’decision was the complete
s
failure of the school board to disestablish an entrenched
dual school system in which only 4.3% of the black children
were attending previously a l white schools. Moreover, in
l
that case there was not the slightest assurance of achieving

�20

21

a unitary school system and the selection of the schools for
closing was therefore suspect. See, A lle n , su p ra at 006.
In G reen v. S c h o o l B o a rd o f C ity o f H o a n o k c , 316 F.
Supp. 6 (W.D. Va. 1070), the closing of the formerly all­
black high school there under consideration would have
caused overcrowding in the three remaining predominantly
white high schools in the city. In the face of this circum­
stance, no adequate reason was advanced by the school
board, in terms of i s desegregation plan or otherwise, to
t
justify discontinuance of the school in question
B rice v. L a n d is , 314 F. Supp. 974 (N.D. Cal. 1969) states
nothing to the contrary. In that case, the closing of a 99%
black school pursuant to the school board’
s plan would have
resulted in overcrowded classes and distorted pupil-teacher
ratios at the three remaining predominantly white schools
options, alternatives and
in the system. I d ., at 977. Other “
courses of action”
were available to the school board. I d ., at
970. Pointing out that a particular desegregation plan “
when
not reasonably required under the circumstances”
could be
discriminatory, the District Court observed (314 F. Supp. at
978):
“
Whether the plan, as here presented, i a good faith,
s
reasonably adequate implementation of constitutional
principles involved, m u s t be d e te r m in e d in th e lig h t,
among other things, o f th e a lte r n a tiv e o p tio n s a n d
co u rses o f a ctio n a v a ila b le to th e D istric t.” (Italics
supplied.)
Commenting upon this decision in A lle n ,
succinctly slated (434 F.2d at 907):

su p ra ,

this Court

“ e are advertent to Brice v Landis (N.D. Cal.,
W
.
Aug. 0, I960), 314 F.Supp. 974, which held on th e
p e c u lia r f a i l s of I h e case that the closing of a Negro
.&lt;l was invidiously disc iimiuutoi y and subject to ins iool

junction. W e t h in k it m e a n s no m o r e th a n I lint and
agree there may be such a ease, but think i i not this
ts
one. I f it is re a d to i m p ly th a t it is o r d in a r ily fo r th e
d istric t c o u rts to d e te r m in e w h ic h schools sh a ll be closed
r a th e r th a n fo r th e sc h o o l b o a rd , w e re je c t th e p r o p o
sitio n .” (Italics supplied.)

Even lessapposite i L e e v. A t a eo n C o u n ty B o a r d o f lu lu s
c a tio n , 448 F. 2d 746 (5 Cir., 1971). In that ease, the Court
of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit reversed a decree of the
district court which would have had the effect of leaving
over 45% of the school district’
s Negro students in all-black,
or virtually all-black, schools. I d ., at 748, 753. Moreover,
the justification advanced by the school board for the pro­
posed closing of two formerly all-black schools was (1) that
whites would resist going to school in facilities formerly used
by blacks, and (2) that otherwise white students would f]cc
the school system altogether. I d ., at 750, 754. In light of
these circumstances, the Court of Appeals directed the dis­
trict court to require the school board “
forthwith to consti­
tute and implement a student assignment plan that complies
with the principles established in S w a n n v. C h a r lo ltc -M e c k le n b u r g B o a rd o f E d u c a tio n .” I d ., at 753. In short, L e e i a
s
school closing, racially motivated, white-flight, non-unitary,
n o n -S w a n n school desegregation ease. Not one of the abovelisted considerations obtains in the ease at bar.
H a n e y v. C o u n ty B o a rd o f E d u c a tio n o f S e v ie r C o u n ty ,
429 F. 2d 364 (8 Cir., 1970) i equally inapplicable. In that
s
ease, the district court decreed the annexation of a small all­
black school district in the county by a larger all-white
school district and, in addition, decreed that the facilities
of the larger all-white school district would be utilized and,
only i these facilities proved inadequate, would those of the
f
formerly all-Negro district be used. There was nothing in the
record to explain the closing of the facilities fonneily used

�22

for ( i instruction of black students. After referring to this
le
Court’decision in the l u h l r r ease and B rice v. L a n d is ,
s
s u p r a , the Court of Appeals observed (429 l\2d at 372):
“ matter of utilization of available facilities i w i t h
The
s
in th e p r o v in c e a n d d isc re tio n o f th e sch o o l b o a rd .

There i a statement in the record that the class rooms
s
of the former Sevier District are not of sufficient size to
meet current state standards. These details, of course,
are subject to many variations and much can be done
within the existing framework of operation to suffi­
ciently utilize existing f
acilities. T h is is n o t a m a tte r fo r
c o u rt c o n sid e ra tio n b u t r a th e r sh o u ld be re so lv e d on
s o m e r a tio n a l n o n -d is c r im in a to r y basis b y th e lo ca l
s c h o o l b o a r d ." (Italicssupplied.)

Throughout their briefs, both appellants and amici curiae
make only glancing references to S w a n n , pay no respect to
A d a m s and do not even mention D a vis at a l Indeed, refer­
l.
ence i made to A d a m s only for i s one line affirmance of
s
t
the district court’retention of the Addison School in Roan­
s
oke; so far as appellants and amici are concerned, the rest
of what this Court said in A d a m s does not even exist. Thus
do they seek to avoid any consideration whatever of the
school board’clear obligation to eliminate one-race schools
s
and achieve the greatest possible degree of actual desegre­
gation as required by S w a n n , D a v is and A d a m s. Thus, too,
do they seek to insinuate that the school board in this case
can get by with something less than f l compliance with the
ul
commands of these decisions, even though f l compliance
ul
can be had, as demonstrated by the plan which the school
hoard adopted and put into effect last September and which
this Court and the Chief Justice of the United States refused
to enjoin.
In addition, both appellants and amici persist in pressing
the illusion that there “
may”be other plans which would

23
meet the prescribed constitutional standards. Sec Brief for
the Appellants, p. 17; Brief for Amici Curiae, p. 16. How­
ever, both arc careful to avoid staling that there “ ”
i such a
s
plan or informing this Court of the details, or even the
outlines, of such other plan. The reason for this equivocation
i quite obvious— both appellants and amici know full well
s
that there i no plan other than that adopted by the school
s
board which rationally and practically accomplishes what
this Court said in A d a m s must be done.
The assertion that the school board’plan unfairly bur­
s
dens the Negro students of Drew and Hoffman-Boston will
not bear scrutiny. For years pupils at these schools have
attended a “
walk-in”
facility and have not been required to
be bused (App. 48-49). If attendance at a “
walk-in”fa­
cility can be deemed a convenience, i i one which these
t s
students have enjoyed for years while thousands of other
children in Arlington County have been bused (App. 13).
To require them at this late date to forego this convenience
so that a racially balanced, unitary school system can be
established can hardly be considered unfair. This, we sub­
mit, i especially true when one remembers that the bus ride
s
they are asked to take i, on the average, only ten minutes
s
longer than the time i would take them to walk to the
t
Drew and Hoffman-Boston fa i i i s and the walk to those
clte,
facilities had to be made in a l weather conditions through­
l
out the school year (App. 39). Finally, while the Drew and
Hoffman-Boston students are now bused to other schools,
over 40% of the Negro elementary students in Arlington
County s i l attend their neighborhood schools (App. 15).
tl
In A lle n , a similar contention was rejected by this Court
in language subsequently deemed controlling and quoted at
length in M im s v D u v a l C o u n ty S c h o o l B o a rd , 329 F. Supp.
.
123 (M.D. Fla., 1971). In M im s , approving a desegregation

�24
plan which involved the closing of seven black elementary
schools, the district court observed (329 F. Supp. at 132133):
“ their second argument plaintiffs seek to have this
In
Court require the School Board to bus white children
to the core city for a l elementary grades, not just to
l
sixth grade centers, so to achieve equal busing of the
races. The United States Court of Appeals for the
Fourth Circuit resolved the same argument in Allen v.
Asheville City Board of Education [434 F.2d 902, 907
(4 Cir., 1970)] with these words:
W e arc asked to decide whether the district court, in
approving the plan, unconstitutionally placed ‘
the
burden of desegregation’
upon black pupils in the
school system. I i urged upon us that the plan ap­
t s
proved by the district court ‘
places an unfair, racially
discriminatory burden upon black children* in that
black children in grades 1 through 5 who previously
attended all-black Livingston and Herring Elemen­
tary Schools will be required to travel as much as five
or six miles in order to attend previously all-white
schools. This i said to be an unfair allocation of the
s
‘
burden’ integration, and i i suggested that the
of
ts
Constitution requires that an equivalent number or
proportion of white children in the same grades be
required to travel an equivalent distance to enter
schools outside their previous attendance zones.
W e hold that such a pattern of assignment imple­
mented by free school bus transportation docs not
violate the equal protection clause of the Fourteenth
Amendment.
The ra tio n a le in the Second Circuit i essentially the
s
same. In Norwalk Core v Norwalk Board of Education,
.
[123 F.2d 121, 124 (2 Cir., 1970)] the Court noted:
1‘
laiulilfs would &lt;liminate what they call unequal
treatment by having, in elfect, one while child bussed

25
out of his neighborhood for every black chili1bussed
out of his— in other words, deprive as many whites of
neighborhood advantages as blacks arc deprived by
being bussed to schools predominantly white. But the
problem i not as simple as a one black, one white
s
ratio. It i a question of the Board, with the facilities
s
available having ‘
acted in the utmost good faith, in a
nonarbitrary and deliberate manner, in order both to
insure racial balance and to provide high quality
education.’ * *”
*
Nor will i do to assert that the school board’plan sug­
t
s
gests to black children that i would be dangerous i “
t
f blacks
make up more than 15% o f the enrollment of any school.”
See, Brief for the Appellants, p. 15. This assertion i instantly
s
blunted by the fact that four elementary schools in Arling­
ton County already had black students in excess of 15%
when the school board’plan was adopted. Moreover, the
s
alternative arrangements for the Drew school espoused in
plaintiffs’ would limit black enrollment to 21% in each
brief
of the schools affected. Does this arrangement suggest that
any number of black students in excess of 21% in any school
i dangerous? Was any such message explicit or implicit in
s
the racially balanced plans approved by this Court in
C h a m b e rs and A lle n ? Neither, we submit, does the plan
adopted by the school board in the case at bar carry such
an inference.
It i,of course, primarily the obligation of the school board
s
to frame and put into effect a plan which establishes a uni­
tary school system, and, as pointed out in D a vis, su p ra at 37,
the “
measure of any desegregation plan i i s effectiveness.”
st
From B ro w n I I to A d a m s , the decisions confirming this
principle have been legion and consistent. As stated in B n a l
le y v. S c h o o l B o a rd o f C ity o f R ic h m o n d , 325 F. Supp. 121
51,
832-833 (E.D. Va. 1971):

�27

26
“ second principle guiding the Court— almost as ob­
A
vious as the doctrine of precedent— i that it is p r im a r ily
s
tin ' S c h o o l B o a r d ’s d u t y to ru n th e schools, a n d n o t th is
C o u r t’s n o r th e p la in tiffs ’ . . . Because both expertise

and responsibility arc the School Board’ i i to their
s ts
,
proposals that courts look f r t for a legally sulficicnt
is
plan. . . . When they assume the ‘
responsibility which
Brown II placed squarely on the School Board,’
Id.,
412, 88 S. Ct. 1696, c o u rts w ill n o t p re su m e to d ic ta te a
se le c tio n b e tw e e n
p la n s .” Wanner v.

e q u a lly

e ffe c tiv e

d e seg re g a tio n

County School Board of Arlington
County, 357 F. 2d 452, 436 (4th Cir. 1966). (Italics
supplied.)

Echoing these observations arc those of Judge Bryan in his
special concurring opinion in A d a m s , su p ra , at 102:
“ I think the only pattern the school authorities and
...
the Courts must observe i one honoring the prescrip­
s
tions of S w a n n and D a v is. So long as i i in keeping
t s
with these decisions, my understanding i that formu­
s
lation of a plan is e n tr u s te d to th e d isc re tio n o f th e
sc h o o l a u th o ritie s ...”
(Italics supplied.)
W e submit that in the case at bar the obligation resting upon
the Arlington County School Board has been fully dis­
charged by the adoption of a desegregation plan which
honors the prescriptions of S w a n n and D a vis, complies with
the commands of A d a m s , and i therefore constitutionally
s
valid.
CONCLUSION

In

v. N a s h v ille , A rk a n sa s, S p e c ia l S c h o o l D istric t
N o . 1, 101 F. 2d 137, 144 (8 Cir., 1969), Judge Blackmun,
speaking for a court which sustained the non-rccmploymcnt
of certain Negro teachers in a school desegregation case,
made the following observations:
W a lto n

“ e arc conscious in this case, as we have been in
W
earlier ones, that the process of school integration i not
s
easy and that there will be hurls and disappointments
as integration i accomplished. Certainly, under the
s
precepts of the B ro w n decisions, i has been too long
t
delayed at Nashville. B u t w e a re to ld th a t it lias n o w
b een f u ll y a c c o m p lis h e d th e re . T h a t fa c t s h o u ld be a
so u rce o f sa tis fa c tio n fo r a ll citize n s, w h ite as w e ll as
b la c k .” (Italics supplied.)

In the case at bar, this Court i also informed that inte­
s
gration has now been fully accomplished in Arlington Coun­
ty It i so informed by the plan i s l , which i currently
.
s
tef
s
before this Court and was adopted to carry out the following
policy of the school board (App. 40):
“ purposes that the board had was, f r t of a l pri­
The
is
l,
marily to eliminate a l vestiges of a dual system, to
l
move to establish a true unitary system throughout the
county, to provide and to establish racial balanced
schools, and I think, then, to get on with the primary
purpose of the school system which i the education of
s
young people.”
It i similarly informed by the appellants who admit that
s
the plan i one “
s
which unquestionably docs away with the
last vestiges of school segregation remaining from the legis­
latively imposed dual school system”and who further ac­
knowledge that i “ undisputed that the Arlington School
t i
s
Board has put into effect a plan that fully complies with the
primary mandates laid down in” ro w n , G re e n and S w a n n .
B
Sec, Brief for the Appellants, pp. 1 9.
,
Finally, this Court i so informed by the District Court in
s
the following language of i s opinion, 329 F. Supp. at 955t
956 (App. 14):
“ Arlington County School Board has now lolly
The
complied with the Supreme Court decision in Bnmu I

�*1
A unitary school m Mc iii as required by Green and
Alexander lias luvii cMablidied .\iliii:*l&lt;ui will liavo
neither black nor \\ bile schools jn.«.( schools.”
In light of tin* foregoing, and for the reason heretofore
slalod. we. submit that tlu* decision of the Dislirc.l C’otirL is
clearly eon eel and should he affirmed.

Respectfully submitted,
II S i m m o n d s
.
G r e c o k y U. E v a n s
1500 North Courthouse Road
Arlington, Virginia

Jam es
.

R. D. M c I l w a i n e , III

P.O.Box705 •
Petersburg, Virginia
C o u n se l fo r A p fic llc c s
C K t a 'i l 'I C A T K

I certify that two copies of the within brief for appellees
u'eio mailed, with f r t class postage prepaid, to S. W.
is
Tucker, L-quirc, 211 East Clay Sheet, Richmond, Virginia
2:1219; to Robert M. Alexander, Esquire, 2011 South Glebe
Road, Ailiuglon, Viiginia 22201; to Allison W. Brown, J .
r,
Esquire, Suite 501, 1421 Sixteenth Street, N.YV., Washing­
ton, 1 2 0 0 5 6 ; to Laurence J. Latin, Esquire, 734 Lif­
t r nth Stieel, N.W., Washington, l).C. 20005; and to Jack
e
Gre&gt; nbiirg, Iv-quire, Suite 2050, 10 Columbus Circle, New
Yoi I, \v York 10010, conn &lt;Ifor plainlilfs; and to William
1 . All' u, l equitr, and |ohn I. Jones, Jr., Esquire, BBS Six1
*
leu h
I N.'.V., W. hiiigi"ii, D.C. 20(.(‘ cm il.l for
,
!, l e
&gt;
;1 iii. i■■ . l ' i d.. i! . I’", 10/2.
1 1.
• ,I! O l j • ' ■*
&gt;
I’. ■). ; li f. V ■ .; , 'll
. :

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="4">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="87">
                  <text>RG 69, Arlington County Public Schools: Desegregation Materials</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
            <element elementId="41">
              <name>Description</name>
              <description>An account of the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="88">
                  <text>RG69 contains information related to the integration of Arlington County Public Schools including the history, redistricting, pupil distribution, and boundary maps. The collection was donated by Lisa Farberstein, Director of Community Service and Public Information for the Arlington County Public Schools</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="24241">
                <text>Cover page: United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit, No. 71-1791, John K. Hart, et al v. County School Board of Arlington County, et al, Appeal from the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia at Alexandria.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="24242">
                <text>Contents include Brief for Appellees, Issue Presented for Review and Statement of the Case. 16 pages.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="42">
            <name>Format</name>
            <description>The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="24243">
                <text>pdf</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="48">
            <name>Source</name>
            <description>A related resource from which the described resource is derived</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="24244">
                <text>RG 69, Arlington County Public Schools:  Desegregation Materials</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="39">
            <name>Creator</name>
            <description>An entity primarily responsible for making the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="24245">
                <text>United States Court of Appeals</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="38">
            <name>Coverage</name>
            <description>The spatial or temporal topic of the resource, the spatial applicability of the resource, or the jurisdiction under which the resource is relevant</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="24246">
                <text>1970s</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="47">
            <name>Rights</name>
            <description>Information about rights held in and over the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="24247">
                <text>This image is subject to copyright. Unauthorized use of the images in the Local History Collections of the Arlington Community Archives is prohibited.</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="43">
            <name>Identifier</name>
            <description>An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="24463">
                <text>69_3_1_13_2</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
  </item>
</itemContainer>
